Chaim Y. Botwinick

Teaching Derech Eretz in an Age of Entitlement

Our children are not rude. Our kids are wonderful. They are bright, they are caring, they can learn Gemara, they do mitzvot and they can code an app and give tzedaka.

But many of them have grown up in a world that has taught them quietly and constantly that the world revolves around them.

Their smartphones are  personalized for them. Their Netflix knows what they want to view. Their Uber and Lyft come directly to their door. Their food is delivered in 20 minutes, exactly how they ordered it, and their sneakers and sweatshirts have their initials embossed  on them.

We call it convenience. Chazal would call it chinuch for entitlement.

And then we wonder why a 6th grader argues with a teacher about a due date, why a 9th grader leaves his lunch on a tray in the lunchroom, and why a 10th grader thinks saying “thank you” is optional.

It’s not because they are bad kids. It’s because no one has intentionally taught them derech eretz. We assumed it would just happen. It doesn’t.

“Derech Eretz Kadma LaTorah” means that  derech eretz came before Torah. [Vayikra Rabba 9:3]

That doesn’t mean that derech eretz is more important than Torah. It simply means that Torah cannot live without it. You cannot build a second floor if the first floor has collapsed.

So how do we as parents, schools and communities rebuild the first floor?

First, we must redefine derech eretz. It’s not only about manners but a way of life. So if you tell a teenager “have good manners,” he ends up hearing “be fake so adults will like you.”

That’s definitely not what derech eretz is. Manners is how you hold your fork and knife at a dinner table . Derech eretz on the other hand begs the question, do you see and appreciate other human beings?

The words “derech deretz” literally means “the way of the land.” The way a human being is supposed to walk on this earth. It’s the understanding that I am not the center of the universe, and that  Hashem is, and other people are not accessories to my story. I am but  a supporting actor in theirs.

As we know, “entitlement” suggests that “the world owes me.” Derech eretz on the other hand says “I owe the world.”

Why this Generation is so Vulnerable?

We have to be honest about three forces that are more responsible for forming our kids than our schools,

The first is the “On-Demand World“ where everything in their life is instant and customized.  Except people. People are not on-demand. A rebbee cannot be paused. A friend cannot be skipped if you’re bored. But, if you’ve never had to wait, you experience people as annoying.

The  second is  the “Affluence Bubble” Many of our day school families, Baruch Hashem, are comfortable. Their children have never seen their parents worry about finances. They have a closet full of  expensive stylish shoes. When you never experience lack, you lose the ability to feel gratitude. And without gratitude, you cannot have derech eretz.

The Torah says: the “Ben Sorer U’Moreh,” rebellious son”begins  or starts not with sin, but with entitlement, “Zolel V’Soveh.  He starts as  a glutton and a drunk.” He wants more, now.

The third is the  “Praise Generation“where we told every child “you are amazing!” Which is true. But we forgot to tell them  that “you are amazing, and you still have to clean up after yourself.” So they feel amazing, but not responsible.

We cannot fix this condition with a poster that reads “Respect!” We have to teach it like a skill.

The following is a  Four-Step Curriculum that actually works:

  • Teach gratitude before greatness (K-3: The Thank You Muscle), Entitlement cannot live where gratitude lives. It’s like light and dark. We have to make “Thank you” a reflex, not a reminder.

The “Who Made This Possible?” Game.

Before a child eats his snack, before he uses a pencil, ask: “Who made this possible?” Mommy bought it, Abba earned the money, the truck driver drove it to the store, Hashem made the wheat grow. One snack has 10 people behind it. Suddenly eating is not “I get,” it’s “I receive.”

In K-3, every day must end with three thank yous — and you cannot thank your best friend. You must thank someone you don’t usually thank like the  school janitor, the security guard, the lunch perso, the kid who held the door.

Rav Eliyahu Eliezer Dessler writes that the difference between a giver and a taker is only one question: Does he say “What can I give?” or “What can I get?” Thank yous train the giver.

Teach Service Before Selfie (4th-8th: The Invisible Jobs)

Entitled kids think some jobs are beneath them.  Those with derech eretz kids know and appreciatethe fact that no job that helps another person is beneath them.

A Practical tool: The Avodat Beit Hamikdash Rotation.

