Jill Szoo Wilson
Nothing is ever just one thing.

Is Jesus Still Jewish?

Olive trees on the Mount of Olives at sunset, looking west across the Kidron Valley to the Old City of Jerusalem. (Canva)
Olive trees on the Mount of Olives at sunset, looking west across the Kidron Valley to the Old City of Jerusalem. (Canva)

Ask most Christians whether Jesus was Jewish, and they’ll say yes. Ask whether he still is, and the room goes quiet.

Many Christians treat his Jewishness the way they treat a birthplace. He was born into a Jewish family, kept Jewish customs for thirty-odd years, and then started something new. On that reading, the Jewishness was the setting. The faith is what came after.

The New Testament doesn’t read that way. It keeps naming him by his family and his tribe long after the crucifixion, in the letters, in the visions, and in the last chapter of the book.

This would be an interesting question in any century. It’s an urgent one in this one. I write from the United States, where antisemitism is widespread and more people are saying so out loud. The share of Americans who endorse six or more anti-Jewish tropes on the ADL’s long-running index has more than doubled since 2019, from 11 percent to about 24 percent.

Christians are part of that number. Many churches fight antisemitism hard, and mine is one of them. Even so, antisemitic beliefs tend to flourish when a Christian has stopped thinking of Jesus as a Jew.

The idea that Jesus left the Jewish people behind is not new, and it has never been harmless. In the twentieth century, a group of German theologians set out to prove Jesus was not Jewish. They couldn’t do it without rewriting the Bible.

The Man in the Room

What follows is the account the New Testament gives. I’m not asking anyone to take it as history in order to see what it says about who Jesus is.

As Passover approached, in about AD 30, crowds welcomed a Jewish teacher from Galilee into Jerusalem, a city Rome ruled through a prefect named Pontius Pilate. Then came the arrest, the trial, and the crucifixion. Peter denied knowing him three times. Some of his followers, including women who had traveled with him from Galilee, stood at a distance and watched him die. Those women followed his body to the tomb and saw where he was laid (Luke 22:54-62; 23:49, 55).

That was Friday, and Friday they understood. What they couldn’t make sense of was Sunday.

Early Sunday morning, Mary Magdalene, Joanna, Mary the mother of James, and other women went to the tomb and found the stone rolled away. The body was gone. Two men in dazzling clothing told them he was alive. They hurried back to the apostles, who dismissed the report as an idle tale. Peter went to see for himself. He found the linen cloths lying there, but no Jesus (Luke 24:1-12).

That afternoon two more of them walked the road to Emmaus, a village about seven miles from Jerusalem. One was named Cleopas. A stranger joined them and walked with them, and they told him everything that had happened. They had hoped Jesus was the one who would redeem Israel. Instead he had been condemned and crucified. The stranger answered by taking them through Moses and the Prophets, explaining what the Scriptures said about the Messiah. Only later, when he sat down with them and broke bread, did they recognize him. Then he vanished (Luke 24:13-32).

By evening his followers were gathered in Jerusalem. John says the doors were locked “for fear of the Jews” (John 20:19). Everyone behind those doors was Jewish. The phrase means the authorities who had handed their teacher to Rome, not the people he came from. These were people who had eaten with Jesus, listened to him teach, and believed he was the one God had promised. Some of them had watched the Romans kill him. Some had seen where he was buried. Now word was going around the room that Jesus had appeared to Peter. Then Cleopas and his companion came in from the road with a story of their own (Luke 24:33-35).

Imagine trying to take all of that in. A man they loved had been executed. They had been grieving him since Friday. Now people they trusted were telling them they had seen him alive.

Then he is standing in the room with them.

Luke records no entrance. No footsteps, no announcement that someone has come. Jesus is simply there, in the middle of the conversation.

“Peace to you,” he says.

They are startled and frightened. They think they’re looking at a spirit. Even after everything they’ve heard that day, the sight of Jesus standing before them is more than they can comprehend (Luke 24:36-37).

So he gives them something they can see and touch. He holds out his hands and his feet. “See my hands and my feet, that it is I myself. Touch me, and see.” A spirit, he tells them, does not have flesh and bones (Luke 24:39).

They are still astonished, still struggling to believe what is happening. Then Jesus does something wonderfully ordinary. He asks for something to eat. They give him a piece of broiled fish, and he eats it while they watch (Luke 24:41-43).

Eight days later, in John’s Gospel, he invites Thomas to examine the wounds from the crucifixion (John 20:26-27).

Notice what he offers them as proof. Not a vision, not a voice. Instead, hands and feet he tells them to touch, the wounds from the cross, and a body that eats a piece of fish in front of them. All of it is evidence of one thing, and that one thing is what this essay is about: continuity.

Jesus has not risen as a different man. The one standing before them is the same Jesus who had been circumcised on the eighth day, grown up in Nazareth, taught in the synagogues, and celebrated Passover in Jerusalem. Resurrection has not erased the man he was.

