Isaac Steven Herschkopf

“Yes, I Signed Up For This!”

“Kol Yisroel Aravim Zeh Bozeh!” – “We are all responsible for each other!” – Shavuot, 39 A

Over the course of my life, I have come to detest certain expressions.

If, when lecturing, a question begins “With all due respect…”, what follows is neither a question, nor respectful.

If someone asks: “Do you want me to tell you the truth?”, they are going to insult you, despite your saying “No, thank you.”

Though it’s less personal, the phrase I despise the most is “I didn’t sign up for this!” It declares, in no uncertain terms, I am unilaterally abrogating our relationship, with my friend, relative, spouse or even my own child.

Two prominent examples:

In 1966, playwright Arthur Miller, “The conscience of his generation”, was blessed with a son, Daniel. He did not consider him a blessing. Upon discovering Daniel had Down’s Syndrome, Miller institutionalized him. He didn’t sign up for that.

Not only didn’t he ever visit him (until shamed into doing so four decades later, shortly before dying, by his son-in-law Daniel Day Lewis), but he hid his very existence to everyone, even in his “No-holds-barred” autobiography.

Miller’s most famous creation, Willie Loman said: “You can’t eat the orange, and throw the peel away! (I am) not a piece of fruit!”

Apparently, his son was, because Miller did.

Willie’s most famous quote is: “There were promises made!”

Miller didn’t keep them.

Yet, Miller was Atticus Finch compared to Joe Kennedy.

Kennedy didn’t merit Dante’s ninth level of hell because he was a Jew-hating Nazi sympathizer, keeping the US out of WWII, warning Hollywood’s Jewish producers, if they denigrated Hitler, they’d be deported back to Germany. (That only earned him the seventh level.)

What earned him the nadir was his treatment of his eldest daughter Rosemary, who was both cognitively impaired and disobedient. He didn’t sign up for that.

Concerned she’d embarrass the family, jeopardizing his presidential ambitions for his sons, when she was 23, he had her lobotomized without telling his wife her family. While awake, a butter knife, inserted into her brain, kept scrambling it until she became incoherent.

He returned home to inform his family she was no longer a member of it, and should never be referred to again, the implicit threat being, if you disobey me as she did, I can do the same to you.

20 years later, in what Dante termed Contrapasso, the perfect divine punishment for a particular sin, Kennedy himself was rendered incoherent by a stroke. When told that his sons who acquired or aspired the presidency, JFK and RFK, were successively assassinated, he could only wail.

Only after his stroke, did Rosemary’s siblings discover where she was institutionalized so they could visit her. Only eight years after that, when Kennedy himself died, could she visit them.

My friend Elie Wiesel once presciently warned me it is only when adversity strikes that we discover who our friends are, i.e., who signed up for this, and who didn’t.

We ourselves are forced to address that question throughout our lives:

When my father was terminally hospitalized, recognizing neither me nor himself, do I still visit him nightly after work? “Yes, I signed up for this!”

When my former Dean, living alone, was stricken with dementia, do I still regularly take him out to dinner? “Yes, I signed up for this!”

When my mother was institutionalized, responding to any question in Hebrew “Kacha, Kacha” (a language she never spoke while lucid), do I continue traveling every weekend to see her? “Yes, I signed up for this!”

When my friend was overwhelmingly criticize and ostracized, do I reach out to him to let him know I remain his friend? “Yes, I signed up for this!”

When my classmates were dying of cancer, do I continue calling them weekly to reminisce, laughing together again? “Yes, I signed up for this!”

When my wife was, post-surgery, bedridden for a month, do I wait on her hand and foot, emptying her bed-pan and anything else necessary?  “Yes, I definitely signed up for this! In sickness and in health!”

When my daughter was being incessantly bullied on her European summer program, am I willing to get on the next plane to personally confront her abusers unless it immediately stops? “Yes, I signed up for this!”

When her sister experienced a Traumatic Brain Injury rendering her unable to open her eyes or speak for months, am I willing to sit at her bedside for hours, holding her hand on her regular visits to the emergency room? “Yes, I signed up for this!”

Perhaps part of my reasoning is, to quote the eminent 20th-century philosopher Lawrence Peter Berra, “If you don’t go to their funeral, they won’t come to yours.”, but most of it is, these precious relationships are precisely what I signed up for.

The book of Deuteronomy is named for its opening phrase “These are the words.”

In chapter 31, verse 8, the book’s words are “God will never abandon you. Don’t be frightened or lose hope.”

In other words, no matter what happens to us, God signed up for this.

I sometimes ponder how to define the omnipresent, yet amorphous term “Love”?

As good an answer as any is “Yes, I signed up for this!”

 

 

About the Author
Son of survivors, Yeshiva University H.S., Queens College (Phi Beta Kappa), NYU School of Medicine (medical school and university Valedictorian.) Attending physician, Teaching faculty NYU School of Medicine (retired), Great Teacher, Alumnus of the Year Awards, Chair Sesquicentennial, President Alumni Association, Founding Chairman NYU Bellevue Psychiatric Alumni. Chatan Torah Park East Synagogue. Served on boards: [IADAF] International Drug Abuse Foundation, Ramaz, Lincoln Square Synagogue, [FASPE] Fellowships Auschwitz Study Professional Ethics. Married five decades, father, grandfather.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.