Michael Knopf
Rabbi and editor of 'No Time for Neutrality'
Featured Post

On Hanukkah and Star Wars

Both the holiday and the blockbuster teach that the struggle of light against dark is eternal
Rey in 'Star Wars: The Last Jedi.' (Screenshot/Courtesy Walt Disney/Lucasfilms)
Rey in 'Star Wars: The Last Jedi.' (Screenshot/Courtesy Walt Disney/Lucasfilms)

Tonight begins the last night of Hanukkah, and this year, Disney has gifted us a new Star Wars movie for the holiday. It is truly fortuitous that the release of The Last Jedi coincides with Hanukkah. In many ways, the parallels between the Star Wars saga and the Hanukkah story are striking. Both stories tell of meager bands of freedom fighters, including farm boys and paupers turned warriors, mounting unlikely rebellions against much larger, better equipped, better-resourced, and seemingly invincible empires.

In both stories, the rebels defeat their enemies, in defiance of all reasonable expectations. They draw upon an invisible force that surrounds and binds everything that exists for guidance, support, strength, and resilience in their struggle against the evil empire.

Both stories highlight freedom against tyranny, hope over fear, good against evil, light against darkness.

Then there is the connection between Star Wars and the Hanukkah candles. There are really only a few things that make a menorah kosher. The candles (save the shamash) have to be level and in a straight line. That way, each flame is equally important and can be distinguishable from the other flames. The menorah upholds the distinctiveness and equal status of each flame. In so doing, it reminds us that our own individuality is precious, and simultaneously, that we are all fundamentally equal.

As a lifelong Star Wars fan, One of the things I have always loved about the Star Wars movies is its diversity and its egalitarianism. Even today, it’s rare to find a Hollywood blockbuster where the hero isn’t a white male. Yet, for over 40 years, the Star Wars films have been replete with heroes of all colors, backgrounds, genders, shapes, and sizes. This is especially true of the current trilogy, which features a beautifully diverse lineup of protagonists. Fine, some of those characters aren’t human. But there is a basic equality implied in the diversity of the Star Wars universe. There isn’t a gender or species hierarchy in the galaxy. By and large, characters relate to each other’s internal qualities, rather than their external features. It doesn’t matter if you are male or female, black or white, human or Wookie. It just matters what side you’re fighting for, what you’re doing to advance the cause of peace and justice, and how good you are at fighting the empire.

Perhaps that’s why the only candle permitted to be raised or elevated above the others on the menorah is the shamash, the helper candle. What distinguishes the shamash is not its external appearance, but rather what it does on behalf of the other candles. It helps them. It enables them to do what they’re supposed to do. It gives them light, and in so doing, increases the overall luminescence. The shamash’s prominence is not inherent. Just as in Star Wars, it’s earned by helping others and by spreading light.

One final thought: This newest Star Wars trilogy is set about thirty years after the original Empire is defeated and yet chronicles a familiar conflict. The Rebel Alliance and the Empire are gone, but the the Resistance and the First Order battle in their stead, implying that evil is never fully vanquished, that the struggle of light against dark is eternal.

Historical experience affirms this artistic assertion. The Maccabee’s victory was not a decisive triumph of good over evil, but, rather, a temporary one. The struggle is renewed in every generation. That’s why we keep lighting the Hanukkah candles year after year, to remind ourselves and our children that the work is not done. The war remains ours to fight. But the force is with us in the struggle.

About the Author
Rabbi Michael Knopf is co-editor of 'No Time for Neutrality: American Rabbinic Voices from an Era of Upheaval', now available on Amazon, and spiritual leader of Temple Beth-El in Richmond, Virginia. The views expressed in this article are solely his own, and do not necessarily reflect those of his congregation.
Related Topics
Related Posts