Miriam Zivin

When silence turns to betrayal

When Silence Turns to Betrayal: Plano ISD, Antisemitism, and Political Apathy

Last month, I published a blog entitled “When Silence Hurts.” It spoke to the pain and frustration of Jewish parents in Plano ISD who have tried—often in vain—to get the attention of local and state officials about the rapidly growing antisemitism in their children’s classrooms. What started as a call for help has now become a glaring indictment: Our politicians have failed us.

They have failed Jewish families. They have failed Jewish students. And they have failed our schools.

Despite media attention and an outcry from the community, the concerns of these parents remain unanswered. Their pleas continue to fall on deaf ears. With each passing day, new stories emerge from classrooms in the district: of swastikas drawn in notebooks, of students emboldened to wear keffiyehs and shirts that read “Resist and Reclaim,” and of classroom materials and assignments that erase Israel from maps of the Middle East.

One of the most shocking incidents occurred in a social studies class where students were asked a Jeopardy-style question: “Group who wants to gain back the country they lost to Israel.” The answer, according to the teacher: who are the Palestinians.

This isn’t just ignorance. This is indoctrination.

Parents who’ve reached out—through emails, phone calls, and city council meetings—have been met with silence. Governor Abott is being briefed. Senator Ted Cruz, Senator John Cornyn’s offices initially reached out to gain knowledge but have since gone silent. Congressman Pat Fallon has never responded. Not one of these elected officials has stood up and said, “This is wrong.” Not one has issued a statement of concern or support. The message to Jewish parents and students is loud and clear: You are on your own.

In recent months, many families have even been hesitant to speak out publicly. Why? Because they fear retaliation. Attending a city hall meeting means your name and address go on record, potentially opening you up to online harassment or doxxing—something many Jewish families already worry about. Their silence is not complicity. It is fear.

Meanwhile, the district’s leadership continues to deny the depth of the problem. They issue vague statements about “equity” and “inclusion,” but refuse to acknowledge or condemn the specific and repeated targeting of Jewish students. Some teachers—either out of bias or fear—look the other way. Others participate. And the students, emboldened by this lack of accountability, continue to push the boundaries of hate.

This is not merely a Plano problem. It is a Texas problem. It is an American problem. And it should concern anyone who believes that our children deserve safe, inclusive, and bias-free classrooms.

Thanks to policies put in place during the Trump administration, the U.S. Department of Justice is now opening a federal investigation into Plano ISD. That alone should speak volumes about the severity of the situation. But even this investigation, while necessary, is not a substitute for leadership. Where are the voices of our Texas representatives demanding action, accountability, and transparency?

There is a new school year beginning, but the wounds of the last year haven’t healed. Instead, they’ve deepened. Students are returning to classrooms where they were previously harassed for being Jewish, where their identity was politicized or erased. Parents are sending their children back into buildings where educators have failed to protect them, and where elected officials have refused to intervene.

To those leaders who have remained silent—this is not just inaction. This is betrayal.

At a time when antisemitism is surging across college campuses, city councils, and social media, what happens in K–12 education matters more than ever. Hatred left unaddressed becomes normalized. Bias unchallenged becomes belief. And silence, in the face of injustice, becomes complicity.

Jewish families in Plano ISD are not asking for special treatment. They are asking for safety. They are asking for dignity. And they are asking for someone—anyone in power—to care enough to act.

If our elected officials cannot or will not answer that call, then it’s time to stop asking politely. It’s time to demand accountability. Because silence is no longer just hurting us. It endangers our children.

 

About the Author
Miriam Zivin was born in Canada and has spent significant portions of her life in Texas and Israel. After completing the last two years of high school in Israel, she volunteered and served in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF). Miriam earned a bachelor’s degree in elementary education from the University of Arizona in 1998, and in 2000 she obtained a master’s degree in early childhood special education from the University of Texas at Austin. With a passion for education, Miriam taught special education for 11 years and Hebrew language at Akiba Academy in Dallas, Texas, for six years. Additionally, she is a licensed educational diagnostician. As the mother of two university students, she has been actively involved in Jewish campus life across various universities. In response to the events of October 7, 2023, Miriam became aware of Mothers Against College Antisemitism (MACA), a grassroots movement that has evolved into a nationwide nonprofit organization dedicated to combating antisemitism on college campuses. Recognizing the importance of this mission, she became one of the founding members of the DFW MACA chapter, established in December 2024. This chapter has grown to include over 100 members who are committed to protecting and advocating for Jewish students in North Texas universities. The members of this group meet monthly, both in person and online, to strategize and implement initiatives that support Jewish life on university campuses. Miriam is dedicated to fostering a supportive environment for Jewish students and combating antisemitism, making significant contributions to the community through her work with MACA and beyond. Miriam is married to Mitchell Zivin, and is the mother of Ben (20) and Ella (18), both students at the University of Oklahoma.
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.