WTF, Chuck? You Knew When Biden Had to Go. Now It’s Your Turn.

There is a time to come and a time to go, and smart people know the difference. Some lose track of the time. President Joe Biden did. He should never have run for a second term. His accomplishments convinced him he had earned the right to run again. Perhaps he had. But earning the right to run doesn’t mean earning the right to win. No politician is ever owed anything by the electorate.
New York Senator Chuck Schumer, who was then Senate Majority Leader, knew what time it was when he personally urged Biden to step aside in 2024. Schumer is now in a similar place. He has served his party well, but the question is no longer what he has accomplished. It’s whether he is still the person Democrats need leading the Senate.
Schumer deserves considerable credit for the Democrats’ success in Senate elections, including their recent return to the majority. He’s a hardworking senator, a skilled negotiator, and a good man. He could leave leadership a winner and remain an effective senator. But I suspect that, like Biden, he feels he’s earned the right to stay. His colleagues may agree. Unlike Biden, Schumer doesn’t have to face the national electorate to retain his leadership position. His Democratic colleagues decide that. But the voters those senators need to reach are another matter. I have yet to speak to anyone I know in the Democratic Party who believes he should remain.
Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland is challenging Schumer for the leadership role. Van Hollen is my senator. I voted for him, I respect him, and I’m glad he represents me. I’ve listened to his speeches and admired his command of the issues. But admiration isn’t inspiration.
And that’s the problem.
Van Hollen is proposing a different approach to running the Senate, and I give him credit for challenging the party establishment. But managing the Senate requires a different skill set than being a compelling public voice. I’m not confident Van Hollen reaches the public outside of Maryland.
The Democratic leader has two responsibilities. One is to manage legislation while holding the caucus together. The second takes place outside the Senate. The leader explains why the stance of the party matters to a public whose political consumption is about four minutes a week. Senate managerial genius doesn’t guarantee explanatory success with the general public.
Van Hollen’s speeches have sometimes informed me of new frames from which to see things. He’s adept at explaining an issue, not to mention he’s likable. But can he make people in Texas care about an issue? I don’t think so. This assessment doesn’t question his seriousness, integrity, or commitment to public service. But do such qualities make someone a national voice for a political party? No.
I want Chris Van Hollen representing me in Maryland. Whether I want him speaking for Senate Democrats nationally is a different question. His challenge to Schumer doesn’t, by itself, answer it.
Senator Tammy Duckworth of Illinois is the personality type we need today. The electorate knows her as a no-nonsense combat veteran who lost both legs in Iraq. The public has heard her speak with authority grounded in experience.
Senator Duckworth effortlessly connects public policy to people’s lives without sounding like she’s giving a Senate speech. Senator Elissa Slotkin of Michigan has some of those same qualities. Van Hollen has command of the nation’s challenges, but Duckworth is better at framing why they matter to the public. That’s what I’m looking for in a Democratic leader.
I’m not sure who we should hope to have as Senate Majority Leader. Van Hollen may offer a different direction for the Senate. I’m just not convinced he represents a different enough voice for the country. But I am sure this is no longer the time for Senator Schumer to be Senate Majority Leader. Most people under 60 do not look at Chuck Schumer and see someone they want leading the Senate.
Schumer has always struck me as a humble, likable man. The type of person I’d love to sit next to while waiting for anything. But humility means knowing when it’s time to leave, not just knowing when someone else should. He understood that Biden’s accomplishments didn’t entitle him to another term, recognizing that Biden’s time had passed. Why can’t he recognize when his own has?
Wtf, Chuck?