Forty days later, he is taken up into heaven from the Mount of Olives, just east of Jerusalem (Acts 1:3, 9-12). As the disciples stand looking into the sky, two men in white tell them he will return the same way they watched him go.

Notice how they identify him: “This Jesus” (Acts 1:11).

This Jesus. Not a different one.

What Paul Wrote, Years Later

Paul wrote to the church in Rome about his fellow Jews, most of whom had not believed in Jesus. He did not write about them as a people God had set aside:

“They are Israelites, and to them belong the adoption, the glory, the covenants, the giving of the law, the worship, and the promises. To them belong the patriarchs, and from their race, according to the flesh, is the Christ…” (Romans 9:4-5).

Notice the tense. Paul does not say the Jewish people used to be Israelites, or that the covenants and the promises used to belong to them. He writes in the present tense, decades after the crucifixion. In the same sentence he says the Christ came from Israel according to the flesh.

Two chapters later Paul gives the Gentile Christians in Rome a warning most Christians since have not so much ignored as misunderstood. He pictures Israel as an olive tree. Gentiles who believe are wild branches “grafted in among the others” so that they share in the nourishing root (Romans 11:17). Then: “do not be arrogant toward the branches. If you are, remember it is not you who support the root, but the root that supports you” (Romans 11:18).

The misunderstanding runs something like this: Jesus came first to the Jewish people, they did not receive him, so he turned to the nations, and Israel’s part of the story closed there.

I used to believe that, because I thought of the Old Testament and the New Testament almost as different stories. I’m embarrassed to say it now, but it’s true. It wasn’t until I started re-reading the Old Testament to understand God’s covenants with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob that I began to see how often the one points to the other, and the other back again. The whole story is a Jewish story. A lot of Christians have never been shown that part.

Believing it does not make a person hate anyone. It can leave them with nothing at stake. If Israel’s part of the story ended, then what happens to Jewish people now is somebody else’s news, and a Christian who hears something ugly said about them may have no particular reason to speak up.

Paul will not let his readers stand there. He is writing to Gentile Christians who are already starting to think of themselves as the main story, and he tells them plainly what they are: late additions to a tree that was alive long before they arrived. Some branches had been broken off, he says, and wild ones were grafted in among the ones still there. He gives the new branches nothing to enjoy in that. God has the power to graft the others back in (Romans 11:23). The root was never theirs to begin with, and it is still the thing holding them up.

Of the same people who had not believed, he wrote that “as regards election, they are beloved for the sake of their forefathers” (Romans 11:28).

The Lion of the Tribe of Judah

Turn to the end of the Christian Bible and you reach the book most people give up on. John wrote it from the island of Patmos, most likely around AD 95, some sixty-five years after the crucifixion. Revelation has a reputation for being all symbol and no sense, difficult at best. I’d say this about it: stop trying to work out what it means, read it for what it says, and it becomes one of the loveliest and most hopeful books in the Bible.

So here’s what it says. John sees a scroll in the right hand of the one seated on the throne, sealed with seven seals, and an angel calling out to ask who is worthy to open it. Nobody answers. Not in heaven, not on earth, not under it. John begins to weep.

One of the elders tells him to stop. “Weep no more; behold, the Lion of the tribe of Judah, the Root of David, has conquered” (Revelation 5:5).

Both of those names come out of Israel’s Scriptures. The Lion of the tribe of Judah goes back to Jacob, blessing his son Judah and promising the scepter would not depart from him (Genesis 49:9-10). The Root of David goes back to Isaiah, and the shoot growing out of the stump of Jesse (Isaiah 11:1, 10).

In the last chapter of the book, Jesus says it of himself: “I am the root and the descendant of David, the bright morning star” (Revelation 22:16).

That is the farthest point in the whole Christian story. Past the resurrection, past the ascension, past the end of the world as anyone knows it. He is still being named by his tribe and his family line, by a writer two generations on from the crucifixion.

Where I Am Writing From

I should say plainly where I stand, because it shapes what I’ve just written. I’m a Christian. I believe Jesus is the Messiah of Israel, and I believe he will return to a throne in Jerusalem. Most Jewish readers do not believe that, and they read the same Scriptures, with centuries of devotion and scholarship behind them, and reach a different conclusion. That disagreement is real, and I’m not going to pretend it away.

What I’m arguing here is narrower, and it’s an argument with my own house. Whatever a Christian believes about who Jesus is, the New Testament will not let that Christian detach him from the Jewish people. The texts keep putting him back. Christians who ignore that have, over and over, done damage.

How the Church Forgot

If the texts are this clear, how did Christians lose track? It happened slowly, over centuries.

