Stuart Katz

Mental Health in the Parsha: Chukat: When Grief Meets the Last Straw

This week’s parsha is bracketed by death. Miriam dies near the start. Aharon dies near the end. And in between sits one of the most painful moments in Moshe’s whole life. He loses his temper, hits a rock, and is told he will never set foot in the land he has spent forty years walking toward. We usually read it as a story about a punishment that feels too harsh for the crime. Read as a story about a human mind, it is something more familiar. It is about grief, exhaustion, and the moment a good person finally cracks.

The loss no one let him mourn

The moment Miriam dies, the water dries up. Our tradition connects the well that kept the people alive to her, so her death and their thirst arrive together. And the people do not give Moshe a moment to grieve his sister. They turn on him at once, demanding water, wishing out loud they had never left. He goes straight from a funeral into a crisis.

Most of us know this in our own smaller way. Life does not pause for our grief. The bills, the kids, the job, the next demand all keep coming, whether or not we have had a chance to feel anything. And grief that gets no room to breathe does not politely disappear. It waits, and it leaks out sideways, often as anger, at the wrong moment, toward the wrong person.

The rock

Hashem tells Moshe to speak to the rock. Instead, calling the people rebels, he strikes it twice. The water comes anyway, but he is told that this moment has cost him the land.

People have argued for centuries about what exactly Moshe did wrong. The more human question is why. A man who led with patience for forty years suddenly snaps. He is grieving. He is worn down. He is being attacked again. The crack in the rock is also a crack in him. And that is how it usually goes for the rest of us too. Our worst moments rarely come out of nowhere. They come at the end of a long stretch where we were running on empty and nobody noticed, ourselves included. The rock was never really about the rock.

The snake you have to look at

Later the people are bitten by snakes, and Hashem tells Moshe to make a copper snake, נחש נחשת, and lift it on a pole. Whoever looks up at it lives. Our sages asked the obvious question. Does a piece of copper heal anybody? Their answer was that the healing came from the looking up, from lifting the eyes and the heart instead of staring down at the wound.

There is a real lesson in that for anyone in pain. Healing often begins the moment we stop running from the thing that hurt us and actually turn and look at it. Avoiding pain feels safer in the short term, but it keeps the venom in. Naming it, facing it, looking up, is where recovery quietly starts.

Some things have no clean reason

The parsha opens with the strangest law in the Torah, the red heifer, פרה אדומה, whose ashes make the impure pure and somehow make the pure impure. It is the classic example of a law with no reason we can understand. And there is a gift hidden in that. Not everything that happens to us comes with a reason we can grasp, and demanding one can keep us stuck for years. Sometimes peace begins when we can finally say, I do not understand why this happened, and I am going to keep living anyway.

Standing on firmer ground

So what do we take from a parsha full of loss?

Make room for grief, even a little. A funeral does not end the grieving, it starts it. If life will not give you the space, take a small piece of it on purpose.

Watch your load, not just your last straw. By the time you snap, the real story is usually everything that came before. Notice when you are running on empty, because that is when the rock gets hit.

Forgive yourself for the moment you cracked. Even Moshe cracked, grieving and exhausted and pushed too far. One bad moment does not erase a lifetime of carrying people well.

Look up instead of away. Whatever bit you, turning to face it is almost always the beginning of getting better, not the thing to avoid.

Make some peace with the unexplained. You do not have to understand why to keep walking forward.

Moshe does not get to enter the land. But notice what he does next. He keeps leading. He keeps caring for the people, right to the end of his life. A season of grief and a single broken moment did not erase who he was. They do not erase who you are either.


Mental Health in the Parsha is a weekly series about the emotional wisdom hidden inside the Torah portion, and what it can offer us right now. These thoughts are meant for reflection and conversation, not as a replacement for professional mental health care.

About the Author
Stuart Katz, PsyD, MPH, MBA, is a co-founder of the Nafshenu Alenu mental health educational initiative, launched in 2022. With his extensive academic background, including a doctorate in psychology, a master's in public health, and an MBA, Stuart brings a unique, multidisciplinary perspective to his work in mental health advocacy. He currently serves on the Board of Visitors at McLean Hospital, affiliated with Harvard Medical School, and holds several leadership roles, including Chairman of the Board of OGEN – Advancement of Mental Health Awareness in Israel and Mental Health First Aid Israel. Stuart is also a key partner in the "Deconstructing Stigma" campaign in Israel. Additionally, he serves on the Board of Directors of the Religious Conference Management Association and has provided counseling to over 7,000 individuals and families in crisis worldwide.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.