Mohamed Osman

Who Gets to Choose? Somalia’s Path to One Person, One Vote

A phased transition could give more Somalis a direct vote without leaving less secure regions behind.

Most Somalis have had no direct vote in choosing who sits in parliament. Direct elections promise to change that. But the dispute over the April and May 2027 election dates announced by the National Independent Elections and Boundaries Commission shows why a new voting system cannot simply be imposed. The Somali Future Council rejected the timetable, citing a lack of consultation. The deeper question is how to expand the right to vote while keeping communities represented where direct polling is not yet feasible.

Why Somalia still uses the 4.5 formula.

Somali delegates adopted the 4.5 formula at the 2000 Arta Peace Conference in Djibouti to share power after civil war. In the 275-seat House of the People, four major clan blocs receive sixty-one seats each, while a grouping of minority communities receives thirty-one. Under the indirect system, clan elders help select delegates, who elect lower-house lawmakers. The two houses of parliament then elect the president.

The formula gave rival groups a predictable stake in government and guaranteed some representation for communities long excluded from power. But it also limits their share and gives political brokers more influence than ordinary citizens. That is why even people who want to move beyond clan quotas may hesitate to give them up without enforceable protections.

What direct voting would change?

One person, one vote would make lawmakers answerable to a broader electorate and give parties more reason to compete on policies rather than clan ties. It would also make it harder to sway a race by buying votes from a small pool of delegates.

But a ballot is only meaningful if people can register, campaign, and vote safely. Insecurity makes that difficult in parts of Somalia. Without an agreed census or unified civil registry, registering displaced citizens and drawing constituencies would be contentious. Disputes over federal member state boundaries and how to account for the fictional seats allocated to the Republic of Somaliland would further complicate the shift. Any new system would also need safeguards for minority communities and a way to enforce women’s representation commitments, including the 30 percent quota that previous cycles fell short of.

A reformed indirect system is easier to run in fewer locations and can preserve guaranteed seats. Expanding electoral colleges would bring more people into the process, as Somalia did when it moved from 51 to 101 delegates per seat. But even a larger college is not a public electorate, and delegate selection can still be vulnerable to manipulation.

A phased approach, with a clear end date

Somalia does not have to choose between nationwide direct elections on a disputed timetable and another cycle of business as usual. It could hold direct elections in districts where registration and polling can be conducted safely, while using a more transparent, expanded delegate system elsewhere. For that compromise to work, the same agreement must explain where each method applies, who decides when a district is ready, and when the temporary arrangement ends.

Three commitments would make that transition credible:

  • Negotiate the rules before setting the dates. The federal government, the Somali Future Council, and all federal member states, including Puntland and Jubaland, should agree on who has authority during the transition. Women’s groups, minority communities, elders, and other civil society groups should have a voice in those talks and in the broader constitutional discussions over how federal and state governments share power.
  • Make the process open to scrutiny. Audit voter registration, make procurement decisions public, and invite independent observers. Where delegate voting continues, make the rules for choosing delegates public, too. Voters and candidates need to know who makes decisions and how those decisions can be challenged.
  • Protect voters without taking sides. Security forces should protect access to polling without favoring any faction. If talks stall, regional partners such as the African Union and the Intergovernmental Authority on Development can offer neutral mediation and help uphold an agreement Somali stakeholder have negotiated themselves.

A phased election would still give citizens unequal access to the ballot in the short term. That is precisely why it needs a deadline and public milestones. The test is not simply whether Somalia holds an election in 2027. It is whether each election gives more Somalis a direct say in who governs them without stripping others of representation along the way.

About the Author
Osman is a retired physician and public health specialist, originally from Somaliland and now a Canadian citizen. His career spans clinical practice, public health leadership, consulting, and health analytics. In addition to his healthcare work, he advocates for Somaliland’s international recognition and publishes commentary on related issues.
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.