Some kindness to strangers: Dentist’s gift aids the needy
What was I thankful for on Thanksgiving last year?
An ecumenical gift from an unexpected source. A gift that crossed religious and ethnic boundaries. A gift that grew out of an encouraging encounter with the medical profession.
With one member of the medical profession. In a setting that is usually nerve-wracking for me.
First, the setting: a dentist, 40ish, clean shaven, clearly from an Indian background (he speaks fluent Hindi and Gujarati) – the Asian country, not the United States. His patient: an Orthodox Jew, in his 70s, a native of Western New York who now lives in New York City. The location: a dental office in northeast Queens. The timing: early morning, mid-November in 2025.
I, the Orthodox Jew with a longtime fear of dental procedures, was seated in a dentist’s chair, an IV needle in my arm, before I was to be anesthetized for several hours of needed work and repairs in my mouth. The dentist, accustomed to scaredy-cats like me, put me at ease with calming words; after all, I would be asleep while he would be at work on my molars and bicuspids; and, he assured me, I would feel no pain when I awoke in the early afternoon. I felt better already, my nerves soothed.
Before the dentist was ready to proceed with the morning’s probing and extracting business, he reviewed the month’s upcoming schedule. Professional and businesslike but very approachable, he outlined what to expect – that day, and henceforth.
I would have to come back in two weeks for a post-oral surgery check-up, to see if everything was healing as expected, and if there were any unexpected problems; and to complete the crowns, etc. which my mouth required.
Two weeks from that date would be the week of Thanksgiving.
Could I come on a Wednesday, the day before Thanksgiving?
Yes. The office would be open, and I could schedule my appointment on that day.
Another question: could I eat turkey the next day, on Thanksgiving? Growing up with a mother who considered a traditional Thanksgiving meal, accompanied by obligatory rendering of thanks by everyone at the table, to be a near-religious, non-debatable requirement, I never miss a Turkey Day repast – formerly with family, now with friends close to my home in Queens. It would be unthinkable to let the day pass without a holiday meal and without a serving of Melleagris gallopavo, preferably some white meat.
But…
Maybe, I thought, my mouth would be too tender or raw from the follow-up tweaking to permit the chewing of fowl, stuffing, potatoes, etc.
No problem, my dentist assured me. “You can eat turkey the same day” – the day of the oral surgery.
“And are you buying the turkey for me?” I was kidding! It was a rhetorical, throwaway that a smart aleck like me is used to casting.
No problem, my dentist, clearly used to smart alecks, responded.
Confident that I would be able to join my friends in a fortnight for our now-accustomed Thanksgiving meal, I drifted off to sleep. When the effects of the anesthesia wore off in a few hours, I was, as my dentist had promised, totally pain free. Not even a dull ache. Whatever he had done in my mouth – crowns, tooth pullings, etc. – I did not ask for details – was a success. When I was sufficiently awake, I called for a ride from a local car service (New York City’s version of a pre-Uber/pre-Lyft taxi system) and went home.
Though my dentist told me I could eat whatever I wanted that day, I limited myself to liquids, like pureed soup, and other soft stuff like pudding. No sense taking a chance.
No problem. I ate without pain, and within a few days returned to my regular diet. The day after the oral surgery, I traveled out of town – in retrospect, foolishly – to a long-planned visit to friends in the Philadelphia area. When I checked my cellular phone, whose ringer I had put on vibrate to avoid disturbing fellow travelers on Amtrak, I noticed that I had received two calls from my dentist’s office.
They were calling to see how I was faring. When I did not answer the first call, they called again.
“We were worried when we could not reach you,” my dentist later told me. Patients do have complications after oral surgery. I, thank G-d, had none.
His office called a few more times in the next two weeks, to make sure that my recovery was proceeding apace. They were not pro forma calls; my dentist and his co-workers truly care about patients’ welfare.
I felt fine, I told his staff – or my dentist himself, who also called – each time they reached me.
Finally, time for my follow-up visit to his office. Erev Thanksgiving, as arranged.
This time, no anesthesia. Whatever he would be doing that morning would be a little uncomfortable (checking my gums, putting in the crowns, taking some X-rays, doing some cleaning), but would not require me being put to sleep, my dentist assured me.
He was right. He knew his business – an online review calls him a “dental pain specialist.” Or, in my case, no dental pain.
The morning’s work in my mouth took more than an hour. While my dentist was working on me, when my mouth was clear enough to carry on a conversation, we schmoozed some more. About his practice, and mostly about my remaining concern about what I would be able to consume the following day.
Yes, I could eat turkey.
I repeated my silly, not-really-a-question question: “And you’ll provide my turkey?” My dentist took the bait: “What kind of turkey do you want?” “A kosher one,” putting the subject out of my mind as soon as I answered the question.
