Sharon Pardo

Who Gets to Decide Where Israel Belongs?

From Tel Aviv to Asia? (Picture by Sharon Pardo, May 2019)

I had just walked into a bakery in Tel Aviv when I heard the sellers talking about the Eurovision Song Contest Asia (ESCA). They were pleased that the Philippines had won. I told them I had expected Malaysia to take the title. One of them said the Philippine music scene was so rich. Then we realized that all of us had been following the same song contest in Bangkok.

The Philippines won the first Eurovision Song Contest Asia on November 14, 2026, with “Sobra-Sobra,” performed by Carmelle. Eleven countries competed at Bangkok’s One Bangkok Forum, and the Israeli Broadcasting Corporation – “Kan” – broadcast the final. What surprised me was how easily our conversation began. We were strangers buying bread and cookies, but we had something to share: music from across Asia.

Six months earlier, during the Vienna contest, it was reported that the European Broadcasting Union (EBU) had discussed moving Israel from the Eurovision Song Contest Europe to its new Asian competition. The report cited sources familiar with the discussions. One source said Israel’s location in Asia was a reason the idea had come up. The European Broadcasting Union said it was talking with additional broadcasters about joining the Asian event and that countries competing in Eurovision Europe could not also compete in Asia.

The next day, Eurovision director Martin Green denied the reports. Assaf Blecher, an Israeli producer and executive producer of Eurovision Asia, was equally direct in a later media interview. “As far as I am concerned, it cannot happen,” he said. Some participating countries, he added, “are not fans of Israel.”

The episode leaves us with a question that has followed Israel through international sport and culture: who gets to decide where it belongs?

In 1974, the Asian Football Confederation voted to bar Israel from its competitions. The vote was 17 to 13, with six abstentions. Israel’s football association became a full member of UEFA in 1994. The circumstances are different, but the echo is hard to miss: in 1974, Asia pushed Israel toward Europe; in 2026, a report said someone had suggested sending Israel back to Asia.

Geography is, obviously, part of the story, but it does not settle it. Israel is in Western Asia, while Eurovision membership follows a different map. The EBU’s rules are based on the European Broadcasting Area, a technical zone defined by the International Telecommunication Union, or on membership in the Council of Europe. Israel’s public broadcaster qualifies through the broadcasting area.

The Tel Aviv bakery conversation reminded me that Israelis can be interested in Asian culture without being assigned to an official Asian institution. I had picked Malaysia; the sellers were happy for the Philippines. We enjoyed the performances and discussed the result, even though we had different favorites.

There was an irony in our conversation. Malaysia and Bangladesh were among the countries represented in Bangkok, although neither has diplomatic relations with Israel. Malaysia lost the right to host the 2019 World Para Swimming Championships after refusing to admit Israeli athletes. Bangladesh restricts travel to Israel. Yet in a Tel Aviv bakery, we were cheering their singers.

Five countries boycotted Eurovision in 2026 over Israel’s participation, and viewing figures fell by 35 million. Israelis have asked Europeans to separate artists from their governments’ policies. In the bakery, we did exactly that for Aina Abdul, Malaysia’s singer. The principle has to work both ways, or it is only a complaint.

That is one reason the contest makes an interesting story about soft power. Eurovision began as a European project, and the EBU helped bring its format to Asia. But the performers and songs came from the participating countries. Carmelle did not win by sounding European. She brought a Philippine song to a wide audience, and viewers around the world voted for her.

There is also a question about who shapes this new version. The European contest grew out of public broadcasting. The Asian edition is organized by commercial broadcasters. Is it a meeting between audiences and musical cultures, or a European format being sold in new markets? It could be both. What matters now is whether the participating broadcasters and artists will help shape the event, or simply appear within a format made elsewhere.

I don’t remember the score. I remember the sellers praising Philippine music, and how natural it felt to share an interest in a contest from so far away.

Israel does not always get to choose which stage others think it belongs on. But we can choose what we pay attention to, and how we treat the people whose music we hear. We can stay close to Europe and grow more curious about Asia. Those connections can exist side by side.

In that bakery, the Philippines, Malaysia, and Israel were all part of the same conversation.

About the Author
Professor Sharon Pardo is a Senior Fellow at the Jewish People Policy Institute (JPPI) and a professor of European studies and international relations in the Department of Politics and Government at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev (BGU).
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.