Herzog’s grand coalition: Here’s how to get there
The only stable government in Israel will be one that includes both Eisenkot and Netanyahu. They will both have to put aside their demonization of the other’s side, including the personal demonization of Netanyahu. Neither of them is showing the maturity to do this.
Only President Herzog is acting maturely on this. He is calling on them to put aside their petty campaign attacks on each other – and implicitly, for Gadi to put aside his deference to the media’s personal attacks on Netanyahu – so they can get on with forming a coalition government.
Of the three, Herzog alone is acting as a statesman. The others should learn from him.
Fortunately, he could all but force them to do this.
How Herzog can do this
Under the Basic Law, the president can select any Knesset member who might best assemble a viable majority, not just the leader of the largest faction or with the most endorsements.
Herzog should proceed to do exactly that. If (when) Eisenkot fails, he should charge a leader of a third party, one who shares the goal of forming a grand coalition – perhaps Naftali Bennett – to do so.
This would all but compel Bibi and Gadi to grow up. Nothing else, it appears, is going to do it. The instinct of the polemics seems too great.
Bennett might be prime minister, Eisenkot and Netanyahu deputy prime ministers, with a written agreement on terms, e.g.: major decisions made by their consensus; if one dissents, decision by a defined supermajority of the cabinet; a Basic Law amendment that protects both deputies from dismissal and requires their consent for dissolving the Knesset. Neither Bibi nor Gadi would thereby concede that the other had won.
It is probable that Herzog will have to issue an amnesty to Netanyahu in order to clear the air of the threat to throw Bibi into jail almost the moment he loses power. That threat, which is itself a threat to democracy, obstructs a coalition. It is at the root of Bibi’s countermeasures against the judiciary, and of the Bibi-threats to Israeli democracy that Gadi references when rejecting cooperation.
Learning from America’s Parallel Experience
We have been through this kind of ruinous demonization-politics in America too. Our media and our Democrats massively demonized a series of presidents in my lifetime, with devastating effect. They provide us some lessons.
- They demonized President Nixon. They never forgave him for having in fact correctly identified Alger Hiss as a Soviet agent; instead they called this a McCarthyite slander and pictured him as an impending fascist dictator. They created a national hysteria about a campaign illegality that was comparatively small – Watergate – but convinced the “street” that it was such a threat that Nixon felt it best to resign and let America calm down. In retrospect, the hysteria was the truly dangerous part. It overturned an election, and with it, the mutual respect among parties for election results – the informal constitution that makes the American formal Constitution work. The damage to U.S. foreign policy was colossal. So was the damage to the American operational constitution – and it remains.
- They tried the same thing against President Reagan. Their attacks didn’t stick; they bitterly called him the “Teflon president” for that. It was only when they had conclusively failed that they stopped demonizing Reagan as an incipient fascist and as a person who wanted to start a nuclear war. After he left office, they pretended to have liked him all along.
There was even the same assassination chic that we have heard against President Trump, and a similar near-successful assassination attempt. That chic is not harmless: a fan base for assassins weakens restraints on them and promises attackers applause afterward.
- They talked of impeaching Ford when he pardoned Nixon, and turned a public majority against him for it. Fortunately Americans gradually accepted the pardon as right; Ford got the 2001 Profile in Courage Award for it.
They are now doing the same against President Trump – finally with grains of evidence for it this time. It is still done primarily by a dangerous entrenched group habit of disrespecting elections they lose (a habit now mirrored by Trump, also dangerously). It’s part of the habits and biases that have earned this class the distrust of a supermajority of Americans.
The take-away: this is not a series of accidents but a recurrent tendency of a predominant subculture – the legacy media, intelligentsia, and academia. It recurrently pits the dominant discourse space against honest conduct of the liberal democracy.
Lessons for Israel
Israel suffers much the same class bias in its mainstream media. For a deep reason: It is run by the same class, a class deeply connected to global Western mainstream journalism.
The more leftward parties tend in Israel, too, to be swept up in the hysterias promoted by the mainstream media. How could they not? It benefits them.
Gadi needs to mature out of joining in this. Bibi needs to mature beyond responding to this with his own constitutional threats.
It is a high order to ask of them, psychologically. But simple steps today could enable it in practice. Herzog could pardon Bibi. His PM-designate could require Bibi to put aside his intolerable constitutional demands. These two steps would give Bibi and Gadi the space they need to stop hurling insults and instead mature enough to form a grand coalition.
And only that can save Israel from much worse outcomes at this time.