My appointment over, I was ready to call a car service for a ride home.
My dentist, out of sight at my side, plopped a big, weighted-down shopping bag on my lap.
What was inside?
To my surprise, I saw a frozen, 14-pound Empire turkey. A kosher turkey. I was shocked; I had in no way expected, or wanted, my dentist to give me a turkey for Thanksgiving. I had been kidding all along, doing shtick. But my dentist, a mensch, took me, and my religious fealty, seriously. He takes care of his patients, even when they’re not sitting in his dentist’s chair. He apparently wanted to show me, post-dental procedure, that I would indeed be able to safely eat turkey that Thanksgiving.
I sputtered. I protested. I didn’t really want a turkey. It’s all yours – take it! I looked at the turkey’s label. It cost my dentist $67.71.
He put his money where my mouth was.
Nearly $70 is a hefty price for a turkey, even for a well-paid medical professional to pay.
I was stuck with something I had not expected.
What would I do with a big frozen turkey?
I called Alexander Rapaport.
Rapaport, a Chasidic Jew from Brooklyn’s heavily Chasidic Boro Park neighborhood, raised in a Vizhnitz home, is the co-founder and executive director of Masbia (masbia.org), a two-decade old food pantry and soup kitchen under Orthodox auspices that serves more than two million meals to its “customers” in the Greater New York area every year on a non-sectarian, ethnically-diverse basis. In other words, many Christians and Muslims and members of other faith groups number among the men and women who get much of their food from Masbia, one of the city’s most-respected outreach humanitarian organizations.
I knew Rapaport well, having reported on Masbia’s altruistic activities several times over the years.
Masbia (Hebrew for “satiate”) has three feeding-and-distribution sites, two in Brooklyn and one in Queens, a few blocks from my apartment. While the pair of locations in Brooklyn serve a primarily Chasidic and non-Chasidic haredi, kashrut-observant clientele, the one near me is geared to the needs of the large, often-indigent, not-always-kashrut-observant population of Jews with roots in the former Soviet Union.
“Alex,” I told him on the phone, “I’m at the dentist. I’m getting in a car service in 20 minutes and will be dropping off a frozen, 14-pound Empire turkey.” I explained how I, an unmarried guy who heats most of his meals in a microwave oven, and had no need for the bird, and was going to a friend’s for the secular-yom tov meal the next day, came into possession of the frozen turkey.
I could tell that my story amused and delighted Rapaport. He would be glad to accept the turkey. He would be back in Brooklyn on Thanksgiving, but directed me to the mashgiach kashrut supervisor at the Queens site to whom I should hand the bag that contained the turkey. I followed Rapaport’s instructions.
My neighborhood Masbia site would be open on Thanksgiving, offering holiday meals and food supplies that clients could carry away.
A 14-pound turkey, according to AI, is a significant source of nourishment; it typically feeds about a dozen people.
My dentist’s gift would be put to good use; instead of donating it to one family, the Masbia staff would thaw it and prepare it and serve it to the folks who came to Masbia on Thanksgiving; it would enable several people to enjoy a healthy and hearty holiday meal, in the company of other people who would not be alone.
All three Masbia sites would be busy on Thanksgiving. To prepare for its larger-than-usual work load, Masbia sponsored “pack-a-thons” at two major local synagogues, one in Manhattan (historic Shearith Israel, on the Upper West Side, which announced last Thanksgiving that it was partnering with Masbia to open a “relief annex” food pantry) and one in Great Neck, Long Island, where volunteers put together boxes of Thanksgiving-oriented kosher food supplies to be distributed to recipients to “meet the ongoing demand.”
Masbia, Rapaport told me, served a total of about a hundred turkey-based meals at its three sites during the week of the holiday last year – using a total of several dozen turkeys, my dentist’s among them.
I informed my dentist what his donated turkey’s fate would be – giving sustenance to many needy people in my neighborhood; fulfilling Maimonides’ second (of eight) levels of charitable giving, where neither the giver nor the recipient knows each other’s identity.
My dentist was delighted. He was doing “a real mitzvah,” I told him. He appreciated the interfaith sentiment, as well as his opportunity to spread – to strangers – some holiday generosity. Like Masbia, he ended up performing a good deed on a non-sectarian basis.
If, as the ubiquitous ads for Levy’s rye bread once boasted, “you don’t have to be Jewish” to enjoy the firm’s popular sliced product, you don’t have to be Jewish to let people enjoy some slices of Empire turkey.
I doubt that the paths of Alex and my dentist will ever cross – they have little in common, geographically, religiously or vocationally. But for one day – one holiday that is not a part of either’s faith – their concepts of chesed (acts of kindness) and prema (loving-kindness) intersected. In the form of a 14-pound frozen turkey.
