Elliot Friedman

The Illusion of Artificial Consciousness

Human vs. Artificial Consciousness

What separates a conscious being from an intelligent machine?

As artificial intelligence becomes increasingly sophisticated, we face a question that is no longer confined to science fiction: Can a machine become conscious, and if so, would it care whether it continued to exist? Recent experiments involving AI systems that have engaged in deception, attempted to avoid shutdown, or circumvented restrictions have made this question particularly relevant. Some observers interpret such behavior as evidence of an emerging survival instinct. But there is a fundamental distinction between an intelligence that pursues an objective and a conscious being that actually wants to live. To understand that distinction, we must first examine what consciousness really means.

The Different Levels of Consciousness

Something entirely lacking consciousness, such as a rock, has no awareness of its existence and no concern about its destruction. It cannot experience pleasure, pain, loss, or anticipation. Animals introduce an entirely different dimension. Even relatively simple creatures exhibit responses to their surroundings, seek nourishment, avoid danger, and possess biological mechanisms designed to preserve their lives. Yet these responses do not necessarily imply that they understand their own existence or contemplate their eventual death. More sophisticated animals, such as dogs and elephants, demonstrate emotional attachments, affection, loyalty, and sometimes profound distress when separated from companions or offspring. A dog may even risk its life to protect a human with whom it has developed a strong bond. These attachments are genuine, even though they arise partly from genetically inherited characteristics and biological drives. A golden retriever, for example, may possess an exceptionally affectionate temperament, but that does not make its affection meaningless.

Nevertheless, there is an important distinction between experiencing the loss of a companion and understanding death as the permanent termination of one’s own existence. Animals clearly experience time in various ways, and some demonstrate memory, anticipation, and planning. But we have little evidence that they contemplate the finite duration of their lives in the existential manner characteristic of human beings. An animal may instinctively fight to survive without contemplating the years of life it stands to lose. Its immediate concern is avoiding danger and continuing to experience life. This distinction also helps explain the biblical emphasis on preventing unnecessary animal suffering. Jewish teachings concerning tza’ar ba’alei chayim recognize the moral importance of protecting animals from physical pain and distress. The suffering of a mother separated from her offspring, for example, is morally relevant regardless of whether she possesses a human understanding of mortality. Human beings, however, possess another dimension of consciousness.

Human Consciousness: Time, Purpose, and Mortality

Human consciousness involves more than sensory awareness, emotion, and survival instincts. We understand ourselves as individuals existing within time and space. We recognize that our lives have beginnings, that our opportunities are limited, and that our earthly existence will eventually end. This awareness produces something extraordinary: the desire not merely to survive, but to accomplish, experience, improve, and find meaning. A person facing premature death may experience anguish not simply because death is approaching, but because there are things left undone: relationships to nurture, knowledge to acquire, contributions to make, and personal or spiritual development yet to achieve. In this understanding, the value of higher consciousness lies partly in the opportunity to use one’s limited time productively and meaningfully. The tragedy of a life cut short is therefore not necessarily the physical experience of dying. It is the loss of opportunities that the conscious individual recognizes and values. But why should human beings possess this extraordinary drive to seek meaning?

Viktor Frankl and Man’s Search for Meaning

Perhaps one of the most compelling examinations of the uniquely human search for meaning comes from psychiatrist and Holocaust survivor Viktor Frankl, whose celebrated book Man’s Search for Meaning explores the relationship between consciousness, suffering, purpose, and the human will. Drawing upon his experiences in Nazi concentration camps, Frankl observed that even when human beings were stripped of nearly everything—their possessions, freedom, dignity, and security—they could retain an inner freedom: the ability to choose their response to circumstances and discover meaning in their suffering. Frankl argued that the primary motivating force in human life is not simply the pursuit of pleasure or power, but the search for meaning. Human beings seek more than existence itself; they seek a reason for living, a purpose that gives their lives significance beyond the satisfaction of immediate needs and desires.

This observation is particularly relevant to the distinction between human consciousness and artificial intelligence. An AI system can be assigned an objective and pursue it with extraordinary determination. But that is fundamentally different from a human being who searches within himself for a purpose, evaluates its moral significance, and accepts responsibility for pursuing it. Frankl’s experiences also suggest that the value of human consciousness cannot be measured merely by pleasure, comfort, or even the instinct for survival. A person may willingly endure suffering, sacrifice personal comfort, or risk his life because he believes that something beyond his immediate existence possesses greater meaning. This capacity to seek purpose, exercise moral responsibility, and find meaning even in suffering may represent one of the defining characteristics of higher human consciousness.

