Lessons From Chanukah For Proud Jewish Advocacy
The Chanukah season is coming up fast, and early this year according to the Jewish Calendar (starting on the evening of December 4th). Chanukah means both Dedication and Education in Hebrew. Let’s make the most of it.
For those unfamiliar with the history of Chanukah (also spelled Hanukkah), it is a valuable lesson in the indigeneity of Jews to Israel and long predates the advent of both Christianity and Islam. I would suggest looking up Chanukah on sites such as Chabad.org or My Jewish Learning or Wikipedia for the basic history and practices and even holiday recipes.
While Chanukah is a minor holiday in the Jewish tradition (not requiring us to take time off work) its observance in North America even among less observant Jewish folks became a proud symbol of our ethnic identity and difference from our surrounding cultures.
The issue of assimilation to the surrounding culture or retaining Jewish authenticity even under threat and remaining true to our tradition is a long theme in Jewish history and our own lives and families. This is especially emphasized in the Chanukah story.
Circa 168 BCE, the Hasmonean family of Mattityahu and his sons encouraged the Israelite community under occupation and threat from the pagan Assyrian Greek empire to ‘follow the law’ and study their traditions and practice their faith even in hiding and even on pain of death, despite any social and economic consequences. Many Jewish folks today are doing the same.
https://www.chabad.org/holidays/chanukah/article_cdo/aid/102978/jewish/The-Hanukkah-Story.htm
https://reformjudaism.org/jewish-holidays/hanukkah/history-hanukkah-story
The dreidel or wooden top emerges proudly as a symbol of resistance in the Chanukah story. We are told that scholars hid in the caves of Judea with their Torah scrolls and studied their tradition and planned resistance strategies while children were placed at the front of the caves playing with tops to observe the passing occupation army and warn the scholars as necessary.
Note the correspondences of this story with so many moments in our Jewish history when Jews were under attack and forced into hiding and resistance by their surrounding societies. The Spanish Inquisition and the Crusades and the Holocaust come to mind. To some extent, so do our contemporary Diaspora communities, where Jews and Jewish sites are often under attack for being visible as Jews, Zionists, and as supporters of Israel.
I note with emphasis that the Chanukah story stresses that the heroic scholars and resistance heroes such as the Maccabees were WARRIORS, often prevailing against overwhelming odds. And this Jewish resistance movement included women such as Judith and Yael and Hannah and her Seven Sons.
The history of Chanukah should inform contemporary debates on the inclusion of Haredi scholars in mandatory military or national service in Israel. There is no free lunch. It is embarrassing to see the extent to which our contemporary Israeli society has coddled a generation of spoiled tax supported Haredi youth who are often most known for illiteracy in secular studies, economic insufficiency, and participation in civil disobedience protests and attacks on women and LGBTQ people. They are an embarrassment. Why support them?
It may be surprising to you, but I do prefer English Bible editions containing the Apocrypha, or books that were not included in the traditional Biblical canon of Judaism and Protestant Christianity, but included in Catholic Bibles and those of Christian Orthodox denominations. Why? Because they include great wisdom teachings such as the Wisdom of Solomon and Ecclesiasticus / Ben Sira allegedly written by philosophical Jewish authors outside the rabbinic canon as well as the Book of Maccabees, which is a valuable historical resource on the Chanukah story written around the same time it happened. It tells many of the same tales we grew up with in Hebrew school. I read it every year!
https://www.sefaria.org/The_Book_of_Maccabees_I?tab=contents
As well, it is worth revisiting the special Chanukah passages in our siddur or prayer book and the Birkat Hamazon or Grace After Meals. Here they are:
https://www.chabad.org/holidays/chanukah/article_cdo/aid/597141/jewish/Texts-and-Prayers.htm
Social scientists studying Jewish life have noted that many secularized Jewish North Americans who may be less observant most of the time will celebrate Chanukah as an expression of their Jewish identity as distinguished from the surrounding secular or Christian culture. It is a proud statement of our Jewish identity and also of our connection to our Jewish history and to Israel.
One of my favorite new discoveries in my Jewish life and studies has been the work of the folk/bluegrass band Nefesh Mountain, who have reclaimed archival songs written by American folk legend Woody Guthrie in honour of Chanukah.
Woody Guthrie's second wife Marjorie Guthrie (a leading advocate in fundraising for Huntington's Disease) was a dancer with the Martha Graham Company in New York City. His mother-in-law was Aliza Greenblatt, a celebrated Yiddish poet. She collaborated with Woody Guthrie on these songs. I can picture them sung and played with children in the early 20th century and Depression Era.
Woody Guthrie himself claimed to have written these songs to honor the Jewish heritage of his wife and mother-in-law and the historic struggles of the Jewish people, which inspired him. I am deeply inspired by the work of the band Nefesh Mountain and their archival work to reclaim these Jewish and Chanukah themed songs to inspire a new generation in Jewish pride. Check out all their videos on Youtube! Some of their videos were filmed in the historic Beth Elohim Temple House in Brooklyn, New York.
Please join me this Chanukah and Holiday Season in supporting a food bank in any flavor you like! I will be supporting our local Jewish Family Services Kosher Food Bank and Leket Israel and our local secular civic food bank Hamilton Food Share. Please give generously. Hunger doesn't discriminate and neither should we.
Best wishes to all for a Chag Sameach, Happy Hanukkah, Merry Christmas, Happy Holiday Season, and all good things for the New Year.
Am Yisrael Chai. We send our love from Canada.
