Danny Shapiro

Anti-Arab Racism: A Five-Alarm Fire for Israeli Democracy

Israel is facing a decisive turning point in its future as a Jewish and democratic state.

“Ra’is al-Knesset”: Right-wing publication Olam Katan portrays newly elected Knesset Speaker Matan Kahana as an Arab puppet for winning with the support of Arab MKs.

For decades, Israel and its supporters around the world have vigorously pushed back against accusations of apartheid by pointing proudly to the full citizenship and political rights of our Arab minority, and to their representation in the Knesset, the judiciary, government, and virtually every sphere of Israeli life. That has been the cornerstone of Israel’s defense against its critics—the proof that Israeli Arabs and Jews enjoy the same voting rights, and that their elected representatives participate fully in our democratic institutions.

“The only democracy in the Mideast!” was the rallying cry.

Today, we are witnessing a vicious campaign to delegitimize Arab political participation. Arab votes are being portrayed as illegitimate, Arab members of Knesset as supporters of terrorism, and Jewish politicians who cooperate with them as traitors.

The question is no longer simply how much racism Israeli society is prepared to tolerate. It is whether a substantial part of the Jewish public is prepared to abandon one of the most basic principles of democracy: that every citizen’s vote counts equally.

We are approaching a point of no return. Liberal democracy is not some optional feature of the Jewish state, or merely an ideal cherished and romanticized by part of its population. It has been indispensable to our defense and security, our extraordinary economic growth, our vibrant cultural and intellectual life, our social cohesion, and our legitimacy not only in the eyes of the world, but in our own eyes as well. Without that democratic foundation, the modern Israel we have built, with all its remarkable achievements, could never have existed.

One Outrage After Another

When Matan Kahana was elected Speaker of the Knesset with the support of Arab MKs, the Netanyahu-led right-wing poison machine went berserk. It called his election an “eternal disgrace,” and the familiar accusations came pouring out: the new parliamentary majority depended on tomchei terror, “supporters of terrorism.” Shlomo Karhi complained that Kahana had been elected despite having a “Jewish majority against him,” while Bezalel Smotrich accused him of choosing “Arabs over Jews.” The right-wing publication Olam Katan called Kahana Ra’is al-Knesset ‒ using the Arabic title associated in Israeli discourse with Yasser Arafat ‒ to make the insult and threat unmistakable.

And then there is Shira Shapira, the mother of Aner Shapira, one of the extraordinary heroes of October 7 who died defending people sheltering from Hamas terrorists at the Nova music festival, repeatedly throwing grenades back out of the shelter where they had sought refuge. Because Shira, now a member of Knesset, supported Kahana’s election, Likud MK Amichai Chikli personally sent her a social media post accusing her, in effect, of betraying her fallen son’s memory by cooperating with Arab MKs. Shira responded with extraordinary dignity, saying she was not asking for immunity from criticism as a bereaved mother, but that there was something particularly cruel about setting a mother against her fallen son and presuming to speak in his name. Chikli did not apologize; he said he had sent the post to reflect the feelings of the national camp.

Five years ago, Benjamin Netanyahu was courting Mansour Abbas, the leader of the Arab Ra’am party. Bibi and his allies were perfectly capable of explaining why cooperation with Arab politicians was legitimate when they thought it might help them remain in power, and the web is full of video clips of them making precisely that case. The cynicism is breathtaking.

While it is emotionally satisfying to dwell on this hypocrisy, something much more dangerous is happening. The racism that Netanyahu and his political machine have been exploiting and legitimizing is already deeply rooted in Israeli society, and the evidence shows it has become considerably more widespread. An Israel Democracy Institute survey found that in 2019, 36% of Jewish Israelis supported encouraging Arab citizens to emigrate from Israel; by 2025, that figure had risen to 53%. Support among Jewish Israelis for including Arab parties in government also declined, from 35% in 2021 to 27% in 2025. Meanwhile, FakeReporter documented a staggering 428% surge in anti-Arab rhetoric in just two days following the October election. This was no spontaneous outburst. Netanyahu and his allies were among the principal drivers of the campaign, spreading baseless accusations of electoral fraud, portraying Arab citizens as enemies, and fueling demands to restrict their voting rights. Netanyahu’s own claim that the election had been stolen attracted some 1.2 million views. The online poison machine was operating at full throttle.