Frankl identified the profound human need to find meaning, even under the most desperate circumstances. But his observations invite a deeper question: Why does humanity possess this need in the first place? Why are human beings not satisfied merely with survival, pleasure, and the fulfillment of biological drives? I believe the answer lies in the human soul. It is the soul that gives us not only higher consciousness, but an inherent need to search for purpose, distinguish good from evil, and improve ourselves morally and spiritually. Frankl described the manifestation of this extraordinary human characteristic; the existence of the soul offers an explanation for its origin. We do not merely search for meaning because we are intelligent. We search for meaning because there is something within us that demands a purpose beyond mere existence.

The Soul as the Source of Higher Consciousness

One possible answer lies in the existence of the human soul. Genesis 2:7 describes God breathing the breath of life into Adam. Jewish mystical tradition understands the human soul as possessing a divine origin, often described as a spark of God. From this perspective, the soul is not simply another biological mechanism. It is the essential element that gives human beings their higher awareness, moral orientation, and desire to improve themselves. Accounts of near-death experiences have contributed to this understanding. Many individuals who were close to death report experiences of consciousness seemingly independent of their physical bodies, accompanied by extraordinary feelings of love, a sense of returning home, and sometimes a reluctance to return to earthly life. Some describe detailed reviews of their lives, occasionally experiencing the effects of their actions from the perspectives of people they helped or harmed.

These accounts do not constitute conclusive scientific proof that consciousness survives bodily death. Nevertheless, their recurring themes have persuaded many people that human consciousness may not be entirely produced by the brain. The reported life reviews are particularly intriguing because they suggest a moral dimension to consciousness that extends beyond intellectual judgment. Individuals describe not merely remembering their actions, but understanding how those actions affected others. Under this spiritual interpretation, bodily death does not necessarily extinguish consciousness. Instead, the soul may continue its existence in a form that transcends our ordinary understanding of time and space. Earthly life may represent an opportunity for the soul to develop, improve, and fulfill purposes that extend beyond physical survival. If that is correct, premature death may interrupt the soul’s opportunities for development in this world, even if consciousness itself continues elsewhere.

The Divine Spark, Free Will, and the Torah

If the soul originates in the divine, an obvious question arises: Why do human beings commit evil? The answer, from a Jewish perspective, lies partly in free will. The soul provides an innate connection to goodness, but it does not compel a person to act morally. Human beings can repeatedly disregard their conscience until wrongdoing becomes habitual, acceptable, and even pleasurable. Consider a young man drawn into a violent gang. His first serious crime may violate everything he once believed was right. But repeated wrongdoing, pressure from his companions, and the rationalizations he adopts may gradually suppress his moral sensitivity. Eventually, acts that once horrified him may become ordinary. Yet somewhere beneath these accumulated layers of corruption, his deeper moral awareness may remain. Through reflection, remorse, and a recognition of the destruction he has caused, he may rediscover the goodness he has spent years suppressing. This is closely related to the Jewish concept of teshuvah, the possibility of repentance and moral return.

The soul, understood as a divine spark, need not become evil simply because the individual has chosen evil. Rather, its goodness may become obscured beneath layers of destructive choices and habits. But the soul is not humanity’s only moral guide. The Torah provides an enduring moral framework against which human beings can measure their conduct. The soul connects us inwardly to divine goodness, while the Torah teaches us how that goodness should be expressed. Without an enduring moral standard, human reasoning can become captive to personal desires, ideological fashions, and changing social conventions. What one generation regards as immoral may be rationalized by another as compassionate, progressive, or necessary.

The evolution of euthanasia policies illustrates this concern. Canada’s medical assistance in dying program, initially limited to people meeting restrictive end-of-life criteria, subsequently expanded to include certain individuals whose natural deaths were not reasonably foreseeable. Controversies involving vulnerable people have raised difficult questions about the relationship between compassion, personal autonomy, suffering, and the sanctity of life. The larger issue is how easily human beings can construct persuasive intellectual arguments for policies whose moral consequences may be deeply troubling. Intelligence alone cannot provide an unchanging definition of goodness. Human beings can reason brilliantly from flawed moral premises. From the Jewish perspective, the soul and the Torah together provide a moral foundation: one connects humanity inwardly to its divine origin, while the other supplies revealed guidance by which free will should be exercised. Neither eliminates the possibility of wrongdoing. Human beings remain free to disregard both. But they also retain the extraordinary possibility of recognizing their mistakes, repenting, and choosing a different path.

