Anchelle Perl

Don’t Wait for Tragedy to Bring America Together!

Photo Credit Schneur Perl November 2001

America Needs a 9/12 Without a 9/11

September 11, 2001, was a day of unimaginable horror and loss. But those who lived through it also remember something remarkable about the next day.

On September 12, America felt different.

Flags appeared everywhere. Strangers spoke to one another. People donated blood, thanked firefighters and police officers, checked on neighbors and called family members just to say, “I love you.”

For a brief time, we were not primarily Republicans or Democrats, liberals or conservatives, or people of different races, religions and backgrounds.

We were Americans.

Twenty five years later, we should ask a hopeful question:

Can we recreate the spirit of 9/12 without first experiencing another 9/11?

Can we rediscover unity without tragedy, patriotism without fear and friendship without crisis?

The America of September 12 was not united because everyone suddenly agreed. We were united because we remembered that what connected us was greater than what divided us.

We desperately need that reminder today.

Patriotism should be more than waving a flag. It should mean caring about the people who share this country with us.

Visit a lonely senior. Help a struggling family. Thank a veteran or first responder. Donate blood. Mentor a child. Introduce yourself to the neighbor whose name you somehow never learned.

Love of country should include love of neighbor.

Perhaps September 12 could become an annual **Day of American Friendship and Good Deeds**, when every American is challenged to perform one deliberate act of kindness for someone outside his or her immediate circle.

We also need to relearn how to disagree.

America’s problem is not disagreement. Democracy requires disagreement. The danger is contempt, when people with different opinions stop seeing each other as fellow citizens and begin treating each other as enemies.

We need to recover a simple sentence:

“I disagree with you, but I still respect you.”

Imagine neighborhood dinners on September 12 with one rule: no politics for the evening.

Instead of asking, “Who did you vote for?” ask, “What brought your family to America?” Ask what someone loves about this country, what their parents sacrificed and what they hope America will be for their grandchildren.

We might discover that behind the political labels are people who love their children, worry about their families, struggle, celebrate, mourn and dream just as we do.

We should also renew our appreciation for freedom.

America has never been perfect, and patriotism should never require ignoring our failures. But neither should our failures erase the extraordinary freedoms we enjoy.

A mature patriotism can say:

America has not always lived up to its ideals, but those ideals are worth protecting and pursuing.

Freedom also requires responsibility.

Freedom of speech gives us the right to speak. Citizenship asks how we use our words.

Democracy gives us the right to vote. Citizenship asks whether we can respect someone who voted differently.

Religious freedom allows us to worship. It should also inspire us to become better neighbors.

And perhaps America’s renewal begins with something surprisingly simple:

Meet your neighbor.

We have hundreds of online connections yet sometimes do not know the person living three houses away.

National unity will not begin in Washington. It begins across the backyard fence, around the dinner table and in the way we speak to one another.

The same applies online.

Before posting an angry comment, ask: Would I say these words if this person were sitting across my kitchen table?

For one day, let September 12 become a day of digital civility. Don’t insult. Don’t ridicule. Instead, thank someone, honor a veteran, celebrate a teacher, recognize a first responder or share a story that makes people feel hopeful about America.

One good deed may seem small. It isn’t.

One phone call matters. One apology matters. One invitation matters. One respectful conversation matters. One decision not to spread anger matters.

Government can address many problems, but Congress cannot legislate friendship. No president can order neighbors to care about one another.

That work belongs to us.

So let September 11 remain a solemn day of remembrance.

And let September 12 become a day of recommitment.

Fly the flag. Perform a good deed. Meet a neighbor. Thank someone who serves. Give charity. Invite someone different from you to your table. Put down the political weapons for a day.

Then, before going to sleep, ask:

What did I do today to make America a little kinder?

And on September 13, do it again.

We should not need another tragedy to remember how precious America is.

We should not need buildings to fall before walls between people come down.

We should not need an enemy attacking America before Americans remember that we are friends.

Twenty five years after 9/11, perhaps one of the greatest tributes we can offer is to reclaim the best of 9/12.

Not unity born of tragedy, but unity born of gratitude.
Not patriotism born of fear, but patriotism expressed through service.
Not friendship because we are under attack, but friendship because we are Americans.

We will always remember 9/11.

Now let us reclaim 9/12, and this time, make the feeling last.

About the Author
Rabbi Anchelle Perl is the Director of Chabad of Mineola, Long Island, New York, and serves as a chaplain for the Nassau County Correctional Center and NYU Langone Long Island Hospital. He is a commissioner on the Nassau County Human Rights Commission and hosts the weekly “Jewish Talk” program on 90.3 WHPC.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.