Sometimes, the answer is ‘no’
We just got up off the floor.
Tisha B’Av ends, the chairs go back to normal height, and then almost immediately it is Shabbat Nachamu. Comfort. From the lowest day on the calendar to the Shabbat named for consolation, with barely anything in between.
That turn is so fast it can feel fake. Like being told to cheer up before you were done.
And then you look at what we actually read this Shabbat, and it turns out the Torah is not being glib about it at all. Because Va’etchanan is the parsha of a man who asked for something with everything he had, and got told “No.”
He begged
The word “ואתחנן” does not mean he requested. It means he pleaded. It is the language of somebody asking for a favor he knows he has not earned.
The sages counted the gematria of that word, 515, and said that is how many times Moshe davened to be let into the land. Five hundred and fifteen times. However literally you take that, the point is unmistakable. He did not ask once and accept it gracefully. He hammered on that door.
He also, and this is the part people skip, tells us exactly what he wanted. Let me cross over and see the good land. That is it. He is not asking to rule it or settle it. He wants to see it. Forty years of desert, and he is asking for a look.
Enough
And the answer he gets is “רב לך.” Enough for you. Do not speak to Me about this matter again.
I do not know how to make that gentle. That is not a soft “no.” That is a “stop asking.”
If you have ever prayed hard for something and watched it not happen, you already know this feeling and you do not need me to describe it. The diagnosis that did not change. The person who did not get better. The thing you begged for with everything you had, and the answer was “no,” and the answer stayed “no.”
The Torah puts that story in the mouth of Moshe, which I think is deliberate. If anybody had the standing to get a “yes,” it was he. He did not get it. So whatever the reason is that our tefillot (prayers) sometimes go unanswered, it is not that we did not daven hard enough or that we are not important enough. That is worth knowing, because in a bad moment most of us quietly assume it is one of those two.
What Moshe does with the “no”
Here is what I keep coming back to.
Hashem tells him to go up the mountain and look at the land with his eyes. And Moshe goes and looks.
Think about what that takes. He is being shown the thing he cannot have. He could have refused. Nobody would have blamed him for saying I would rather not stand there and stare at it.
He goes and looks anyway.
And then he comes down and teaches. The entire rest of Devarim (Deuteronomy) is Moshe, holding the biggest “no” of his life, continuing to give everything he has to people who get to have what he does not. He does not go quiet. He does not go bitter. He does not spend his last months making sure everyone understands how unfair it was.
That is not a man who got over it. He clearly did not get over it. It is a man who kept going while still carrying it, which is a completely different thing, and a much more honest one.
Comfort said twice
Then comes the haftarah that gives this Shabbat its name. נחמו נחמו עמי. Comfort, comfort my people.
Twice. Why twice?
I have heard a lot of answers over the years. Here is the one that feels true to me. Because one time does not do it.
Nobody has ever been comforted by a single sentence delivered once. Real comfort is repetitive. It is the friend who calls again next week. It is showing up a second time and a third, long after the shiva ended and everyone else went back to their lives.
The word is doubled because comfort that only comes once is not comfort. It is a formality.
What comfort is not
Since it is Shabbat Nachamu, let me say the practical thing.
If you are the one trying to comfort somebody this week, the instinct is to explain. To find the reason. To say everything happens for a reason, or Hashem has a plan, or at least it was not worse.
Please do not lead with that. I say this with love, and knowing I have done it myself. Explanations mostly serve the person giving them. They clean the mess up so the comforter can stop feeling helpless. The person actually in pain usually hears something closer to: “Your grief is making me uncomfortable, so here is a reason to stop.”
The comfort in this haftarah is not an explanation. It never explains anything. It just says I am here; this is going to end; you are still my people.
You can do that. Sitting there and saying, “I do not have anything smart to say. I just did not want you to be alone with it” is worth more than every reason anybody has ever offered.
The comfort comes after
And notice the order, because the calendar is doing something on purpose.
We do not skip Tisha B’Av and go straight to Nachamu. We sit on the floor first. We read the Megillat Eichah (Lamentations) out loud. We let it be as bad as it actually is, and only then does comfort show up.
That order matters. Comfort that arrives before the grief has been felt is not comfort; it is a request to be quiet. But comfort that comes after, when somebody has let you be as broken as you actually were and then says, “Alright, come on, we are going to keep going” – that lands.
If you are in the Tisha B’Av part right now, you are not behind schedule. Nachamu is coming. It comes after. That is the whole design.
For this week
Do not measure your tefillot by the answer. Moshe did not get his and it was not a failure of tefilla, and it was not a failure of him.
Go look at the land anyway. Whatever you did not get, you are still allowed to look at the good in your life without it. That is not settling. That is what Moshe did.
Keep going while still carrying it. You do not have to be over something to keep living. Those were never the same thing.
Comfort somebody twice. And then again. The word is doubled for a reason.
Skip the explanation. Say, “I am here.” Say, “I do not know what to say.” That is enough and it is usually better.
And if you are somewhere near the floor right now and cannot see the turn coming, tell somebody. A friend, a rabbi, a professional. This week of all weeks, the calendar itself is arguing that it does not stay like this.
Moshe asked 515 times and heard “no.” Then he climbed a mountain, looked at everything he was not going to get, came back down, and taught the people he loved for the rest of his life.
He never entered the land. He is still the greatest of them.
–
Mental Health in the Parsha is a weekly series about the emotional wisdom hidden inside the Torah portion, and what it can offer us right now. These thoughts are meant for reflection and conversation, not as a replacement for professional mental health care.