In the Beit Hamikdash, Kohanim did jobs that looked like janitor work such as sweeping ash, cleaning the Menorah, washing the floor. In the Beit Hamikdash, the most holy people did the most humble jobs.

Create a rotation where your 6th, 7th, 8th graders do the invisible jobs such as emptying trash in the Beit Midrash, wiping down tables after lunch, setting up chairs for an event, helping a 1st grader zip his coat. And they do it WITHOUT being thanked. Without a certificate or fanfare. That’s is exactly the point.

The Chazon Ish said: The test of a person is how he does a job that no one will see and no one will praise him for.

We must stop giving our kids leadership titles and start giving them service towels.

Teach Boundaries Before Freedom (9th-10th)

Entitlement grows when a child never hears “No” and makes it stick. Our kids need to hear from teachers they respect.

For example…..“No, I will not accept that work late because you were tired. You need to learn to manage time.”

“No, I will not change your grade because you tried hard. Effort matters, but results matter too.”

“No, you may not talk to me that way, even if you are upset. We can talk tomorrow when you can speak with Derech Eretz.”

This is not mean. This is love. The Gemara says: “Kol HaMevater Al Kavodo, Kavodo Machul“the one who forgives his own honor, his honor is forgiven. That is for the teacher’s own ego. For the student’s chinuch, we must protect the honor of Torah, of the classroom.

Saying  the word “no” with calm and warmth is the greatest derech eretz lesson. The world will not bend to you. You must bend to what is right.

By the time a student reaches high school, entitlement looks like talking to someone while looking at your phone. or when a human is talking to you, your eyes are up. Phone face-down. “V’HaChai Yiten El Libo” which suggest  that the living must give his heart to the living. You cannot give your heart while scrolling on you ipade or smartphone.

It is essential  that our students are accustomed  to use words like thank you, sorry, mazal tov, I need help . You say it with feet, not with  thumbs. Walk over to the person. AI sends texts. humans physically show up.

Practice choosing to be last, last to get food last to be served, first to help.

The great Rav Chaim Volozhin’s talmidim said that Reb Chaim was always the last one out of the Beit Midrash so he could turn off the lights. He was the Rosh HaYeshiva.

A Important  Note to Parents and to Teachers as they are Watching our Entitlement

This is the most challenging and difficult  part to write.

Our children will not have derech eretz if we do not have derech eretz. This  means if we complain about the school in front of our kids,  they learn that you don’t have to respect authority.

If we yell at the waiter, they learn that people who serve me are less than me.

If parents  demand a grade change for our child they learn that rules are not for me but for other people.

If we don’t thank our spouses, our children  learn that gratitude is for strangers, not for family.

The most powerful derech eretz shiur is not a shiur at all. It’s when a principal stops and picks up garbage off the floor. It’s when a mother says “Please” and “Thank you” to her own child. It’s when a rebbe says to his class: “I was wrong yesterday when I spoke sharply. mechila.” (my apology).

Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky said I wondered why the Torah tells us Avraham’s servant Eliezer was old, and Lavan was wicked. It  was to teach us that derech eretz is seen in the small details and  how a servant acts, and how a brother-in-law speaks.

Always keep in mind that our children are watching and observing every small detail.

Another  rule of thumb is to not aspire to raise children who are impressive, but rather children who are good natured. “Impressive” may help get the child accepted  into a college but “good gets the child into Olam Haba.

A child with derech eretz knows that he is not entitled to anything, but he is responsible for everything.

Hashem is the center, not him.

And, every other human being is an image of HaShem, not a tool for his success.

If we teach that, we really teach it, not just hang it on some wall in the classroom. And if we teach that concept properly, we won’t just cure entitlement, but we will bring derech eretz back to its rightful place –  right before Torah.

About the Author
Dr. Chaim Botwinick is a senior executive coach and an organizational consultant . He served as president and CEO of the central agency for Jewish education in Baltimore and in Miami; in addition to head of school and principal for several Jewish day schools and yeshivot. As an Influencer, he has published and lectured extensively on topics relating to education, resource development, strategic planning and leadership development. Dr. Botwinick is Author of “Think Excellence: Harnessing Your Power to Succeed Beyond Greatness”, Brown Books, 2011
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.