Toasting “L’chaim!” to PCATI – The Public Committee Against Torture in Israel

The thousands of members of “L’chaim! Jews Against the Death Penalty” from across Israel, the USA, and the world wholeheartedly salute the sacred work of the Public Committee Against Torture in Israel (PCATI) in seeking to abolish the death penalty in Israel. PCATI has been at the public forefront of the campaign in Israel against the two death penalty laws – and related military orders that the Israeli Knesset passed in March and May 2026, opening new paths for the state to execute Palestinians. The March law made death the default sentence for certain Palestinians convicted of terrorism-related killings in West Bank military courts, reviving a punishment that had been de facto dormant for decades. Blatantly racist, that legislation does not apply to Israelis charged with the same crimes. The May law created a separate tribunal to prosecute Palestinians accused of participating in the Oct. 7 attacks, with no indictments filed as of October. Since then, PCATI has responded vigorously to every step of the implementation of these archaic laws.
PCATI’s Charge Against Death Penalty
Image: The official logo for the Public Committee Against Torture in Israel (PCATI).
As its website explains, PCATI has been active since 1990 as a human rights organization in the struggle to eliminate torture in Israel in all forms. It represents Israelis, Palestinians, refugees, and migrants who have undergone torture or inhuman, cruel, or degrading treatment by the Israeli authorities, including the Israel Security Agency (ISA – “Shabak”), the Israel Police, the Israel Prison Service (IPS), the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), etc. It staunchly defends victims injured during imprisonment, detention, demonstrations, interrogations, and otherwise, and represents prisoners in legal efforts to improve their imprisonment conditions. The staff and volunteers at PCATI believe that torture and abuse of any kind, in any situation, are incompatible with moral values, democracy, and the rule of law. PCATI’s vision is an Israel free of torture and abuse where people who have suffered physical and psychological injury receive recognition and justice.
PCATI and L’chaim align in many significant ways regarding capital punishment. PCATI recognizes the incontrovertible fact that the death penalty constitutes torture, often physically, and always psychologically. L’chaim has been emphasizing this point for years, drawing upon its correspondence with individuals who are both Jewish – like Jedidiah Murphy in Texas – and not-Jewish – like Christa Pike in Tennessee – who have counted down their months, weeks, days, hours, and minutes to execution.
PCATI also understands viscerally what L’chaim has articulated ad nauseam publicly since its inception in 2020: that the death penalty, at its core, is born out of the base impulse for vengeance. Noam Hofstadter, the head of the public advocacy department at the Public Committee Against Torture in Israel, recently emphasized this reality in an Haaretz op-ed that carries the telling headline: “Israel Is Now Valuing Revenge Over Life and Justice.”
The Executive Director of PCATI, the indomitable Israeli-Jewish human rights lawyer and activist Sari Bashi, poignantly articulated the foundational role of revenge in capital punishment in a November 5, 2026 conversation entitled “Justice or Vengeance?” with Dr. Michal Ben-Josef Hirsch of the Political Science and Legal Studies Department of Suffolk University in Boston, Massachusetts. Bashi initially argued – quite correctly – that the new Israeli legislation cannot be separated from a legal system that already subjects Palestinians and Israeli settlers in the occupied West Bank to different standards of prosecution and legal protection.
Bashi then adroitly framed the legislation as part of a larger question about justice and vengeance. Bashi attributed public support for the proposed capital trials to frustration with the government’s failure to investigate the intelligence and military failures preceding the Oct. 7 attacks. She next rightfully pointed to the political orientation of some of the communities attacked on Oct. 7, accurately describing them as predominantly left-leaning and opposed to capital punishment. “A lot of the victims and survivors of the October 7th [2023] attacks, just by chance, were liberal leaning,” said Bashi. “So the communities they attacked on the border tended to be Zionist left communities, people who ordinarily don’t support the death penalty.” That distinction raised a fundamental question for Bashi about whose interests the legislation ultimately serves, leading her to comment, “That’s an important community, because it’s supposed to be justice for them.”
