Shayna Netanya
An American Olah In Israel

The Privilege Paradox: Why American Jews Won’t Make Aliyah

Warning: This article may cause feelings of discomfort and reflection.

In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, millions of Jews arrived in America, passing through the gates of Ellis Island. They came with little money, did not speak the native tongue, and the hope that their children and subsequent generations would not have to work as hard as they did. Between 1881 and 1924, more than 2.5 million Eastern European Jews immigrated to the United States, fleeing persecution, poverty, and a continent that had repeatedly reminded them of their place in society.

These Jews worked long hours in sweltering garment factories and earned meager livings operating pushcarts. Their children translated for them while they spoke Yiddish at home. They lived in crowded tenements, endured discrimination, and built their lives in a country where they were not always welcome. These Jews were resilient because they had to be to survive, and they knew it.

But their dream was eventually realized.

Their descendants entered universities, started law firms and corporations, became doctors, and contributed greatly to American political institutions. Generations later, many became thoroughly assimilated into the American machine, increasingly accepted into the category of “white.”

And they prospered and gladly accepted this privilege.

According to Pew Research Center’s 2020 study of American Jews, approximately half lived in households earning $100,000 or more annually, considerably higher than the national average. The descendants of immigrants who once struggled to communicate in English became members of one of America’s most economically successful religious communities.

Today, approximately 70% of American Jewish voters identify with or lean toward the Democratic Party. Half of American Jewish adults described themselves as politically liberal in Pew’s 2020 survey. They speak the language of privilege, systemic inequality, and social justice.

They know the vocabulary. They can identify privilege in everyone around them.

But can they identify it in themselves?

I would argue that this inability to confront their own privilege is one of the reasons so few American Jews make Aliyah.

And the numbers are extraordinary.

The Galut Mindset

In 2020, Pew Research Center estimated that approximately 7.5 million Jews lived in the United States. Yet in 2025, only approximately 3,733 people made Aliyah from America. That is equivalent to roughly 0.05% of the American Jewish population in a single year. One immigrant for every 2,000 American Jews.

Think about that.

A community of millions, many of whom proudly proclaim their Zionism, their love of Israel, and their unwavering commitment to the Jewish state. Yet when presented with the opportunity to actually live in the Jewish homeland, overwhelmingly, they remain in America. Even as Jew-hatred escalates throughout the West, increasingly disguising itself as anti-Zionism, the vast majority of American Jews refuse to make Aliyah.

I believe this has much to do with what I call the Galut mindset.

A Galut mindset is one in which Zionism exists comfortably as an intellectual position, a political identity, or a charitable cause, but rarely as a personal obligation. It is the mindset of endless appeasement and hasbara to those who will never accept them. Of constantly explaining ourselves and choosing to turn your pockets out so your leftist friends accept you and stop calling you a “zionazi”. It is selfish in nature and has nothing to do with advocating for Israel.

It is Zionism in theory, but not in practice.

Of course, no community is monolithic. I know courageous, outspoken American Jews who refuse to bend to antisemitism. I also know American Jews whose family responsibilities, finances, or circumstances make Aliyah genuinely difficult. It is not these Jews I am speaking of.

But I am not interested in pretending that American Jewish comfort has nothing to do with the decisions people make. Because the statistics present a contradiction that deserves examination.

According to the Anti-Defamation League, there were 3,697 recorded antisemitic incidents in the United States in 2022. In 2023, that number surged to 8,873. In 2024, it reached a historic high of 9,354. And in 2025, despite declining from the previous year, the number remained at 6,274 incidents. That is approximately 70% higher than in 2022.

Seventeen reported antisemitic incidents every single day. And the ADL’s 2025 audit found that physical assaults reached their highest recorded level, even as overall incidents declined.

So what are American Jews waiting for?

How much more hatred must they experience before they begin seriously questioning whether the comfort of America is worth the price of remaining there? Why is a community that speaks so passionately about Jewish survival and continuity rejecting the homeland that would welcome them with open arms and subsidization?

And what I find particularly revealing is the reaction of certain American Jewish “activists” to those of us who actually leave. In the online activism space, I have encountered American Jews who deride Jews making Aliyah as “deserters.” I have been condescended to by people insisting that Israel “needs them” to survive and called “Erev Rav” for making Aliyah.

Apparently, sitting in America and arguing on social media constitutes a greater contribution to the Jewish state than actually becoming one of its citizens and paying taxes to the Jewish homeland.

