Combating Antisemitism: Reframing or Reclaiming?

Antisemitism is a growing concern in the United States, challenging the very fabric of American society. As an Israeli observing this issue, I see a critical dilemma: should American values be reframed to be more inclusive, or should there be a return to the traditional values that have long defined the nation? This dilemma is well-articulated in the recent article by Eran Shayshon and David Bernstein, “The Big Dilemma in Combating Antisemitism: Reframing or Reclaiming American Values?”.

One approach to combating antisemitism is to redefine what it means to be American. This involves promoting a broader cultural shift towards inclusivity and diversity. By embracing a more inclusive definition of American identity, we can create a society where Jewish identity is protected and celebrated. This approach, however, comes with its own set of challenges. It requires significant cultural change and may face resistance from those who are wary of altering traditional values.

Alternatively, we can combat antisemitism by returning to the core American values of liberty, equality, and justice. These values inherently oppose antisemitism and can serve as a strong foundation for our efforts. By reinforcing these principles, we can remind society that antisemitism has no place in America. However, this approach also has its challenges, as it may be perceived as politically charged or insufficiently inclusive.

The fight against antisemitism is not just a cultural battle; it is also deeply political. There is a fear that any message against antisemitism might be politicized, potentially alienating parts of the community. This fear can hinder the development of a unified, effective strategy. It is crucial to navigate these political waters carefully to ensure that the message remains focused on combating hate and promoting unity.

Creating a single, consensus message for the Jewish community is a daunting task. The community is diverse, with varying political, religious, and cultural perspectives. While it may be challenging to find common ground, it is not impossible. A unified message can be powerful, but it must be carefully crafted to respect the diversity within the community.

Perhaps the most effective strategy is a combination of both approaches. By reframing American values to be more inclusive while simultaneously reclaiming the core values of liberty, equality, and justice, we can create a comprehensive approach to combating antisemitism. This dual strategy can address the issue from multiple angles, making it more robust and inclusive.

The fight against antisemitism in the United States is complex and multifaceted. While there may not be a single “right” answer, a combined approach that includes both reframing and reclaiming American values offers a promising path forward. It is essential for the Jewish community to engage in open dialogue and collaboration, both within and outside the community, to effectively combat antisemitism and promote a more inclusive and just society.

As we move forward, let us remember that the strength of our community lies in its diversity and resilience. By working together and embracing both new and traditional values, we can create a future where antisemitism has no place in America.