Shmuel Legesse
A Call to the Moral Debate the World Refuses to Face — A Black Jewish Voice Speaks for Israel and Global Jewry

A Light Unto Nations Must Shine Through All Its Voices

Foreign Minister Gideon Saar speaks to journalists as Israeli Ambassador to the UN Danny Danon looks on ahead of a UN Security Council meeting on the hostages and the Gaza war at the UN headquarters on August 5, 2025, in New York (Photo by Angela Weiss/AFP)
Foreign Minister Gideon Saar speaks to journalists as Israeli Ambassador to the UN Danny Danon looks on ahead of a UN Security Council meeting on the hostages and the Gaza war at the UN headquarters on August 5, 2025, in New York (Photo by Angela Weiss/AFP)

As an Ethiopian, Black, African Jew, I view Israel not only as a homeland but as a moral idea, a living story of justice, resilience, and renewal. Yet in the global arena, Israel’s diplomacy too often fails to reflect that moral depth. The Jewish State possesses immense strengths: technological innovation, strategic alliances, humanitarian outreach, and an unshakable partnership with the United States. But it also suffers from deep weaknesses: fragmented coordination, a reactive narrative, and limited representation of diverse Jewish voices, especially from African and Ethiopian backgrounds.

If Israel seeks to defend its legitimacy and restore its moral authority, it must transform how it conducts diplomacy. The next stage of Israeli statecraft must be grounded not only in power, but in values of inclusivity, credibility, and moral leadership.

Israel’s diplomatic base remains strong. Its alliance with the United States is one of the most enduring and bipartisan in modern history. The Abraham Accords opened unprecedented relations with Arab states, reshaping Middle Eastern diplomacy. Israeli humanitarian missions from earthquake relief in Turkey and Haiti to medical aid across Africa reveal a compassionate face that too often goes unnoticed.

Israel also wields enormous soft power through innovation. The “Startup Nation” reputation gives it credibility in cybersecurity, agriculture, health, and climate resilience. In a world hungry for technology-driven solutions, Israel’s creativity can serve as a bridge between nations divided by politics.

Yet despite these achievements, Israel’s diplomatic narrative remains narrow and defensive. Instead of presenting a forward-looking moral vision, Israel spends too much energy reacting to its critics. Its public diplomacy “hasbara” focuses on justification rather than inspiration. Younger and progressive audiences in the West are unmoved by arguments of security alone; they respond to authenticity, inclusivity, and shared values.

A deeper flaw runs through Israel’s diplomatic corps itself. The institutions that represent Israel abroad rarely reflect the diversity of Israeli society. Ethiopian and African-origin Jews, who embody resilience, faith, and the ancient connection to Zion, remain almost invisible in Israel’s embassies, think tanks, and public forums. This exclusion weakens Israel’s credibility. The world, especially Africa, the Global South, and multilateral bodies, watch who speaks for Israel. When Israel presents only one cultural profile, it narrows its message and alienates potential allies who might otherwise see themselves in its story.

In today’s multicultural and identity-driven world, diversity is not a gesture of tokenism—it is a strategic necessity. African-origin diplomats could help Israel reconnect with a continent where the Jewish people have ancient spiritual ties and moral allies. From Addis Ababa to Accra, from Nairobi to Johannesburg, leaders admire Israel’s innovation but struggle to see themselves reflected in its representatives. That gap is not about race, it is about resonance.

Israel’s engagement with Africa and the Global South remains episodic, focused mainly on security or temporary aid. These efforts save lives but rarely build long-term trust. Africa is no longer a peripheral region; it is the world’s moral frontier and demographic engine. By 2050, one in four people on Earth will be African. Ignoring that reality is a strategic failure.

Israel can build enduring partnerships through technology, education, and shared moral purpose—especially by elevating the voices of Black and Ethiopian Jews who embody both African identity and Jewish heritage. These voices tell a universal story of survival and faith. They can serve as bridges of diplomacy, translating Israel’s message into a language of inclusion, dignity, and shared destiny.

To rebuild its moral and diplomatic strength, Israel must launch a bold reform agenda.

First, create a National Council for Global Diplomacy to coordinate the Foreign Ministry, Prime Minister’s Office, Jewish Agency, and civil-society initiatives. Today, these institutions operate in silos, duplicating efforts and diluting impact. A unified strategic body would ensure coherence and continuity.

Second, invest in moral and digital diplomacy—training a new generation of diplomats, including Ethiopian, Mizrahi, and other minority voices, to engage global audiences through digital media and moral storytelling. In the 21st century, diplomacy is fought on screens as much as in embassies. Israel’s envoys must shape hearts, not only policies.

Third, expand Africa partnerships beyond counterterrorism. Establish regional centers for technology, agriculture, and education across the continent, led by diverse Israeli teams who understand local cultures and values. Building on Israel’s expertise in water, health, and innovation, such centers would generate goodwill and long-term influence.

Fourth, strengthen interfaith and Jewish–African alliances that revive the moral bridge between Israel’s narrative and the global struggle for justice. Linking the Exodus, Zionism, and Africa’s liberation movements can remind the world that Israel’s story is not colonial, it is universal.

The late Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks (z”l) often said that Israel’s purpose was not only to provide safety for Jews but to give moral meaning to the world. To fulfill that purpose, Israel’s diplomacy must mirror the moral and cultural richness of the Jewish people.

As an Ethiopian Jew, I carry within me both Africa’s rhythm and Israel’s faith, both Jerusalem’s vision and Addis Ababa’s endurance. Israel can only speak with moral authority when all its voices are heard and represented.

The time has come for Israel to move beyond hasbara, beyond explanation, and toward inspiration. A nation founded on freedom must also model inclusion. When Israel’s diplomacy reflects not just its strength but its conscience, it will not need to defend its existence. The world will see its truth in the diversity of its messengers.

To reclaim its global voice, Israel must practice the same moral courage abroad that built it at home: unity amid difference, conviction without arrogance, and faith expressed through service. Power may win wars, but only moral clarity wins hearts.

When Israel leads not only with innovation but with inspiration, not only with strength but with soul, it will fulfill the prophetic promise that made it unique among nations and a light unto the world.

About the Author
I am a Black Ethiopian Israeli Jew, a scholar, diplomat, and upcoming author of Moral Diplomacy for a Broken World. I am calling on CNN, BBC, Sky News, Fox News, SBN, and Piers Morgan to host a public debate that includes the voices they have consistently ignored: Black/African/Ethiopian Jews/Israelis. The world hears endless commentary about Israel but almost never from those of us who represent Israel’s true diversity. It is time for an honest, global, moral debate about Israel’s identity, the nature of Zionism, the plight of Jewish communities worldwide, and the truth about who the Jewish people really are. For too long, media panels have portrayed Israel through a narrow racial and political lens. I challenge the international networks to include me in a live debate not as a token voice, but as a representative of millions of Jews of color whose story refutes the false accusations of colonialism and exposes the real moral complexity of this conflict. This is not a political manifesto but a moral movement: a call for peaceful, educational debate grounded in respect, evidence, and human dignity. Please contact me for peaceful, educational debate: educatordrshmuel@gmail.com With wisdom inspired by Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks, Dr. Legesse reminds readers that Judaism is not a religion of division, but of unity; not of power, but of purpose. Dr. Shmuel Legesse is an international educator, community activist, and diplomacy expert. He has served in the Israeli police force and worked as a detective for the Supreme Court of New York. He represented Israel's Knesset in international public affairs and holds a master's in community leadership and philanthropy from Hebrew University and a doctorate in international Educational Leadership and Administration from Yeshiva University, NY. educatordrshmuel@gmail.com
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.