Decolonize This
Concordia University professor (I hesitate to call her that) and former US Holocaust Memorial Museum Fellow (clearly, they are not vetting their fellows) delivered a talk this week on the decolonization of Holocaust museums. The advertisement for the lecture included the following statement: “…Holocaust museums are not free from entanglements with state poser nor from inherited traditions and infrastructures of museum practice with their attendant biases, exclusions, and silences.”
Let’s look at Professor Lehrer. Her research focus includes Memory/Heritage/Museums, Jewish-Polish Heritage, and Decolonial Museology in East Central Europe. She also founded the organization Thinking Through the Museum (thinkingthroughthemuseum.org), which “brings together university researchers, museum professionals, and members of diverse communities to respond to colonial legacies and other histories of injustice with new forms of engagement.” The organization has an entire page dedicated to “critical race museology,” which is described as: the examination of how museums and galleries are implicated in the production of race and racism, analyzing racialized collections and exhibitionary spaces via such lenses as gender, sexuality, class, colonialism, and nationalism, and addressing intersecting legacies of settler colonialism and slavery.
Dr. Lehrer seems to be on a decolonization tour, preaching the need to decolonize Holocaust museums. Here’s an ad for her talk at the University of Michigan.
The backlash against her talk at Penn State led the university to publish a rather offensive press release that notes that the director of the Jewish Studies Program, Tommaso M. Milani, has addressed the terms used in the ads (decolonization). Who is Tommaso Milani? On Milani’s Penn State page, he is described as an interdisciplinary scholar who works at the intersections of Applied Linguistics, Jewish Studies, African Studies, and Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies. Milani has written numerous articles questioning Zionism. In an article titled “Affective trouble: a Jewish/Palestinian heterosexual wedding threatening the Israeli Nation-State,” Milani and co- author Roey J. Gafter write the following:
As we explain in more detail below, Israel constitutes a complex example of the relationship between citizenship and nationality: while there are approximately one million Palestinians who are citizens of Israel and should enjoy the same rights and duties as Jewish Israeli citizens, Israeli nationalism has historically been built around a Jewish Zionist idea of common origin from, and belonging to, the land of Israel, that has consistently sought to exclude – erase even – Palestinians and their symbols from the Israeli national imaginary.
Milani and Muzna Awayed-Bishara wrote a chapter in The Palgrave Handbook of Decolonizing the Education and Language Sciences titled “Learning to Unlearn Colonial Fear: Sumud as Linguistic Citizenship Among Palestinian Youth in Israel.” The abstract states the following:
The Hamas attacks on Israel followed by Israel’s response causing massive destruction, starvation, and excessive death tolls in Gaza compel our attention to the implications of the war not only about what it means to be human but also about the moral obligations of applied linguistics.
The question that must be asked is how this man became the head of a Jewish Studies Program at an institution such as Penn State. It isn’t shocking that someone who sees Israel as a colonizing state would invite a speaker such as Lehrer to speak.
I spent a lot of time researching Professor Lehrer and her work. To her credit, she did important work in Poland while a fellow at the US Holocaust Museum. However, there does seem to be a shift in her focus to decolonization, the new trend in academic scholarship. All one needs to do is add “decolonization” to a talk about the murder of 6 million Jews, and they become the trendsetter of the week. So, what is decolonization? It includes challenging settler colonialism (a term thrown around by Israel haters), restoring land rights, and reviving indigenous culture. Where have I heard this before?
Whether it is decolonizing a Holocaust museum or calling a Jewish person a colonizer, the term is now associated with the hatred of Israel, the only Jewish state. Rather than focusing on its meaning, it has become the language of Jew hate. Milani is a linguist who knows the importance of words, the weight of language. Why choose such a title for the talk? Rather than using language to further peace or dialogue, the Jewish Studies Program used language to further the dangerous belief (and incorrect belief) that Jews are colonizers.