Netanyahu’s long-term strategy is to effectively disenfranchise Israel’s Arab citizens and thereby ensure permanent right-wing rule. Not by taking away their right to vote, but by making their votes politically illegitimate. Exclude 15–20 Arab seats from the calculation, and it is impossible for the opposition to assemble a 61-seat majority. That’s the trap.

Bibi’s Long Game: Ensuring Permanent Right-Wing Rule

Netanyahu’s long-term strategy is to effectively disenfranchise Israel’s Arab citizens and thereby ensure permanent right-wing rule. Not necessarily by taking away their right to vote, but by making their votes politically illegitimate.

The calculation is simple. A government needs a majority of 61 seats in the Knesset. But if the 15–20 Arab seats are automatically excluded from any legitimate governing majority, the center and center-left must somehow assemble 61 seats from the remaining 100–105. That makes forming an alternative government impossible. That is precisely the political trap Netanyahu and his allies are trying to create. We are watching it play out right now.

And this is no longer just about political delegitimization. Some on the right are already openly calling for restrictions on Arab voting rights. What begins as an attempt to invalidate Arab political influence could ultimately become an attempt to deny Arab citizens the vote itself.

This Didn’t Start with Bibi, and It Won’t End With Him

Netanyahu did not invent anti-Arab racism, and it would be a terrible mistake to assume it will disappear when he leaves the political stage. He has exploited it, nurtured it, and given it political legitimacy, but its roots run much deeper. Some of those roots lie in the very real history of the Arab-Israeli conflict—decades of war, terrorism, and bloodshed that have left many Jewish Israelis with deep suspicions and fears. Others lie in an increasingly influential form of extreme Jewish religious nationalism, which regards Jewish sovereignty as a divine imperative and democratic equality as a threat to Jewish supremacy that must be rejected. Ben-Gvir is its most notorious purveyor, but he is hardly alone. Defeating Netanyahu and confronting the racism he has helped legitimize are two very different challenges.

The Cancer of Occupation is Metastasizing

For decades, the Israeli left has warned that we cannot maintain an apartheid-like regime in the West Bank while preserving liberal democracy within Israel itself. We cannot deny millions of Palestinians political rights while Jewish settlers living alongside them enjoy full Israeli citizenship, and expect that inequality to remain neatly contained beyond the Green Line. The warning was never only about what the occupation was doing to Palestinians; it was also about what it would eventually do to us. A society accustomed to one set of rights for Jews and another for Arabs cannot simply switch that mindset off at the Green Line. The Greater Israel movement, long intertwined with extreme religious messianism, has long placed Jewish sovereignty above democracy, and its influence has spread from the political margins into the mainstream. Now we are seeing its underlying logic applied inside Israel itself, as the political rights of Arab citizens are increasingly challenged. The cancer has metastasized.

Israel’s Legitimacy Is at Stake, Abroad and at Home

Israel is already facing an extraordinary crisis of international legitimacy. Its relationship with the United States, particularly with Democrats and younger Americans, has deteriorated dramatically, and its standing in Europe has suffered enormously.

This is also a disaster for Diaspora Jews. Already confronting rising antisemitism, Jews abroad face growing pressure to answer for policies they neither support nor control, while younger generations increasingly distance themselves from a country whose values they no longer recognize as their own.

Now, precisely when Israel desperately needs to rehabilitate its international legitimacy, its political leadership is undermining one of the strongest arguments we have ever made in Israel’s defense: that Arab citizens enjoy equal political rights and that their votes count just as much as Jewish votes. What are Israel’s supporters around the world supposed to say when the principle of equal citizenship is being openly challenged, when Arab political participation is increasingly treated as illegitimate, and when anti-Arab racism is becoming normalized across substantial parts of Israeli society?

No “hasbara” geniuses will be able to explain this away, because it is impossible to “spin.” This is a moral crisis of the highest order—an existential threat to Israel’s legitimacy, not only in the eyes of the world, but in our own.

The very foundations of Israel as a Jewish and democratic state are being undermined from within. We have to stop it.

About the Author
Danny Shapiro has lived in Israel since 1980. Over a 35-year career, he worked in public affairs, fundraising and strengthening ties between Israel and Jewish communities around the world, including senior positions at several major Israeli institutions. A progressive Zionist, he writes about Israeli politics, democracy, Zionism, and Israel's relationship with the United States and the Jewish world. He lives in Tel Aviv and publishes regularly on Substack.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.