Freda Rosenfeld
Freda Rosenfeld

The Case for Remembering Bilhah and Zilpah

At the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, with some extra time on my hands, I decided to explore a topic that has troubled me over many years. Why, when we remember the mothers in our prayers/tefillot, do we exclude Bilhah and Zilpah. Why do we count only four? (Sarah, Rebecca, Leah and Rachel.) After all, we aren’t remembering them as wives, but as mothers. And they had four children between them, constituting a third of the twelve tribes.[1] Research showed me that in the 1990s, some women did bring their plight to light, but, unfortunately, I haven’t seen any concrete changes in the liturgy. I would now like to restate the case for their inclusion in our prayers and consciousness.

I have asked the question, “Why not Bilhah and Zilpah?” to rabbis and around Shabbat tables, in forums and study groups. Mostly people say, “interesting question,” then, “I have no idea.” The most interesting answer I got was from a woman named Rena, who said that by the time the Tefillot were enacted, the tribes of Gad, Naftali, Asher and Dan (the sons of Bilhah and Zilpah) were already lost. The most common answer I got was to see the Gemara Brachot 16B (see below, translation by Sefaria):

“The Sages taught in a baraita: One may only call three people patriarchs, Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, but not Jacob’s children. And one may only call four people matriarchs, Sarah, Rebecca, Rachel, and Leah.

The Gemara asks: What is the reason for this exclusivity with regard to the Patriarchs? If you say that it is because we do not know whether we descend from Reuben or from Simon, so we cannot accurately say our father Reuben, for example, if so, with regard to the Matriarchs as well, we do not know whether we descend from Rachel or from Leah, and we should not call Rachel and Leah matriarchs either. Instead, the reason the sons of Jacob are not called patriarchs is not for that reason, but because until Jacob they are significant enough to be referred to as patriarchs, but beyond Jacob, they are not significant enough to be referred to as patriarchs.

This serves as an introduction; although older people are often referred to with the honorific: Father so-and-so, it was taught in another baraita: One may not refer to slaves and maidservants as father [abba] so-and-so or mother [imma] so-and-so. But they would call the slaves and maidservants of Rabban Gamliel “father so-and-so” and “mother so-and-so.”

The Gemara asks: Is a story cited in order to contradict the previously stated halakha? The Gemara answers: There is no contradiction;
rather, because Rabban Gamliel’s servants were significant, they were addressed

with these honorifics.”

Both of these answers only made me want to recognize and honor these women more.  Let’s start exploring this and – I hope – correct these wrongs:

First, let’s address the suggestion that Bilhah and Zilpah aren’t included in our liturgy because these tribes were lost. This is probably accurate, yet heartbreaking on two levels: One reason is that just because they are “out of sight” doesn’t make them any less important or relevant. We are now living in truly magical and wonderous times. We have been blessed with seeing the ingathering and awareness of Jews from all over the world coming to live in or even just visit – Israel. Our dream of being a united and whole Israel is being realized. From the broken and homeless Jews of the Holocaust to the teaming Russian Jews held captive behind the Iron Curtain – They are coming!  The Jews of Ethiopia and India and Jews from the Arab world are living in and contributing to the Israeli community – They are coming. And then, there are small but growing communities of Jews in Indonesia, Uganda, South America, Madagascar and many other places reclaiming or claiming their Jewish heritage. By reciting Bilhah’s and Zilpah’s names we thank Hashem for those who returned and speak of our hope in finding more Jews and welcoming them back to the fold. By not invoking their names we are not opening our hearts and minds to accepting all our brothers and sisters back.

We are also blessed to be living in times when women and their roles in society are growing more and are being more respected. Thank G-d, women are no longer dependent on men to thrive. By honoring Bilhah and Zilpah we are saying that all moms and all women are important, and their voices and legacies should be and are heard.  We say that “handmaidens” are important people in their own right, and we say that no one is a slave to any other human. We say that we are all responsible individuals whose task it is to be the best person we can be and to be free to serve Hashem on our own. If  Rabban Gamliel’s servants were significant – which is how they should be thought of – I think that that should also be true for all wo/mankind.

We also open our eyes to those women and men whose lives are still not their own, the women and men of our modern world who are still tied to lives controlled by others and we say, “we hear you. Your voice and your individuality are important.”

Next time you invoke the mothers in prayer, don’t just say their names by rote, but say them with kavanah and add Bilhah and Zilpah and truly ask G-d to help us all.

[1] The twelve sons and one daughter of Jacob:

  • Children of Leah: Reuven, Shimon, Levi, Yehuda, Yissachar, Zevulun and Dina
  • Of Bilhah: Dan and Naftali
  • Of Zilpah: Gad and Asher
  • Of Rachel: Joseph and Benjamin
About the Author
Freda Rosenfeld is a lactation consultant, enthusiastic Jewish learner, and environmental and Jewish activist, living in Jerusalem and Brooklyn.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Comments