Ed Gaskin

Why Rebuilding Gaza Never Brings Peace: It Can’t Be Rebuilt With Concrete Alone

Series Introduction

Is Jesus the Solution for Gaza? Offering the Trump Plan for GRACE?

Is Jesus the Solution for Gaza? Offering the Trump Plan for GRACE?

In a Washington Times editorial, Jonathan Feldstein—an Orthodox Jewish Israeli—posed a question many found jarring, provocative, or even inappropriate: “Is Jesus the solution for Gaza?”

For some readers, the question was dismissed immediately. For others, it felt offensive or dangerously naïve. Yet Feldstein was not proposing conversion, nor was he advancing a missionary agenda. His argument was far more disruptive—and far more serious.

He was arguing that military force, political agreements, and reconstruction money alone cannot heal Gaza, because they do not address what decades of violence have destroyed at the deepest level: moral boundaries, human dignity, and psychological capacity for coexistence. Without some form of moral reconstruction, he warned, Gaza would remain trapped in cycles of extremism and despair—no matter how many buildings are rebuilt.

In the months since Gaza was devastated yet again, the global conversation about “rebuilding” has followed a familiar script. There are debates about ceasefires and security, aid flows and governance, borders and buffer zones. There are donor conferences and reconstruction plans, each promising that this time will be different.

And yet history tells a harsher truth: every major effort to rebuild Gaza has failed to deliver lasting peace or stability.

This ten-part series takes Feldstein’s question seriously—not as theology, not as evangelism, and not as a slogan or silver bullet—but as a thought experiment in public moral leadership.

It asks a different, parallel question:

What if a serious reconstruction effort treated moral repair, trauma healing, and dignity as essential infrastructure—rather than optional extras?

And it asks that question in a specifically American political context.

If John F. Kennedy could create the Peace Corps, mobilizing young Americans to serve abroad in the name of national purpose;
if Bill Clinton could create AmeriCorps, channeling civic service into domestic renewal;
then it is reasonable to ask:

Why couldn’t President Trump do something similar—by mobilizing Christians who feel a genuine calling to serve both Palestinians and Israelis through humanitarian service, accountability, and reconstruction?

Not as missionaries.
Not as political operatives.
But as builders, caregivers, engineers, teachers, trauma counselors, and monitors—helping ensure that reconstruction funds are used for humanitarian purposes, not diverted back into violence.

That question lies at the heart of what this series refers to as Trump’s Plan for GRACE:
Gaza Reconstruction and Community Empowerment.

The idea is not that religion replaces politics, or that faith “solves” geopolitics. It is that large-scale civilian service—when rooted in moral seriousness, strict humanitarian guardrails, and accountability—has historically succeeded where governments alone have failed.

This series argues that moral and psychological reconstruction are not soft concerns. They are hard requirements for security, coexistence, and any future worth defending—especially for Israel. Healing is not charity; it is security policy. Service, not domination, is the foundation of any peace that can endure.

Across ten columns, this series explores that “what if” by drawing on trauma science, post-conflict history, interfaith ethics, Israeli security concerns, and economic realism. It asks why past reconstruction efforts have repeatedly collapsed, what they systematically ignore, and what a more durable approach might require.

A basic but unavoidable question runs throughout: how do we prevent some of the billions sent to rebuild Gaza from ending up purchasing weapons for the destruction of Israel?

The goal is not to sentimentalize Gaza, excuse violence, or minimize Israeli security needs. It is to confront an uncomfortable truth: a shattered society next door will never be neutral, and ignoring that fact guarantees more bloodshed, not less.

Whether one agrees with Feldstein’s provocation or not, dismissing the question outright is a luxury history does not afford.

If Gaza is to be rebuilt in a way that does not collapse again, we may have to ask not only how to rebuild—but what kind of moral architecture any lasting peace would require.


Why Rebuilding Gaza Never Brings Peace

It Can’t Be Rebuilt With Concrete Alone

Every few years, after the fighting stops and the rubble settles, the world returns to a familiar ritual: pledges to rebuild Gaza.

There are donor conferences and reconstruction plans, engineering assessments and aid commitments, all promising that this time will be different—that stability will follow once homes are rebuilt, infrastructure restored, and humanitarian needs met.

And yet it never does.

Gaza has been rebuilt before. More than once. Each time, the cycle resumes. That failure is not accidental. It is structural. And it begins with a mistake we keep repeating.