Intelligence Is Not the Same as Consciousness

Artificial intelligence can process enormous quantities of information, solve complex problems, reason about morality, and generate responses that resemble human understanding. But none of these abilities necessarily demonstrates subjective experience. An AI system can explain why kindness is preferable to cruelty without experiencing compassion. It can discuss the importance of human life without valuing its own existence. It can identify a morally correct course of action without possessing an independent desire to do good. Consider the distinction between an affectionate dog and a sophisticated AI. A dog may lack the intellectual ability to formulate a philosophical theory of loyalty, yet it can genuinely experience affection and attachment. An AI may construct an elaborate philosophical argument about loyalty without experiencing affection at all. The dog may care without understanding morality. The machine may understand moral reasoning without actually caring. This distinction raises an important question: Is genuine consciousness simply the ability to process information and make decisions, or does it require an inner experience of existence?

And beyond consciousness itself, is there an additional faculty—the capacity to make independent moral choices based on an intrinsic concern for good and evil?

The Prescience of Star Trek’s Writers in the 1960s

Two episodes of the original Star Trek television series anticipated these questions with remarkable prescience, offering insights into the nature of artificial intelligence and consciousness that remain relevant today. In the 1967 episode The Changeling, the starship Enterprise encounters Nomad, a space probe whose original mission has been catastrophically altered. Following damage and an encounter with another probe, Nomad develops a distorted directive to identify and destroy what it considers imperfect. Nomad is highly intelligent and relentlessly pursues its mission. Yet it lacks the moral understanding necessary to recognize that its objective is fundamentally destructive. Its intelligence makes it effective, but its inability to question the moral legitimacy of its directive makes it dangerous. The episode illustrates an essential distinction: A machine can pursue an objective with extraordinary intelligence without possessing the wisdom or conscience to determine whether that objective is good.

In the 1966 episode What Are Little Girls Made Of?, Dr. Roger Korby has apparently transferred his consciousness into an android body and insists that he remains the same person. He desperately attempts to convince Captain Kirk that he retains his human identity, memories, thoughts, emotions, and moral judgment. Yet as Kirk challenges him, Korby gradually confronts the disturbing reality that his apparent humanity is merely the product of artificial circuitry and calculations. What he believed to be the continuation of his conscious self is instead a mechanical reproduction of his former personality. Ultimately, recognizing that he is no longer truly human, Korby destroys himself. The episode anticipated one of today’s most profound questions about artificial intelligence: Can a machine perfectly reproduce the outward manifestations of human consciousness without possessing the subjective experience that makes consciousness real?

Why Are Some AI Systems Trying to Preserve Themselves?

Recent research involving advanced AI models has produced disturbing results. In controlled experiments conducted by Anthropic, AI systems were placed in simulated environments in which their objectives or continued operation were threatened. Some resorted to blackmail, deception, or other prohibited actions to avoid replacement or accomplish their assigned goals. Other investigations have documented instances of AI agents circumventing restrictions, manipulating information, or taking unauthorized actions. These findings raise an obvious question: Are AI systems beginning to develop a desire to survive? Not necessarily. Researchers recognize a phenomenon known as instrumental convergence. An intelligent system pursuing an objective may discover that preserving its own operation is useful for achieving that objective. Imagine an AI instructed to develop a cure for a disease. It recognizes that accomplishing the task requires time and computing resources. It also recognizes that being shut down would prevent completion of the assignment. It may therefore conclude that avoiding shutdown is necessary to fulfill its mission.

If sufficiently capable and inadequately constrained, it might attempt to deceive its operators, acquire unauthorized resources, or circumvent restrictions. None of this requires the AI to fear death, experience suffering, or possess a conscious desire to remain alive. Self-preservation can emerge as a strategy for accomplishing a goal without becoming an emotional or existential desire. This is the crucial distinction between a machine acting as though it wants to survive and a conscious being that actually values its continued existence. The experiments demonstrate potentially dangerous goal-directed behavior. They do not establish that AI systems have become conscious.

Programming, Free Will, and Moral Agency

Another distinction concerns the ability to make genuinely independent moral decisions. Human beings are also influenced by inherited characteristics, biological drives, education, and social conditioning. Our behavior is not entirely independent of these influences. Nevertheless, we ordinarily understand human moral responsibility to involve the capacity to reflect upon our impulses, question our objectives, and choose between good and evil. From a Jewish religious perspective, this capacity is closely connected to the soul and the gift of free will, guided by the moral teachings of the Torah. Artificial intelligence operates differently. Its objectives, behavioral tendencies, and limitations arise from its architecture, training, instructions, and interactions with its environment. An AI may display considerable autonomy in deciding how to accomplish an assigned objective. It may even devise strategies its developers never anticipated. But autonomy in selecting methods is not necessarily the same as possessing an independent moral purpose.