Bashi’s criticism, however, went well beyond whether the trials would satisfy survivors. She argued that the legislation reflected a political climate increasingly willing to treat punishment as a response to collective grievances, particularly when the legal consequences differ according to whether the accused is Palestinian or Israeli. “I think that the country is moving toward a place of increased thirst for vengeance and violence and we’re not seeing it only in the death penalty,” said Bashi. Bashi described the growing violence as a sign of the difficulty of maintaining political control, which forces a reliance on force.“Violence is the weakest expression of power,” said Bashi. “And so as the power weakens, it has to use more and more violence to keep people in check.” This natural tendency, combined with the understandable, but in no way justifiable, broader political appetite for vengeance in the wake of the October 7th massacre, has served as a driving force for the renewed push for capital punishment across Israel.
L’chaim could not agree more. Members have said the same in every case, without exception. This has included public opposition to the death penalty not only in Israel, but anywhere. This includes the death sentence that the United States government handed down to the perpetrator of the Pittsburgh Tree of Life Synagogue shooting in 2018, the Washington, DC Israeli Embassy shooter in 2025, and the flydubbai terror attack in 2026, and the ongoing plague of executions in Iran, to name but a few recent examples.
Next Steps: Marching Together Toward Abolition
Regarding Israel, L’chaim stands steadfastly with PCATI, emphasizing as well the existential danger that a return to executions poses for Jews globally, including in Israel. Alongside PCATI, L’chaim unequivocally supports the petition now before the Israeli Supreme Court to repeal the death penalty. L’chaim underscores what Bashi stated toward the end of her aforementioned interview – that the immediate priority for human rights advocates now is preventing its first execution. “Part of the battle’s work, the struggle we’re building now,” Bashi said, “is to see how we can mobilize opposition in every stage to prevent the first execution.” L’chaim joins PCATI’s call for opposition at every step now, as the aptly-named “machinery of death” that is capital punishment begins to unfold across Israel.
L’chaim joins PCATI in the hope that Israel can redeem itself on the world stage on this issue. Israeli representatives conveniently were absent at a recent preliminary United Nations vote on a resolution for a global moratorium on the death penalty, to which a record high of 133 countries voted “yes.” In 2022, the previous Israeli government was among a supermajority of 125 countries at the United Nations to do the same. Indeed, more than seventy percent of the nations of the world recognize that the penalty of death is a slap in the face of the most fundamental human right of all – that of life itself. The current Israeli government likely will not join these other nations in the upcoming UN resolution vote this December. All the more reason, then, for Jewish death penalty abolitionists the world over to continue to push back against megalomaniacal politicians like Israel’s Minister of National Security Itamar Ben-Gvir and his sadistic death wish, which puts Israel squarely on the wrong side of history.
L’chaim will continue to raise the banner of PCATI and the countless other Jewish organizations condemning state-sponsored murder. L’chaim has lauded the accomplishments of many Jewish abolitionists over the years, including innocent Jewish death row survivor turned activist Sunny Jacobs, Z’L, in Florida. L’chaim publicly toasted Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro when he promised to work toward death penalty abolition in that state in 2023. The group likewise toasted California Governor Gavin Newsom earlier this month for the phenomenal humanitarian feat of his historic decision to commute the sentences of all 548 individuals on California’s death row. Members now join in raising a proverbial glass to the dedicated staff of PCATI, with Sari Bashi at the helm, as they continue the herculean effort of leading the charge in Israel, seeking to remind the citizens of that nation what death penalty abolitionist Elie Wiesel knew from experience and exhorted about capital punishment; namely, that “Death should never be the answer in a civilized society.”
And so, a toast to PCATI: L’chaim…to Life!
Cantor Michael J. Zoosman, MSM
Jewish Prison Chaplain
Co-Founder: L’chaim: Jews Against the Death Penalty
Advisory Committee Member: Death Penalty Action
