Shmuel Legesse
A Call to the Moral Debate the World Refuses to Face — A Black Jewish Voice Speaks for Israel and Global Jewry

Rabbi Sacks on Healing a Broken World

In our complex and often contentious world, we do not get to choose all the people with whom we share life. Like it or not, we live with people; we come from people; we need people to continue life. We cannot exist in isolation. Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks, the late Chief Rabbi of the United Hebrew Congregations of the Commonwealth, understood this truth more deeply than most. In his writings and speeches, he often reminded us that our humanity is bound up with the humanity of others, even those who frustrate, challenge, or oppose us. “The test of faith,” he wrote, “is whether I can make space for difference.”

From birth to the end of life, human beings depend on one another. The food we eat, the language we speak, the roofs over our heads—all come from the labor, creativity, and generosity of others. Even our identities are shaped through relationships. Rabbi Sacks saw this as part of God’s design. In The Dignity of Difference, he argued that no person, community, or culture has a monopoly on truth. We are each in possession of a fragment of wisdom; only together do we approach the fullness of understanding. Even those who trouble us are part of the larger human tapestry we cannot do without.

Living alongside people who think differently, or act in ways we find harmful, is one of life’s greatest challenges. Our instinct is to withdraw, to label them “other,” or to meet hostility with hostility. But Jewish tradition offers a higher standard: machloket l’shem shamayim, argument for the sake of Heaven. This does not mean avoiding disagreement. It means engaging in it without destroying the other’s dignity. The goal is not to win but to seek truth together. In our age of polarized politics and fractured societies, this teaching is more urgent than ever. Arguments about vaccines, climate change, war, or religion are often conducted as battles to defeat opponents rather than conversations to find shared ground. Rabbi Sacks taught us that societies are healthier when debate is not a weapon but a searchlight—pointing us toward wisdom that no one side possesses alone.

One of his most profound lessons was that listening, especially to those we find most difficult, is an act of moral courage. In a world where so many shout past one another, listening is countercultural. It requires humility, patience, and the willingness to be changed. When we listen, we acknowledge the image of God in the other person. We may not agree with them. We may even conclude that they are wrong. But in listening, we affirm their humanity and keep open the possibility of connection. That simple act, often dismissed as weakness, is in fact leadership. A leader who listens demonstrates respect and makes space for a future where adversaries may yet find common cause.

Rabbi Sacks often said, “We are enlarged by the people who are different from us.” That enlargement is not easy, it comes through tension, patience, and sometimes forgiveness. In his view, the health of society depends on our ability to turn strangers into neighbors and, sometimes, adversaries into allies. This is not about ignoring harm or injustice. It is about refusing to let bitterness become the final word in our relationships. Small acts of kindness—a respectful word, a willingness to help in a moment of need—can soften the hardest hearts and bridge the widest divides. In international affairs, where mistrust can escalate into violence, such acts of dignity can lay the groundwork for peace treaties. In families, they can make the difference between estrangement and reconciliation.

For me, as a Black African Jew from the Beta Israel community of Ethiopia, these teachings resonate deeply. I have seen how misunderstanding and prejudice can wound. I have also seen how dialogue, education, and shared purpose can heal. My community endured centuries of isolation in Ethiopia, yet we kept alive the dream of Jerusalem. Our survival was not only through faith but through our ability to live alongside those who were different from us, sometimes in hardship, sometimes in hope. When we were finally brought home to Israel in daring airlifts, our story testified that a people can endure separation and still carry forward dignity. That experience taught me that dignity is not a luxury in human relationships; it is a necessity.

The world today is filled with forces pulling people apart. Social media amplifies anger. Politics rewards outrage. Even within families, disagreements harden into estrangement. Rabbi Sacks insisted that this fragmentation is not inevitable. He reminded us that societies can choose paths of respect and reconciliation. The Torah teaches that every human being is created in the image of God. That single idea, he believed, could transform global politics if taken seriously. To see the image of God in another is to admit that their life has worth, their perspective has meaning, and their dignity must be honored. Without this recognition, diplomacy collapses into coercion, politics degenerates into violence, and communities fracture into hostility.

If we truly believe, as Rabbi Sacks taught, that “the world God created is one in which there is room for all of us,” then our task is clear: to make that room in our homes, communities, and nations, even for those we find most difficult. Especially for them. That does not mean ignoring injustice or excusing cruelty. It means confronting wrongs without denying the humanity of the wrongdoer. It means acknowledging that change, however slow, is always possible. It means trusting that respect is not weakness but the strongest foundation for peace.

We will not agree on everything. But we can refuse to let disagreement harden into hate. We can choose to meet the difficult not with dismissal, but with dignity. That choice, repeated daily in conversations, negotiations, and encounters, can slowly mend the fractures of our world. It is not easy. It requires discipline and humility. Yet it is the only way forward.

That is how we live together—not merely surviving one another, but learning from one another, in this difficult, beautiful, shared world. Rabbi Sacks left us with a vision both challenging and hopeful: a vision where human dignity is the cornerstone of coexistence. In fractured times, that vision is not optional. It is essential.

About the Author
I am a Black Ethiopian Israeli Jew, a scholar, diplomat, and upcoming author of Moral Diplomacy for a Broken World. I am calling on CNN, BBC, Sky News, Fox News, SBN, and Piers Morgan to host a public debate that includes the voices they have consistently ignored: Black/African/Ethiopian Jews/Israelis. The world hears endless commentary about Israel but almost never from those of us who represent Israel’s true diversity. It is time for an honest, global, moral debate about Israel’s identity, the nature of Zionism, the plight of Jewish communities worldwide, and the truth about who the Jewish people really are. For too long, media panels have portrayed Israel through a narrow racial and political lens. I challenge the international networks to include me in a live debate not as a token voice, but as a representative of millions of Jews of color whose story refutes the false accusations of colonialism and exposes the real moral complexity of this conflict. This is not a political manifesto but a moral movement: a call for peaceful, educational debate grounded in respect, evidence, and human dignity. Please contact me for peaceful, educational debate: educatordrshmuel@gmail.com With wisdom inspired by Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks, Dr. Legesse reminds readers that Judaism is not a religion of division, but of unity; not of power, but of purpose. Dr. Shmuel Legesse is an international educator, community activist, and diplomacy expert. He has served in the Israeli police force and worked as a detective for the Supreme Court of New York. He represented Israel's Knesset in international public affairs and holds a master's in community leadership and philanthropy from Hebrew University and a doctorate in international Educational Leadership and Administration from Yeshiva University, NY. educatordrshmuel@gmail.com
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.