It Is Not Enough to Affix a Mezuzah to the Doorpost
It Is Not Enough to Affix a Mezuzah to the Doorpost. We Must Also Know How to Protect Our Home.
What Can Ethiopian Jewish Tradition Teach Us About Covenant, Listening, and Responsibility?
About a week ago, we had the privilege of holding a moving ceremony at Ono Academic College to celebrate the reopening of the International Center for the Study of Ethiopian Jewry, following the renovation and redesign of its facilities. It was a dignified occasion, attended by partners, scholars, and dear friends who have accompanied us on the long journey toward establishing the Center.
Amid the excitement, I found myself looking at Brenda Gewurz, who, despite her health challenges, stood there with pride and dignity. Brenda had initiated the renovation, transforming the space into a fitting and dignified home for the study of Ethiopian Jewry. Her vision went beyond improving the physical surroundings. It reflected a deeper conviction that the place in which we work should embody the values we seek to advance through our engagement with the cultural and religious world of Ethiopian Jewry.
I would like to share the central ideas I expressed during the mezuzah ceremony at the opening. As we prepared to affix an authentic Ethiopian mezuzah to the doorpost, I made an observation that may have surprised some of those present: Today, virtually every Jewish family of Ethiopian origin in Israel has a mezuzah on its doorpost. Yet in Ethiopia itself, Jewish homes did not have mezuzot. The Jews of Bete Israel, the historic Jewish community of Ethiopia, did not traditionally observe the practice of affixing a mezuzah to the entrance of their homes.
This presents an intriguing paradox. A commandment that has become one of the most recognizable symbols of a Jewish home was not part of the customary religious practice of Ethiopian Jews. At first glance, one might interpret this as evidence of their separation from rabbinic tradition or unfamiliarity with the commandment. I would suggest another perspective: Perhaps the tradition of Bete Israel can help us rediscover something of the mezuzah’s deeper meaning, even though the community did not physically place one on its doorposts.
To explain, let me begin with an amusing story about a non-Jewish Swiss couple visiting Israel. While visiting Jewish friends, they noticed a small object attached to a doorpost and asked what it was. Their friends explained, “It’s a mezuzah. It protects Jewish homes.”
When the couple returned to Switzerland, they decided to install a mezuzah on their own front door. But they went a step further, placing one on each side of the doorway. Asked why, they replied with impeccable logic: “If one mezuzah protects the house, surely two will provide twice the protection!”
The story is humorous, but it raises a serious question. Many people associate the mezuzah with protection and safety. Indeed, alongside circumcision and Sabbath observance, it has become one of the most visible expressions of Jewish life.
The commandment originates in the Torah: “And you shall write them on the doorposts of your house and on your gates” (Deuteronomy 6:9). Many Jews have the custom of touching the mezuzah and kissing their fingers when entering or leaving their homes. This small, everyday gesture can express a profound idea: Even within the privacy of one’s home, we are called to remember God’s presence and the responsibilities that come with it.
But if the commandment appears explicitly in the Torah, why did Ethiopian Jews not observe it? We might instead ask how the practice of affixing a mezuzah developed over the centuries and when its familiar form became established. Historical scholarship indicates that the commandment was expressed differently in different periods and that religious practices evolved over time.
My purpose here is not to enter that historical debate, but to show how an encounter with Bete Israel tradition allows us to reconsider questions whose answers we often take for granted.
This brings us to a more fundamental question: What truly protects a home? Does attaching a mezuzah to the doorpost guarantee its safety, or is the mezuzah meant to remind us of our responsibility to protect the home from within?
One of the central principles I identify in the theological, legal, and social foundations of Bete Israel is compromise. This principle was embodied in the work of the shmaglotch, traditional community elders who served as leaders and mediators. This does not mean that legal judgments or formal decisions had no place. Rather, alongside them stood a commitment to reconciliation, restoring relationships, and enabling people to live together after a dispute.
In this sense, compromise is more than a practical means of resolving conflict. It reflects a worldview in which determining who is legally right is not always sufficient. Sometimes an equally important question is how the parties will continue living together once a decision has been reached.
