Tova Herzl

The Death Penalty: A Lesson from South Africa to The New Knesset

A memory that has stayed with me from my adolescence in South Africa in the 1960s and 1970s is the media coverage of executions. Only later did I fully understand what lay behind those reports: the laws had been written by whites; the judges were white; and the overwhelming majority of those hanged were black.

Here is a statistic I came across while researching this article: between June 1982 and June 1983, nearly half of the black men convicted of murdering white people were executed. Yet not one of the 31 white men convicted of murdering black people was hanged.

How was this possible? The law specified what constituted extenuating circumstances, and in their absence the judge’s discretion was severely restricted. Much like the Death Penalty for Terrorists Law passed by Israel’s Knesset in March 2026, which applies to Palestinians in the West Bank who are neither Israeli citizens nor residents, the death sentence was effectively the default punishment.

In South Africa, there was no jury; cases were decided by a judge, and the prosecution was not even required to request the death penalty. Under Israel’s new law, a unanimous decision by the judges is not required. Nor does it reflect the spirit of an ancient Jewish legal tradition, according to which a Sanhedrin – the supreme Jewish judicial body in antiquity – that executed even one person in seven years was called “destructive.” In both cases, the law’s rigid provisions severely restrict judicial discretion, reducing the judge to little more than a rubber stamp.

Another searing memory from those years is reading Cry, the Beloved Country, Alan Paton’s novel about racial injustice in South Africa. I am not suggesting that the Hamas-led terrorists who took part in the October 7 massacre were victims of their circumstances, as the young Black man who is hanged in the novel might be understood to have been. But beyond the familiar arguments against capital punishment, the book highlights another point: a state execution does not necessarily bring healing or relief to the victim’s family.

Let me be clear: there is no need to equate apartheid-era South Africa with Israel today in order to learn from South Africa’s experience about the dangers of imposing an irreversible punishment within an unequal legal system.

In 2001, shortly after Nelson Mandela’s presidency had ended, I arrived as Israel’s ambassador to in a very different South Africa. Mandela’s release from prison in 1990 by South Africa’s last white president, F.W. de Klerk – who would later share the Nobel Peace Prize with him – was part of a series of steps that paved the way for negotiations and national reconciliation. These included a suspension of executions.

Among those involved in the difficult negotiations to end apartheid and transition to democracy was Tony Leon, a Jewish member of Parliament. His father, Ramon (Ray) Leon, had been a judge. After retiring from the bench, he became an active campaigner against the death penalty.

In explaining his opposition to capital punishment, the elder Leon regarded imposing it as an act in which a human being arrogates to himself the role of God. Yet once he became a judge, he understood that he was bound by his professional oath to apply the law. He later recounted that it took him weeks to recover from imposing a death sentence – he was tormented by questions such as whether the outcome might have been different had the defense lawyer been more capable, and, above all, why a person’s life should depend on the random composition of those present in a particular courtroom.

This is not the place to examine whether obedience to the law absolves a judge of moral responsibility for his decisions, or whether a judicial system can preserve its humanity when required to operate under such rigid legislation.

But those members of Knesset who have been designated to undo some of the legislation enacted by Israel’s last parliament, and who focus on prominent measures such as the politicization of judicial appointments, should also ask whether leaving this particular law on Israel’s statute books is compatible with the country’s self-definition as a Jewish and democratic state.

No less important, they should ask what retaining the law would say about the direction Israel wishes to take regarding its continued rule over the West Bank (Judea and Samaria, in Israeli terminology). Is Israel choosing a future of continued confrontation and repression of a population that has lived under its control for nearly six decades? Or does it seek to create conditions for negotiations, however difficult, with the aim of reaching reconciliation and resolution in the future?

About the Author
Tova Herzl served twice as congressional liaison in Washington DC, was Israel's first ambassador to the newly independent Baltic states, and took early retirement after a tumultuous ambassadorship in South Africa. She is the author of the book, Madame Ambassador; Behind The Scenes With A Candid Israeli Diplomat.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.