Learning from the past, Strengthening our future

Last week, while preparing dinner, my son asked me why we always talk about Israel at home. “Why does it matter so much, Ima?” This simple question sparked a reflection on the urgency of ensuring that the next generation understands their Jewish identity as deeply intertwined with the fate of Israel.

In times of crisis, it becomes essential to explore the lessons we can draw from the concept of Diaspora nationalism—ideas that resonate profoundly today. Historically articulated by Simon Dubnov, this notion emphasizes the shared cultural and historical consciousness of Jewish people across borders. For Dubnov, Jewish identity was not merely about religious practice or attachment to a land; it was about cultivating a dynamic sense of belonging that could thrive within diverse contexts, particularly in the Diaspora.

Modern Zionism, born out of a yearning for national self-determination, shares this sentiment, advocating for a connection to Israel as an integral part of Jewish identity. Yet, as we face rising antisemitism and anti-Israel sentiment, particularly on college campuses, we must bridge these two frameworks. Understanding that being a Zionist in the Diaspora is a vital expression of our identity can empower us to confront the challenges we face today.

The events following October 7th have illuminated a stark reality for many Jewish Americans: our connections to Israel are not just about supporting a distant homeland but about affirming who we are as Jews. The shock of discovering that friends and neighbors hold deeply anti-Israel views has left many feeling isolated, questioning their place in a society that seems increasingly hostile to their identity.

This is where the principles reflected in Diaspora nationalism can guide us. They urge us to embrace our shared history and collective memory, reminding us that our identity is not confined by geography. In fact, the struggle to maintain a vibrant Jewish identity in the face of adversity is a testament to our resilience. As we nurture this identity, we can create a foundation that not only honors our past but also prepares the next generation to stand confidently in their beliefs.

For our children, the dual identity of being American and Jewish, with a connection to Israel, must be celebrated. They should see their Jewishness as a tapestry woven from the threads of history, culture, and shared struggles—one that finds its strength in the bond between the Diaspora and the Jewish homeland. The insights from the past can help them understand their place in this ongoing narrative, instilling in them a sense of responsibility to engage with the world around them.

Moreover, embracing the lessons from Diaspora nationalism can foster a movement that emphasizes civic engagement and activism. By equipping young people with the tools to articulate their Jewish identity and advocate for Israel, we empower them to confront discrimination and antisemitism head-on. This includes understanding their role as informed citizens, engaging in dialogue, and standing up for their beliefs in both academic and social spheres.

In this moment of crisis, we have a unique opportunity to reframe our narrative. By drawing on the insights of Dubnov and other thinkers who understood the importance of a united Jewish people, we can reaffirm our commitment to Israel as an integral aspect of our identity. We can encourage pride in our heritage and solidarity with our homeland, ensuring that our children see themselves as part of a larger story.

As we navigate these challenging times, let us commit to nurturing a strong, resilient Jewish identity among our children—one that is rooted in our shared history and is adaptable to the realities of modern life. By doing so, we ensure that the next generation grows up with a robust understanding of their place in the world, grounded in the knowledge that they are part of a larger story—one that connects the Diaspora to the heart of Israel.