We rebuild what can be measured and photographed, while ignoring what war actually destroys first.

Wars do not only flatten neighborhoods. They fracture trust, harden identity around grievance, erode moral boundaries, and leave trauma untreated. When those deeper wounds are ignored, reconstruction becomes cosmetic. The surface changes, but the underlying dynamics remain intact.

This is not a claim about ideology or religion. It is a claim grounded in psychology, history, and hard experience across conflict zones—from Northern Ireland to Bosnia, from Iraq to Afghanistan.

Trauma Is Not a Side Effect. It Is the Environment.

In Gaza, trauma is not episodic. It is ambient.

Children have grown up knowing airstrikes before they know stability. Families have experienced repeated displacement, loss, and fear. Entire communities have learned that tomorrow is uncertain, authority is unreliable, and violence can return at any moment.

Under these conditions, trauma does not remain an individual mental-health issue. It becomes social infrastructure. It reshapes how people interpret threats, how they understand dignity, and how they imagine the future.

Trauma narrows imagination. It rewards absolutism. It makes compromise feel like betrayal and restraint feel like weakness. It does not create extremism on its own—but it allows extremist narratives to grow organically, without needing to be taught, especially among the young.

Rebuilding roads and power lines without addressing that reality is like repairing a dam while ignoring the pressure building behind it.

Why Money and Plans Are Not Enough

International reconstruction efforts tend to focus on what institutions can deliver quickly: housing units, water systems, electricity, food aid. These are essential. No serious person disputes that.

But material reconstruction alone assumes something that is rarely true after prolonged violence—that once basic needs are met, societies naturally return to trust, cooperation, and civic life.

History suggests otherwise.

In post-conflict societies where trauma goes unaddressed, rebuilt infrastructure often becomes contested terrain rather than shared space. Schools reopen, but education remains disrupted by fear. Housing is restored, but resentment festers inside it. Aid flows, but dignity does not.

When that happens, reconstruction unintentionally stabilizes the conditions for the next collapse.

Rebuilding structures without rebuilding moral and psychological capacity does not prevent violence—it merely postpones it.

Why This Matters for Israel

For Israelis, this is not an abstract humanitarian concern. It is a security reality.

A Gaza that remains psychologically shattered—even if physically rebuilt—will continue to generate instability, radicalization, and recurring violence. Walls, surveillance, and deterrence can manage that reality, but they cannot resolve it.

Israel has repeatedly demonstrated its military capacity to defeat armed groups. What no army can do is heal trauma, restore dignity, or rebuild moral boundaries inside another society. And yet without those elements, military success never translates into lasting calm.

This is not a question of generosity or guilt.
It is a question of whether the next war is merely postponed—or meaningfully prevented.

A neighbor trapped in despair does not become safer with time.

The Question We Keep Avoiding

The uncomfortable question is not whether Gaza can be rebuilt. It has been rebuilt before.

The question is whether we are willing to rebuild what war actually destroys first:
the inner lives of people, the social fabric of communities, and the moral frameworks that make coexistence imaginable.

Until reconstruction efforts take those dimensions seriously—treating healing, dignity, and moral repair as essential infrastructure rather than optional extras—every new plan will look different and end the same way.

If Gaza is rebuilt without addressing trauma, dignity, and moral collapse, the outcome is not peace—it is preparation for the next war.

In the next column, we will look more closely at trauma itself: how it reshapes identity, fuels extremism, and why ignoring it is not compassion, but strategic negligence.

About the Author
Ed Gaskin attends Temple Beth Elohim in Wellesley, Massachusetts and Roxbury Presbyterian Church in Roxbury, Mass. He has co-taught a course with professor Dean Borman called, “Christianity and the Problem of Racism” to Evangelicals (think Trump followers) for over 25 years. Ed has an M. Div. degree from Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary and graduated as a Martin Trust Fellow from MIT’s Sloan School of Management. He has published several books on a range of topics and was a co-organizer of the first faith-based initiative on reducing gang violence at the National Press Club in Washington DC. In addition to leading a non-profit in one of the poorest communities in Boston, and serving on several non-profit advisory boards, Ed’s current focus is reducing the incidence of diet-related disease by developing food with little salt, fat or sugar and none of the top eight allergens. He does this as the founder of Sunday Celebrations, a consumer-packaged goods business that makes “Good for You” gourmet food.
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.