The church began Jewish. On Shavuot, Peter stood up in Jerusalem and preached to Jewish crowds gathered for the feast, and about three thousand were baptized that day (Acts 2:41). For years nearly every follower of Jesus was a Jew. One of the first serious controversies the movement faced was not whether Jews could follow Jesus. It was whether Gentiles could, and on what terms, and the apostles and elders met in Jerusalem to settle it (Acts 15).

Then the proportions reversed. As the message spread through the nations, more and more believers were Gentiles, and fewer and fewer had any connection to Jewish life. Over time many church leaders began teaching that God was finished with the Jewish people and that the church had taken Israel’s place.

None of this happened evenly. Christian attitudes varied by place and by century, and some Christians stood with their Jewish neighbors. The forgetting still spread far enough to do enormous harm.

What It Took to Build Another Jesus

On May 6, 1939, eleven German Protestant regional churches opened the Institute for the Study and Eradication of Jewish Influence on German Church Life. They held the opening at Wartburg Castle, where Martin Luther had translated the New Testament into German four centuries earlier. The location was not an accident.

Its academic director was Walter Grundmann, a professor of New Testament at the University of Jena. Grundmann and his colleagues taught that Jesus came from the non-Jewish population of Galilee and that he had fought against Judaism. In 1940 they published their own New Testament, Die Botschaft Gottes, The Message of God, built to replace Luther’s. It left the Old Testament out altogether and rearranged what remained into four parts. They produced a hymnal stripped of the words Hallelujah, Jehovah, Temple, and Psalm, and a catechism teaching that the message of Jesus stood opposed to Judaism.

Consider the timing. The Institute opened six months after Kristallnacht, the nationwide pogrom of November 9 and 10, 1938, when synagogues across Germany burned, Jewish shops were wrecked, and tens of thousands of Jewish men were arrested and sent to concentration camps. While the Institute’s theologians worked to take Judaism out of Christianity, the persecution around them escalated into deportation and mass murder. A Jesus with no Jewish family made it easier to look away, and easier to take part.

Now consider what the project required. The Institute could not reinterpret two or three verses and be done. It had to cut. Out went the genealogies, the Hebrew names and places, the quotations from the Prophets, the fulfilled prophecies, and, in the scene at the Samaritan well, the line where Jesus says that salvation is from the Jews (John 4:22). Jesus’ Jewish identity runs from the first verse of the New Testament to its last chapter, so scholars who wanted a Jesus without it had to take a blade to the book.

That is the strongest evidence I know for the thing I’m arguing. Remove Jesus from the Jewish people and you cannot leave the Bible intact. Take away Abraham, and Matthew’s first verse means nothing. Take away David, and no one can say what the title Son of David is for.

After the war, Grundmann and many of his colleagues went on supporting one another in Germany. Susannah Heschel tells the whole story in The Aryan Jesus: Christian Theologians and the Bible in Nazi Germany.

The Branches and the Root

The Institute was an extreme case, and almost no Christian alive would own what Grundmann built. An extreme case is still worth studying, because it shows the shape of the ordinary one. Grundmann needed a Jesus detached from the Jewish people before he could teach what he wanted to teach. Detachment comes in much milder forms: a Jesus whose Jewishness is a detail of his biography, interesting, and not load-bearing.

There is now some evidence for how that works. In early summer 2026, Katie Posey, a doctoral student in antisemitism studies at Gratz College, surveyed 1,090 American Christian men between 18 and 30, drawn from Catholic, evangelical, mainline, and nondenominational backgrounds. Church attendance did not predict their attitudes toward Jewish people. Theology did. The strongest single predictor of antisemitic attitudes was the belief that God’s promises to the Jewish people have ended. The men who believed the covenant still stands scored lower.

The survey has not been published in full, and an association is not a cause, so I’d hold the finding loosely. It points, though, at the thing this essay is about. What Christians believe about God’s promises to the Jewish people tracks with the attitudes they hold toward them.

I am not describing a problem I know only from books. Last Sunday my pastor preached a sermon on God and Israel. He told the congregation that our church rejects replacement theology, and that we are and will remain friends of Israel. He was not breaking new ground. He was saying out loud what the New Testament already says. That it still needs saying out loud, from a pulpit, in 2026, is the point.

Paul’s warning to the Christians in Rome is the one that keeps getting skipped. The branches do not hold up the root.

So go back to the room on the evening of the resurrection. A Jewish man who had kept Passover days earlier stood in front of his frightened friends and told them to touch his hands. Christians have spent two thousand years worshiping him. The least they owe him is to remember whose son he is.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved. Biblical references appear in the text.

About the Author
Jill Szoo Wilson is a writer, theatre artist, and educator in St. Louis. She is the author of Thinking Through Theatre and writes the essay series One Story. One Covenant. One Messiah., which helps Christians see the Jewish story at the heart of their faith. She serves on the board of St. Louis Friends of Israel.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.