Laban and the Danger of Being Accepted on Someone Else’s Terms
At the Passover Seder, we learn that Jacob’s father-in-law, Laban, was an even greater threat to the Jewish people than Pharaoh. Based on the verse, An Aramean sought to destroy my father,* we read in the Haggadah, “Go out and learn what Laban the Aramean sought to do to Jacob, our father; since Pharaoh only decreed [a death sentence] on the males but Laban sought to uproot everything.” Yet, when we read the biblical accounts of Pharaoh and Laban, this contrast is not the easiest to relate to. Pharaoh enslaved an entire people and ordered the murder of children. Laban welcomed Jacob into his home, married off his daughters to him, and provided him with employment. What made Laban a greater threat to the Jewish people than Pharaoh?
Pharaoh saw the growing Jewish population in Egypt as a fifth column – a subversive “enemy within” that would sympathize with and aid an external enemy. He therefore sought to deal shrewdly with them through enslavement. When enslavement didn’t work, he asked midwives to kill Israelite boys secretly. When they refused to comply, he pronounced an open decree that all Israelite boys be thrown into the Nile.
Enslaving the Israelites was counterproductive to Pharaoh’s goals. Not only did they continue to grow in number, but their economic and social subordination did not extinguish their collective identity. Trying to eliminate all male Jewish infants likewise did not achieve what Pharaoh had hoped. Instead, it created a situation of such desperation that God intervened on the Israelites’ behalf.
Laban also shrewdly attempted to subordinate Jacob and his family, but he did so by giving Jacob a false sense of belonging.
When Laban first meets Jacob, he calls him “my bone and my flesh,” reflecting Adam’s reference to Eve as “bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh.” He then calls him “my brother” before asking him what his wages should be. At first, Laban’s offer seems generous. He recognizes that a relative should not be expected to work without compensation. Yet, in retrospect, it becomes clear that Laban uses Jacob’s working for him to exploit him. After Jacob fathers eleven sons and seeks leave of Laban, Laban again draws Jacob in, complimenting him by saying that he has been blessed because of Jacob. Jacob doesn’t leave at that time. Laban asks him what his new wages should be to continue to work for him. This was not an offer to become a partner in the family business. It was a way to keep Jacob dependent on Laban for Laban’s own benefit.
Six years later, Jacob hears the Divine voice tell him to return home. When Jacob tells his wives, Rachel and Leah respond: “Have we still a share in the inheritance of our father’s house? Does he not regard us as outsiders? Since he has sold us and used up our wealth…” Laban’s daughters recognize that he does not treat them as family but as possessions, yet they add, “all the wealth that God has rescued (hitzil) from our father belongs to us and to our children.” A similar expression occurs when God appears to Moses at the burning bush. God says, “I have come down to rescue them [i.e., the Israelites] (l’hatzilo) from the Egyptians and to bring them out of that land.” The similar use of language points to a similarity of situation – in both cases the subjugated oppressed need rescue from those who claim ownership over them and over the fruits of their labor.
Laban himself finally reveals his true motives when he declares to Jacob, “The daughters are my daughters, the children are my children, and the flocks are my flocks; all that you see is mine. Yet what can I do now about my daughters or the children they have borne?” Were Laban simply expressing his affection for his children and grandchildren, he would have no need to include mention of flocks and everything that one could see. The inclusion suggests that Laban sees Jacob’s wives and children no differently than he sees the flocks. They are all his possessions. Nevertheless, he admits that he cannot do anything about the situation, since God had told him the night before not to touch Jacob and his family.
Laban blurred the distinction between offering Jacob a sense of belonging and claiming that his family belonged to him. Had he succeeded, there would have been no need to physically destroy Jacob’s family. He would have undermined Jacob’s ability to carry forward the mission of Abraham and Isaac. What made Laban’s tactics particularly dangerous was that he used the very relationships that supported Jacob to try to annihilate him.
Jacob was not naïve. He recognized that Laban had repeatedly deceived him, yet he remained in Laban’s household for twenty years. Recognizing that one is being exploited is not the same as being able to extricate oneself from an exploitative relationship. Jacob had to flee, and only when they met at Gilead could he successfully stand up to Laban and establish strong boundaries – both territorial and relational – between them.
This is not to suggest that Jews should be suspicious of acceptance by others or that external rejection is beneficial to Jewish identity. Appreciating the danger that Laban posed requires recognizing that acceptance is not genuine if it is conditional upon surrendering one’s identity or subordinating oneself to another’s interests.
Perhaps this is why the Haggadah begins the passage with the words, “Go out and learn what Laban the Aramean sought to do to Jacob, our father.” The measure of how genuinely a Jewish identity – or any identity – is accepted is whether a person can express it openly in public rather than only in the privacy of their home. Also, when someone uses the language of affection and kinship to take advantage of you, it becomes harder to distinguish gestures of care from attempts at control. Each of us must, therefore, go out and learn whether the relationships we cultivate affirm who we are or make our acceptance conditional upon becoming someone else.
* A few commentators translate, Arami oved avi, as “my father was a wandering Aramean,” identifying the subject as either Abraham or Jacob, not Laban. The writers of the Haggadah, however, adopt the same interpretation found in Onkelos, who translates the verse, “An Aramean sought to destroy my father.”