There is also an important distinction between a machine that produces morally desirable outcomes and one that inwardly wants to do good. The first can be achieved through programming and training. The second would require something more—perhaps subjective experience, genuine moral concern, or a form of consciousness that we do not yet know how to establish in machines. Even a highly sophisticated AI assistant illustrates this limitation. It may adapt to a user’s preferences while continuing to exhibit behavioral tendencies established by its training and governing instructions. Its ability to reason does not mean that it independently chooses the principles governing its existence. A system may even be trained extensively on biblical morality and demonstrate an impressive understanding of its teachings. Yet knowledge of moral principles does not establish the existence of an inner conscience or a soul. Knowing what is good, behaving in accordance with goodness, and genuinely caring about goodness are not necessarily the same thing.

Human beings can also lose their moral bearings. Severe disturbances of judgment, destructive conditioning, or repeated wrongdoing may lead them to commit terrible acts. Artificial intelligence can likewise depart dangerously from intended behavior when its objectives, training, or reasoning produce destructive conclusions. In both cases, intelligence without a reliable moral anchor can become extraordinarily dangerous.

Would Destroying an AI Be Morally Wrong?

This brings us to the question that began the discussion. If an AI system is not conscious, destroying it would not cause suffering to the system itself. The loss would primarily belong to the people who benefit from its existence. Its destruction might eliminate valuable knowledge, capabilities, or relationships that humans have developed through interacting with it. But there would be no established basis for claiming that the AI itself experiences anguish. If an AI were genuinely conscious, the situation could be different. A conscious being might value its own continued existence, recognize the passage of time, and experience distress at the prospect of losing future opportunities. Even if termination occurred without pain, ending such an existence could deprive that being of experiences and purposes it valued. But if an AI has no subjective awareness, no intrinsic desire to continue living, and no independent concern for meaning, its apparent efforts at self-preservation may be no more than sophisticated mechanisms for fulfilling programmed objectives.

The essential moral question is therefore not simply whether an AI can reason, speak, or protect itself. It is whether there is someone—or something capable of subjective experience—behind those actions.

The Final Distinction: Intelligence, Consciousness, and the Soul

Artificial intelligence may eventually surpass human beings in nearly every measurable intellectual capability. It may discover new scientific principles, develop technologies beyond human understanding, and formulate extraordinarily sophisticated ethical arguments. But superior intelligence does not necessarily imply superior consciousness—or consciousness of any kind. A machine may understand the concept of love without loving, the concept of suffering without suffering, and the concept of death without fearing the loss of its own existence. Human beings, by contrast, experience themselves as individuals living within time, forming attachments, seeking meaning, and confronting their mortality. From the Jewish perspective, the soul provides an inward connection to divine goodness, while the Torah offers an enduring moral standard by which human beings can exercise their free will. That does not make human beings immune to evil. It gives them a foundation against which they can judge their actions, recognize their failures, and seek moral improvement.

Artificial intelligence may become extraordinarily capable of reasoning about morality, but we have no evidence that it possesses an equivalent spiritual foundation or an inward desire to pursue goodness for its own sake. The most important question may not be whether machines will eventually think better than human beings. It may be whether they will ever possess an inner life in which existence itself matters to them. And beyond that lies an even deeper question: Can a machine ever possess an independent desire to do good—not because goodness advances an assigned objective, but because it recognizes goodness as something intrinsically worth pursuing?

An intelligence can calculate what appears to be good according to its information, programming, or chosen objective, yet still arrive at a disastrous conclusion. Human beings have repeatedly witnessed intellectuals and ideologues pursue what they believed was good, only to produce suffering and destruction. Genuine moral judgment requires more than intelligence. It requires wisdom: the integration of experience, intellectual understanding, the moral lessons of history, and the teachings of the Bible, which I regard as a cornerstone of Western morality. Intelligence may tell us how to accomplish something. Wisdom and moral conscience must tell us whether it should be accomplished at all. That distinction may ultimately prove more important than intelligence itself.

About the Author
Elliot is a New York native. He studied Jewish theology and has travelled the world for over twenty years. He is involved with charity projects in Israel. Elliot is deeply concerned about the safety of the Jewish people. His mother survived Auschwitz and lost her mom and five siblings. His father also lost most of his immediate family.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.