Senator-elect El-Sayed, Why Single Out Israel Now?
An open letter by Mansoor Hussain Laghari
Dear Senator-elect El-Sayed,
In 1948, Israel’s founders proclaimed a Jewish state and pledged equal social and political rights to its inhabitants regardless of religion, race or sex. They put both commitments in the same declaration. At The Atlantic Summit, you said Israel should uphold equal rights and should be a country that “does not identify itself with a culture or a faith.” I agree with you on equal rights. I condemn your call for Israel to give up its Jewish identity.
Jewish, Muslim, Christian, Druze and Baháʼí citizens of Israel already share the same right to vote in national elections. A Muslim voter’s ballot carries exactly the same weight as a Jewish voter’s. Israeli citizens of every faith can seek public office. Those rights belong to Israelis today, under the flag with the Star of David.
If you believe a particular law treats Israeli citizens unfairly, name the law. Tell us who is harmed and what remedy you propose. I take discrimination seriously enough to want those details. What I have yet to hear is how removing the Jewish character of the state would improve the life of a single Israeli citizen.
I grew up in Sindh, in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. I celebrated Diwali and Holi with my Hindu neighbors. I also learned what it costs when religious authorities presume to decide who belongs. So let me put the question to you as one Muslim to another. Would you stand in Islamabad and ask Pakistanis to take “Islamic” out of their country’s name? Would you make the same argument in Saudi Arabia, Iran and Egypt? Would you deliver that speech before the 57 member states of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation? My Jewish brothers and sisters deserve to know whether your standard travels beyond Jerusalem.
There is something more at stake here than a name or a flag. When a Jewish family faces persecution abroad, Israel’s existence means there is one country where Jews themselves have the authority to open the door. For centuries, Jewish families depended on governments that could withdraw their welcome overnight. Israel’s Law of Return put the decision about Jewish refuge into Jewish hands. Senator-elect, who do you believe should hold those keys?
I went to Israel as a Muslim from Sindh and an American veteran. I stood at the Western Wall and walked the Nova festival grounds. What stayed with me was the welcome I received from Israelis who knew exactly who I was. I came home calling Israel my second home. Nobody asked me to become less Muslim to belong at their table. I owe my Jewish brothers and sisters the same respect.
You spoke of self-determination. So let me ask you plainly. Do the Jewish people have the right to exercise it in their ancestral homeland?
My answer is yes. I stand with Israel as a Jewish and democratic state. And I will say so as proudly in Islamabad as I would in Jerusalem.
Am Yisrael Chai.
Mansoor Hussain Laghari
U.S. Army veteran and founder of the Global Youth Unity Project