An illuminating concept in this context is the word ስምምዕ (simmim, agreement or mutual understanding). I see in it an expression of a deeper principle: Agreement does not necessarily begin with two people thinking alike. It begins with their willingness to hear and understand one another.
We can hear another person’s words without truly listening, just as we can listen attentively without agreeing. Listening does not require abandoning our convictions. It requires recognizing that the other person also has an inner world, with pain, needs, and a perspective of their own.
For me, then, compromise begins not with concession, but with listening.
I am reminded of a question once posed to me by Leila, the bright young daughter of my dear friend Ilan Gewurz. She asked, “Why did God speak to the Children of Israel in biblical times, but stop speaking to us?”
I was about to respond with an idea I had learned from Rabbi Professor David Hartman: Perhaps God’s silence is not abandonment, but an expression of trust in humanity. God steps back to allow human beings to stand on their own feet, not because He has stopped loving us, but precisely because He believes in us.
Before I could answer, however, Professor Tova Hartman, who was present, offered another possibility: “Maybe God never stopped speaking to us. Maybe we are the ones who stopped listening.”
Her words reminded me of something I had heard from my late uncle, the Hacham Daniel Mengesha. He explained that in Ethiopia, we did not divide the commandments into two separate categories: those governing our relationship with God (bein adam laMakom) and those governing our relationships with other people (bein adam la-chaveiro).
A person’s character was measured first and foremost by how they treated others, while commandments concerning one’s relationship with God were, to a considerable extent, also understood as obligations toward oneself.
God addresses us through the person standing before us, through the suffering of others, and through our responsibility to listen, show consideration, and make room for another human being.
It is relatively easy to speak of humility before God. It is far more difficult to practice humility toward someone whose views differ from our own.
But what does all this have to do with the mezuzah?
Within the Jewish legal tradition, the Rishonim, the leading rabbinic authorities of the medieval period, disagreed over whether a mezuzah should be placed vertically or horizontally. The Shulchan Aruch, the authoritative code of Jewish law, ruled that it should be affixed vertically, and this remains the general Sephardic custom. Among Ashkenazi Jews, however, the practice developed of placing the mezuzah diagonally, accommodating both positions.
I once heard a beautiful explanation of this custom attributed to Rabbi Yaakov Edelstein, of blessed memory. One of the most important foundations of any home, he taught, is the ability to compromise.
The diagonal mezuzah reminds us that a home cannot flourish when each person insists on standing perfectly upright, convinced that only their own position is correct and unwilling to lean even slightly toward the other.
Every time a couple enters or leaves their home, the mezuzah can remind them that maintaining a relationship requires a willingness to bend.
Here, three ideas come together: compromise in Bete Israel tradition, listening as a religious obligation, and the symbolism of the diagonal mezuzah. All three express the understanding that peaceful, trusting relationships are impossible when individuals place themselves at the center and leave no room for others.
We can now return to our original question: How can a tradition that did not practice affixing mezuzot to doorposts illuminate the meaning of the commandment?
We might suggest, as a spiritual interpretation, that Ethiopian Jews did not place the mezuzah on the outside of their homes because they carried its meaning within their hearts. This is not a historical claim about why the practice was absent, but an attempt to understand the spiritual insight we can draw from that tradition.
The mezuzah is more than a small case attached to a doorframe. It can also represent an inner awareness that our home does not belong exclusively to us or exist solely to satisfy our wishes. A home is a place of relationships, commitments, and responsibilities, where each person must recognize the presence and needs of others.
We often describe the mezuzah as a source of protection against harmful forces threatening us from outside. Yet perhaps the greatest danger to a home lies within it. We ourselves can destroy the very home we seek to protect.
It is not enough to affix a mezuzah to the doorpost. We must also know how to protect our home.
This brings me back to the International Center for the Study of Ethiopian Jewry and the question of its mission.
Certainly, the Center must be a home for rigorous, critical scholarship, the preservation of traditions, the documentation of knowledge at risk of disappearing, and the training of a new generation of researchers. It must listen to the voices of the Kessim, the traditional spiritual leaders of Ethiopian Jewry, and the community’s elders. It must study manuscripts, customs, and worldviews while fostering encounters among different Jewish traditions.
