The International Criminal Court’s Godfather moment
The International Criminal Court is once again in crisis and the European Union is clearly deeply concerned about the ebbing credibility of one of their most closely held pet projects.
Establishing the European Union’s umbilical connection to the International Criminal Court is not difficult. It is an open secret. The distinguished British academic Stephen Hopgood has described the ICC as “a European vanity project”. It has been openly described by European academics as an “EU Court”. The Europeans certainly have a vested interest in the ICC. They have dropped two billion dollars on the Court, roughly two-thirds of its total budget to date. And the EU is noted for being ruthlessly transactional. He who pays the piper really does call the tune.
The reality is that the ICC is a bought and paid for subsidiary of Europe Inc. and has acted as an instrument of European – and especially French – foreign policy in Africa for most of its existence. Despite proclaiming itself to be an international court, the Court has in fact only ever “convicted” Africans (in some very dodgy trials) since its establishment and until 2022 had only indicted Africans. All this was rather helpfully confirmed by French ICC Judge Marc Perrin de Brichambaut, a Vice-President of the Court, in a May 2017 talk he gave at Beijing Law School in which he candidly stated that European countries were “paying the bills for the ICC” and described African states as “a group of 54 countries who provide the suspects and the accused” for the Court.
The ICC was sold to the World at its founding conference in Rome in 1998 as a treaty-based body which would only bind its member states (referred to by the ICC as States Parties). The Court has had a very rocky time since it opened its doors in 2002. In a desperate attempt to move away from the Court’s racist docket, repeated courtroom fiascos and most recently the allegations of sexual misconduct surrounding the subsequently fired ICC Prosecutor Karim Khan, the Court’s eager political activists have deliberately distorted the Rome Statute in order to commence proceedings against non-ICC states including America’s key ally, Israel. Having been categorically promised at the Rome conference that the ICC would stay in its lane, this recent ill-judged and transparently illegal “judicial creativity” was the final straw for the United States.
The United States has now threatened to dismantle the Court “brick by brick” and has imposed economic sanctions and travel restrictions on the Court and a number of its judges and employees: No computer software, no credit cards or bank accounts, no Amazon, Ebay, Netflix, Airbnb or Ubers, no more Alexa or Grand Theft Auto VI, and no more holidays at Walt Disney World. Naturally, mass panic has broken out within the Court and its largely Millennial staff, its non-governmental organisation groupies and the wider human rights industry. Internal discontent within the ICC States Parties – which had already seen countries such as Burundi, The Philippines, and several African Sahel states including Burkina Faso, Mali, and Niger relinquishing ICC membership – has intensified. Following the latest US sanctions more ICC members ranging from Latin America, Africa and the Pacific have also announced their intention to leave the Court. Many more are paying lip service to the Court but not their membership fees. Even more embarrassingly, in a recent vote on 2 November at the United Nations to protest at the American sanctions, 34 of the ICC’s nominal 123 States Parties voted against or simply ignored the resolution, despite frantic lobbying, cajoling, bribery and blackmail by European diplomats.
The ICC’s existential crisis has spooked the European Union. The EU’s avid support for the court, from conception to statute and beyond, over almost 25 years, is a matter of record. The EU has additionally tied the Cotonou Agreement, a comprehensive multi-billion euro economic partnership treaty signed in June 2000 between the EU and the African, Caribbean, and Pacific states, to ICC membership. Any Global South state that chose not to ratify the Cotonou Agreement in its entirety and continue to play nicely with the ICC would lose hundreds of millions of euros in “development” funds and be denied EU market access.
The European mask has well and truly slipped. Previously this European economic blackmail of Global South countries to join and stay in the ICC had been whispered sotto voce, under the radar, in discrete demarches and non-papers and over canapés at diplomatic parties. The EU is now resorting to blackmail by megaphone to bolster its rapidly unravelling judicial experiment. The European Union is now demanding that Global South states slavishly support the ICC. Kaja Kallas, the EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs, previously the prime minister of Estonia, has resorted to out and out threats, warning Global South countries in receipt of European funds not to disengage from the Court or else:
“Clearly, we’re supporting the ICC . . . you have the pressure from the other side saying that . . . countries need to leave the ICC. Now, we are giving huge funding to these countries. Now, we have to be ready on our side to say . . . you also have a price to pay if you don’t follow the rules, because these are the basic principles of the European Union.”
It would seem that a basic principle of the European Union, as clearly outlined by Mrs Kallas, is that of blackmail. There is, of course, something quintessentially European about a Northern blond Baltic EU bureaucrat invoking a financial version of the Sicilian horses-head in the bed threat with real world consequences for any Third-World ICC States Party and Cotonou Agreement signatory uncowed enough to question the credibility of the ICC. Don Corleone and Luca Brasi would have been proud of her.
Pan-European imagery aside, this Godfather moment in EU-ICC history starkly demonstrates that the situation must be very bad indeed for the European Union to have to fall back on crass institutional blackmail to support the International Criminal Court.
