Jerusalem Day: Why the Bennett-Lapid government was doomed to fail

MK Mansour Abbas, photo by Zaher333 via Wikipedia

If reports from Arutz 13 are to be believed, Naftali Bennett and Yair Lapid were set to announce their unity government on Sunday, on Jerusalem Day. The government likely would have consisted of Bennett’s conservative Yamina party, Lapid’s neoliberal Yesh Atid, the centrist Blue and White, the anti-Netanyahu conservative New Hope, the social democrat Labor Party, the democratic socialist Meretz, the Russian interests-secularist-hawkish Yisrael Beiteinu, with outside support from the Islamist Ra’am Party. With Yamina’s MK Amichai Shilki vowing to vote against such a government, the vote of confidence, with and only with the support of Ra’am, would scrape by 61-59.

This, obviously, did not occur. As Bennett and Lapid were planning on meeting with Ra’am chief Mansour Abbas Sunday morning, violence broke out in Jerusalem between Arab rioters, Jerusalem Day celebrators, and the Israeli police. Abbas called off the meeting and froze all contacts with the “Change Bloc.” As Hamas began sending rockets into Jerusalem and Beit Shemesh, Abbas announced that he would not support any government that would wage war in Gaza.

This should not be a surprise to anyone, least of all Naftali Bennett, who likened a government with Ra’am to “a government with Hamas” multiple times during the campaign when it seemed Netanyahu would be the one to employ the Islamist faction in the path to government formation. Bennett, although hyperbolic, is not very far off. Following Operation Protective Edge, for instance, then-Ra’am chief Ibrahim Sarsour attended what the Jerusalem Post described as a “Hamas victory party” alongside Balad’s Jamal Zehalka and Haneen Zoabi, singing the Palestinian national anthem and hanging banners reading “Gaza won.”

With war against Hamas a constant threat, what exactly made Bennett believe a government supported by a party he equated to the terrorist group would endure? So too a government with Meretz, who Bennett refused to sit with during the elections because of their “anti-Zionism,” stating so on several internal calls with party activists.

It almost seems too obvious to be said, you cannot have a government, especially a wartime government, with necessary support from parties who want you to lose. It is very lucky for Israel that this outbreak of violence occurred before the formation of this government, likely preventing it, rather than after, when Ra’am and, to a slightly lesser degree, Meretz could very well have sabotaged the war effort with credible threats of a no-confidence vote. No ground invasion or we are calling a no-confidence vote, no striking certain targets or we are calling a no-confidence vote, such demands in an all-out war could have cost many lives.

Jerusalem Day proved why the suggested Bennett-Lapid government was doomed to fail from the start, an Israeli government cannot rely on anti-Zionists. These anti-Zionist parties like Ra’am are able, in good conscience, to sit as opposition backbenchers and bemoan the “occupation,” they are able, in good conscience, to grift the Arab population into giving them votes and money in return for absolutely nothing, but they cannot in good conscious sit in the government of a state upon which they wish nothing short of total destruction.

So let this be a lesson to any prospective prime ministers. If you make a government with the support or inclusion of anti-Zionists parties, it will not last long. At a certain point, in your effort to defend the state and people you swore to protect, they will either compromise you with demands or they will leave you with a sitting-duck government. Elections will come again and voters, either way, will not be happy you invited enemies of the state into the halls of government.

About the Author
Yishai Edberg is a member of the Religious Zionist Party's youth wing. He has previously served as a spokesman and graphic designer for the Yamina Youth and has written for such publications as VISION Magazine, The Post Millennial, and The Israel Press. Jesse is a student at the Tulane University of Louisiana where he is pursuing a degree in political science. The Complete and Translated Poetic Works of Avraham Stern by Avraham Stern, translated with forward and footnotes by Yishai Edberg is available today on Amazon and where books are sold.
Related Topics
Related Posts