But I believe its mission extends beyond these important responsibilities.
For many years, Ethiopian Jewry has primarily been an object of study, classification, and judgment. Others have asked who Ethiopian Jews are, where their traditions originated, and how their religious practices resemble or differ from rabbinic Judaism.
These are important questions. But the time has come to ask another: What can Ethiopian Jewry teach us?
What can its theology contribute to our understanding of the relationship between humanity and God? What can its understanding of covenant offer Israeli society as it struggles with profound crises of trust and coexistence?
I do not wish to portray Ethiopian Jewry as an ideal society untouched by conflict or injustice. That is precisely why its traditions deserve serious study, not romanticization, but thoughtful and critical engagement.
Perhaps this is also the message I most want to convey at this particular moment, as antisemitism rises across the world, to every part of the Jewish people, in Israel and throughout the Diaspora.
Antisemites do not distinguish between liberal and conservative Jews, between Orthodox, Reform, and Conservative Jews, between settlers and Tel Aviv residents, or between Jews living in Israel and those living abroad. Their hatred is indifferent to our internal differences.
On October 7, we witnessed an even more brutal reality: Hamas terrorists did not even distinguish between Jews and non-Jews. They murdered, raped, and abducted human beings, Jews and non-Jews, Israelis and foreign nationals alike.
In the face of this reality, I want to remind us of something simple: We do not have to agree with one another, but we must remember that we are responsible for one another.
We are not being asked to abandon our disagreements, our distinct identities, or our beliefs. We are being asked to preserve the covenant within which those differences can exist.
After all, what is the point of fighting for our right to be different if, in the end, we are incapable of living together?
I do not wish to be a prophet of doom, nor do I claim to know what the future holds. But I cannot ignore the deep concern that weighs on me.
At the very moment when antisemitism is intensifying and Jews around the world feel threatened simply because they are Jewish, we risk deepening the divisions among ourselves. Each group retreats behind the certainty of its own righteousness, each camp convinced that it alone possesses the truth. At times, we seem more concerned with proving who is right than with discovering how we can continue living together.
And so I ask, almost plead: Please, please, before it is too late, let us not reject one another.
Let us have the integrity and courage to look in the mirror rather than merely point out the shortcomings of others. Let us ask not only where others are mistaken, but also where we ourselves may be wrong.
Compromise is not weakness, and listening does not mean surrendering the truth. On the contrary, sometimes it takes greater courage to listen than to fight, and greater humility to make room for another person than to insist upon our own righteousness.
We do not need to be identical to belong to the same people, nor must we agree on everything to accept responsibility for one another.
Precisely because antisemitism makes no distinction among our different Jewish identities, we must not allow those differences to become grounds for division. Our unity should not depend on erasing our diversity, but on preserving the covenant that allows us to remain together despite it.
Yet this covenant is not intended merely to ensure our survival. It serves a greater purpose.
The Jewish people were not meant only to defend themselves against their enemies, but also to bring blessing to the world: to be or lagoyim, a light unto the nations, and to pursue tikkun olam b’malchut Shaddai, the repair of the world under God’s sovereignty.
But how can we aspire to repair the world if we cannot make room for one another within our own home? How can we bring light to others if we allow hatred and suspicion to extinguish the light within us?
Perhaps this is where all these ideas converge, at the mezuzah on our doorpost.
The diagonal mezuzah reminds us that we need not always stand rigidly upright in opposition to others. Sometimes we must be willing to lean a little, not out of surrender, but out of responsibility.
The consciousness of covenant preserved in Ethiopian Jewish tradition reminds us that a home is protected not only by laws and agreements, but also by the relationships we cultivate within it.
We ask God to protect our home, and we pray:
“May He who makes peace in His heavens bring peace upon us and upon all Israel.”
But perhaps the mezuzah reminds us that God also expects us to do our part: to protect our home, to work for peace among ourselves, and to pursue peace throughout the world.
For it is not enough to ask God to make peace. We must become partners in making it.
Am Yisrael Chai — The People of Israel Live.
