Jonathan Carp

The Cathedral He Could Not See

AI image of the cathedral
AI image of the Cathedral

On David Lynch’s The Elephant Man

The first time Frederick Treves looks at John Merrick, we are not allowed to look with him. David Lynch keeps his camera on the surgeon. A curtain is drawn back in a dim sideshow booth, the showman barks his patter, and on Anthony Hopkins’s face we watch something pass: pity, shock, and something quicker and less comfortable, the alertness of a doctor who knows he is seeing what he may never see again. A single tear runs down his cheek. Lynch withholds Merrick’s body for a long time after that. He wants us to notice the looking before we are permitted to do it.

I know that face from the inside.

Years ago I cared for a woman with trigeminal trophic syndrome, a rare condition in which the face, robbed of its normal sensation, is slowly worn open. In her case the wound had reached through into a sinus, leaving a large hole in the center of her face. It was striking to see and hard to explain, and I gave it hours: reading, reasoning, turning the puzzle over in my mind. I felt for her from the first day. But I have to admit that in those early weeks the diagnosis stood in front of her. She came fully into view only slowly, through more conversations, through her family, through the ordinary details by which we come to know anyone. Sympathy was there from the beginning. The relationship needed time to catch up with the diagnosis.

That gap, between feeling for someone and truly seeing them, is the quiet subject of Lynch’s 1980 film. It is why the film has stayed with me for so long.

Shot in black and white, The Elephant Man plays less like a period drama than like a memory of Victorian London: smoke and steam, gaslight and machinery, a city that seems to be grinding its people down. John Hurt, buried under layers of makeup, plays Merrick almost entirely with his voice and his eyes, and it is one of the great performances of its kind. We meet Merrick as property. Bytes, the sideshow manager who calls himself his owner, beats him and exhibits him for coins.

Treves rescues him, or seems to. He brings Merrick to the London Hospital, and before long he is presenting him to the Pathological Society, standing him nearly naked before a hall of men in frock coats while describing his deformities in a calm, clinical voice. The scene is meant to be the opposite of the sideshow. Lynch frames it so that we feel how closely it rhymes with one.

This is the film’s honesty. Treves is not a villain. His curiosity is real, but so is his wish to help, and the film never pretends a doctor could do good work without curiosity. What it asks is harder: what happens when the desire to help lives in the same heart as the desire to examine, explain, and display? Later, unable to rest, Treves asks his wife whether he is a good man or a bad one. The film does not answer him. It gives him credit for asking, and it does not let good intentions settle the question.

What the film will not say in words, it shows in a railway station. Bytes kidnaps Merrick and drags him across the Channel to be exhibited again. Merrick escapes and makes his way back to London, only to be pursued through the station by a jeering crowd and cornered in a public lavatory. There, with nowhere left to run, he cries out the film’s most famous line: “I am not an animal! I am a human being!”

The Talmud teaches that one who shames another in public is like one who sheds blood. The image is almost physiological: the color drains from the humiliated face, as though blood had actually been spilled. As a physician, I find that precise. Shame is a wound, not merely an insult. The crowd in the station repeats the sideshow in a new place. It turns Merrick’s body into public property and refuses, absolutely, to meet him as a person.

And then the film turns toward the light. Mrs. Kendal, the celebrated actress played by the absolutely stunning Anne Bancroft, comes to visit. She brings him a signed photograph and a copy of Romeo and Juliet. They read the play aloud together, and when Merrick answers her lines from memory, she tells him that he is not an Elephant Man at all. He is Romeo.

I don’t think Merrick has to teach Mrs. Kendal to see him. She arrives already able to. That is what an artist’s imagination can do: recognize grace before anyone has proved it, and hear the depth of feeling beneath a voice that others only hear as strange.

They talk about the model Merrick is building, a cathedral he can glimpse only partly from his hospital window. He can see the spire, he explains. The rest he must imagine.

That model is the film’s central image. A cathedral cannot be built from what is visible alone; the builder must imagine what is not yet there. The same is true of seeing another person. A body, a diagnosis, or a first impression gives us something real, but it never gives us the whole person. We have to imagine the life that cannot be read from the outside: what someone loves, fears, remembers, believes, and hopes for. Einstein remarked in a 1929 interview that imagination is more important than knowledge. In this film, imagination does not replace knowledge. It keeps knowledge from becoming the whole story.

Pirkei Avot offers a related teaching: do not look at the vessel, but at what is inside it. The metaphor needs care, though. Merrick’s body is not an incidental shell around a “real” Merrick hidden within. It is part of his lived experience, and part of what others must learn to encounter without turning it into a spectacle. The task is not to look past his body but to look at it without forgetting him.

Mrs. Kendal sees his gentleness, his faith, his courtesy, his delight in a visit, a book, a beautiful face, an evening at the theater. He meets cruelty without hatred and without demanding retribution, and he remains open to beauty and kindness. That quality is moving, but we should be careful not to turn it into an expectation we place on people who suffer. Merrick’s dignity does not depend on his being grateful, forgiving, or unusually gentle. Those qualities help others recognize what is already there. They do not earn him his humanity.

Near the end, Merrick tells Treves that his life is full, because he knows he is loved. His words do not turn his suffering into a blessing; his life has not been made fair, and nothing has been undone. They tell us what he has managed to make of a life that others kept trying to reduce to his appearance. Treves, for his part, has stopped being only the one who gives. Their friendship has become mutual. Merrick is no longer simply a recipient of care. He has become someone whose presence has changed the doctor.

That night Merrick finishes his cathedral and signs it. Then he takes away the pillows that have propped him upright his whole life, and he lies down flat to sleep, the way other people do. Lynch leaves the meaning to us, but the gesture is unmistakable. The last thing we see Merrick do is not a symptom. It is a choice, the choice of a man who wants, for once, to rest like everyone else.

The crowd in the station is easy to condemn. Treves is harder to judge, because he is both doctor and man: curious, ambitious, compassionate, and capable of recognizing when his first way of seeing has failed. His responsibility is not only to keep Merrick safe. It is to see the man beneath the case, and to let that recognition change how he acts.

I think of my patient, and of how long it took me to see past the wound I was trying to explain. An unusual case deserves hours of thought. The patient deserves to remain present through every one of those hours.

The film leaves the same responsibility with us. We begin by looking at Merrick because he is extraordinary. We have to learn to see that his inward life is not extraordinary at all: his longing to belong, his gratitude, his faith, his capacity for wonder are simply human. His appearance is the spire we can see from the window. The rest of the cathedral we have to imagine, and the film asks whether we are willing to.

About the Author
Jonathan Carp, MD, is a physician and writer interested in Jewish thought, moral responsibility, and the challenges of modern life. He writes reflective essays that explore how Jewish ideas about meaning, suffering, and obligation intersect with culture and lived experience.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.