I Appreciate You – We need to tell our evangelical friends while we still can
Two weeks ago I wrote that American Jews have lost their influence in American politics. For the most part, and no matter how we feel about it, the truth is that electorally, we don’t matter anymore.
Vis-a-vis Israel this can pose a long term disaster (as I pointed out).
The silver lining is that we could say, at least we still have the evangelicals.
There is only one problem.
We don’t anymore.
And you don’t have to take it from me. Take it from Bishop Robert Stearns.
Stearns is not a critic of Israel and he is not a pundit. He founded an organization called Eagles’ Wings and has spent decades building Christian support for Israel. He runs the Global Day of Prayer for the Peace of Jerusalem, which draws millions of Christians around the world. He is one of the biggest supporters of Christian Zionism.
Days after the midterms he told the Jerusalem Post that Israel can no longer count on evangelical support. He said the younger generation is “formed within an entirely different cultural and media reality.” He said the next Israeli government needs a long term national strategy aimed at young Christians, and that the period right after this election is “an invaluable window of opportunity.”
When the man whose life’s work is this alliance starts using the word window, the window is closing.
Various polls show that support for Israel among young evangelicals (18-29) is less than half of what it was in 2018, and nothing since suggests it has gone back up. This is the new reality.
I mentioned in a previous post how evangelical parents need to teach the next generation about the reason for supporting Israel, but Bishop Stearns is correct. It is not only his job, it is ours, and we are failing at it.
It gets worse. Then there is the part no one is talking about.
It is not only that young evangelicals are leaving their religion. There are fewer evangelicals.
White evangelicals were 24 percent of the electorate in the 2022 midterms. 23 percent in 2024. This month, 17 percent. Americans with no religion at all were 27 percent, and climbing.
So the pie is shrinking and the young people inside it are walking out at the same time. Those two lines do not have to go much further before the thing we keep calling our strongest support in America is a rounding error.
Do the math. It is not looking good.
Stearns says the Israeli government has to step up. He is right, unfortunately it won’t, and even if it wanted to it would be bad at it. The Israeli government does not know these people. There is nobody in that coalition who can talk to a 22 year old in Tennessee.
I read that 74% of people have never even met a Jew. I wonder how many Jews have had real conversations with an evangelical Christian.
When I was still in business I had two Christians who were major parts of my life and success. One was a business partner for over 30 years (we both asked our spiritual advisers if we could go into business together, not knowing beforehand; they both said yes) and the other helped build my sales team.
They were, and still are, some of the most honest and hard working people I know. During the war I heard from almost none of my acquaintances, but they reached out every few months to tell me they were thinking about me and praying for me.
Honestly, it brought me a lot of comfort.
We also need to be more truthful about the relationship we have actually had.
We took the votes. We took the lobbying. We took the busloads of pilgrims who kept Israeli tourism alive through two intifadas and a pandemic. We took the congressmen who voted our way because their churches told them to.
Then most American Jews voted against them on every domestic issue there is.
We assured each other that they only like us because of the End Times. The truth is it is a small percentage that believe that. Most believe the Jews are important because of what God says to Abraham in Genesis 12:3 (which we read a month ago): “I will bless those who bless you, and him who curses you I will curse; and in you all the families of the earth shall be blessed.”
There is also another important reason. In Genesis 17 God gives the land to Abraham and his descendants as “an everlasting possession.” Everlasting is a long time. If God can walk back a promise He called everlasting, then none of His promises are safe. For them (and us) the land is not a policy position. It is an eternal promise from God.
For sixty years they regularly showed up for us, and most of us never said thank you. We never once bothered to explain to our own children, or to theirs, why any of it mattered.
Their kids are now getting their history from the same places ours are. TikTok, a professor, a comment section. Nobody from our side ever really went and made the case to them on a personal level, person to person.
So here is my question, and it is not rhetorical.
What exactly is the plan?
When evangelicals are down another five points and the ones under 30 are gone, who is left? Us? There are fewer than 8 million of us in the USA and that is a VERY LIBERAL NUMBER AT BEST.
We are about 2 percent of the country. We will barely matter going forward.
I don’t have a program, but what I know is that this one is not Bibi’s or any other Israeli politician’s to fix, and blaming the Israeli government is the easy way out of a conversation we should have had in 1995. The people who can reach young evangelicals are American Jews who are willing to engage with evangelicals.
That is a low bar, and I am willing to do my part.
After reading that 74% of people have never met a Jew, I asked myself: would it make a difference if they did?
I think it would. I wanted to start something called “Ask the Jew” and set up a table in Times Square and take any question whatsoever, as long as it was not coming from a malicious place. After thinking about it more I realized that might be a good way to get killed.
I am willing to talk to any group of any size. I am in a unique position. I am the American born son of Holocaust survivors who understands why the USA is the greatest country in the world, and even though I still believe that, I was willing to move to Israel. I am observant and can answer basic questions concerning Judaism, and without bragging, I know a lot of Jewish history.
I am willing to do this on Zoom or travel someplace, at my own expense, to meet in person.
I know most people may not be willing to do this, but as Bishop Stearns says, there is a window now that won’t stay open forever.
If possible, I want to do my part. If anyone has the ability to help me take this further, let me know. I am extremely serious about this.
I remember that some of my Christian acquaintances and friends would sometimes say “I appreciate you.”
The first time I heard it, I thought it was weird. Who says that? I lived in New York, where saying that would cause dirty looks at best. At worst, a punch to the face.
I think that in the future, if you meet a Christian supporter of Israel, it would be appropriate to say “I appreciate you.” It is the least we can do.
