Charlotte Mendel

A Protective Presence Shift: Children and Elections

I am trying to write these blogs in chronological order and I am getting near the end of my story, but I am too pissed off by the recent Israeli election not to mention it.

My siblings were glued to their TVs/devices last week, waxing jubilant over the Democratic sweep in the US. But for me, jubilation is reserved for something unexpected, and the economy is a dependable vote-predictor. Inflation caused by tariffs and wars hurt the pockets of Americans, and their differences about immigrants and trans suddenly weren’t so important. Money trumps all, and trumped Trump.

Thus it is with most countries; money rules. Except in this country.

“Isn’t it good that Israel has values apart from money?” asks a sibling.

Not if their “values” are based on racism. The short-sighted stupidity of anyone who voted for Bibi after October 7 is only surpassed by Carney’s short-sighted stupidity about the climate crisis.

I spent a couple of weeks manning booths, attending rallies, trying to persuade people to abandon Bibi. There was one huge demo in TA, where the mothers of the hostages and dead of October 7 got up on the stage and demanded an investigation into how the massacre happened—something Bibi has blocked because it would prove he received warnings that Hamas was planning something and didn’t bother to update his own military.

Packed in like sardines in the midst of that huge crowd, yelling “Shame! Shame!” I felt for a moment that we were the majority. Human beings rejecting the horrific results of a terrible leader. Democracy at its best; granting power to the people to overthrow megalomaniac leaders, as demonstrated in the US last week. “Shame! Shame!” I screamed, energized, sure that the misery of my Bedouin family was finite. A new government might not dismantle illegal settlements, but it would stop illegal violence.

But Tel Aviv is another bubble, like the West Bank. I was wrong. The anti-Bibi bloc got more votes in total, but not enough to form a government. So they’ll have to make a coalition, either with the Arabs—who came out in record numbers to vote—or the Haredim. Plus ça change…

It is a quiet day in the West Bank. I sit with Baby Yosef on my knee, placid and happy as usual. His four-year old sister Anie plays with Ahsan, one of her brothers. As always, it is a rough male game, as Anie is the only girl among 5 boys. The ‘game’ involves knocking each other to the ground and rolling around—weird antics performed globally by both men and puppies with great energy and aggression and no identifiable goal or purpose.

Ahsan focuses only on the battle, but Anie, repeatedly knocked to the ground, keeps looking at Yosef to see if he’s laughing. The difference between men and women in a nutshell. Inevitably, Anie’s head bashes against the floor sufficiently to send her screaming in the direction of her mother and the game ends.

Sometimes Anie tries to engage me in play, but I can’t stand it. Partly because during any down-time I want to conserve my energy, not play. Mostly, because I got played out after 20 years of motherhood and I find kids boring and limited and don’t have a clue why others seem to like them.

Eytan comes in, energy emanating in waves as he yaks on his phone and greets us all simultaneously. A large group of settlers are constructing something new near the house of another Palestinian we protect, and he wants to go and check it out. As always, I am happy to go in the car and escape the unpleasant face-to-face encounters with the settlers.

We cruise along, then Eytan suddenly slows down. “On your right. See them? They’re building something. Take a bunch of photographs. Faces if you can.”

I’m crap at taking photos but I snap steadily in the hopes that some will turn out OK. The settlers see us and 10-15 run towards the car, surrounding it. Hostile, angry faces peer at us through the windows.

Eytan phones the police as a settler pounds on his door. I see my old friend Nehoriah with his puppy eyes and wave at him excitedly. Then I see Pinchas! I haven’t seen him for weeks; not since he sat with me to explain his perspective for over an hour (apparently the only justification you need for ethnic cleansing is God saying, ‘You will inherit the land and live in it’). I hammer on the window, grinning broadly. I pull the letter I wrote in response to his perspective from my pocket (Godly quotes extolling peace) and indicate that I want to give it to him. He motions to open the window.

I turn to Eytan. “Can you open my window? I have a letter for Pinchas.”

“We’re under attack!” he bellows at me.

“Yes,” I say, though that hadn’t quite registered, “but could you just open the window a sliver so I can pass the letter out?”

Eytan refuses, and I indicate to Pinchas that Eytan is an idiot (not the first time I forget whose side I’m on).

I continue to nag, until Eytan explodes, “Be quiet! I’m on the phone with the police!”

“Just open the window and I’ll shut up,” I insist. “I’ve been carrying this letter for weeks; I must give it to him.”

Eventually frustration conquers prudence and Eytan cracks open the window. I push my letter out, and Pinchas takes it. Eytan closes the window so fast he almost catches my fingers.

Pinchas unfolds the letter, but another settler grabs it and starts to read it out loud; then a third settler snatches it and in the tussle the wind catches the letter and impales it on a branch. The hostile, angry faces are all laughing, transformed from threats to young boys. They scuffle in much the same way Anie and Ahsan did earlier. They abandon our car and walk back the way they came.

I notice that Pinchas retrieves my letter from the branch and puts it carefully in his pocket before he leaves.

About the Author
Charlotte Mendel was born in Nova Scotia and lived in Israel for 10 years. She is the author of 3 literary fiction novels and one Young Adult book. She is also a parent, a farmer, a teacher and an environmental activist. Charlotte is currently volunteering with Protective Presence in the West Bank.
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.