What an extraordinary expression of privilege.

The Israeli Mindset

The Israeli mindset could not be more different.

The image of the tanned Sabra working the land, defending the country, and serving in the IDF remains one of the most powerful symbols of the Jewish national rebirth. Israel is also a country shaped by Jews whose families came from Morocco, Iraq, Yemen, Tunisia, Iran, Ethiopia, Poland, Russia, Ukraine, and dozens of other places.

In America, Jewish identity is increasingly filtered through the language of racial categorization. White Jews. Brown Jews. Jews of color. Ashkenazi privilege. Mizrahi oppression. As though Jewish identity can be adequately understood through an American racial framework.

In Israel, these histories are lived rather than merely theorized.

In my experience as an American Olah, the obsession with classifying Jews by skin color that dominates American Jewish conversations does not happen here by and large. In my first two weeks in Israel, I became adopted by an Ethiopian Jewish family. They spoke Hebrew, identified as fully Israeli and we made no distinction regarding race or melanin content as we hugged.

A Jew whose family came from Tunisia can have blonde hair and blue eyes.

A Jew whose family came from Ukraine can have olive skin, thick curly hair, and dark features.

Jewish history is not a pantone chart.

And yet I have watched American Jewish “activists” attempt to project their racial hierarchies and insecurities onto a society whose history, politics, and ethnic composition they all too often barely understand.

The controversy surrounding actor Ariel Stachel and questions of Jewish representation in theater reflects how intensely these conversations can become entangled with American ideas of race, identity, and authenticity. Ashkenazim race to uplift “Jews of color” to prove they’re one of the “good whites” and the Mizrahim complain they didn’t get a part in a Broadway show. As a former actor myself of Latino descent, you aren’t going to get every role and them’s the breaks, kid.

In America, identity is a competition for recognition of oppression as currency.

In Israel, Jewish identity is recognition we are a strong force to be reckoned with.

It is the exact opposite.

Which is why I suspect there is so much resentment and animosity towards those of us who exhibit the strength to say goodbye to our families, our pets, our belongings, our status and our home countries to set out for a life of meaning, belonging and never having to be a victim ever again. It is a projection of their own inadequacies.

Because in the oppression Olympics, if you are strong that makes you the “oppressor”. That’s why American Jews stay: they want to be recognized as a special minority instead of living as the strong majority.

Jews in the Galut have personally called me a “coward” for making Aliyah.

Imagine that.

I was physically assaulted by a group of Islamist antizionists in America. I endured something that almost none of the slacktivists will ever encounter: real world physical violence. And when I’ve asked these condescending “influencers” whether or not they’ve endured this type of violence suddenly the mic goes silent.

Olim exhibit extraordinary resilience in the face of persecution abroad and discomfort assimilating while here in Israel. Yet people sitting comfortably in their American homes have called me a coward for moving to what they describe as a “war zone.”

I have been told to “examine my privilege” by people who have never examined their own.

I have been told that Israel would somehow be unable to survive without the contributions of American Jews who have no intention of living here.

But while that finger wags at me in my home in Netanya, remember that four fingers are pointing back at you.

Support for Immigrants, but Never an Immigrant Themselves

This is perhaps the most glaring contradiction of all.

Approximately seven in ten American Jewish voters align with the Democratic Party, a political coalition in which immigrant rights and opposition to restrictive immigration enforcement are prominent causes. Many American Jews passionately advocate for immigrants, denounce ICE and write op-eds advocating for Latino families. They discuss structural inequality, economic marginalization, and the indignities experienced by people attempting to navigate an unfamiliar country.

As someone who is both Mexican and Jewish, I have often found the tone of these discussions patronizing. Because there is a difference between advocating for immigrants as a person who thinks of themselves as “white” while being unwilling to become one yourself. Part of why I knew I could be resilient enough to make Aliyah is because I come from a family of immigrants. This isn’t the first time, but for me it will be the last.

And this is where I believe American Jewish privilege becomes especially visible.

In America, a successful Jewish professional may possess wealth, education, influence, social standing, and complete fluency in the dominant language.

In Israel? That same person may struggle to open a bank account. They may be unable to explain themselves to a government employee. Their professional credentials may not transfer. Their salary may decrease. God forbid they take a working class job while they acclimate and learn Hebrew.

Suddenly, the person patting the heads of “brown” immigrants in America is being treated just like them in their imaginations: In essence, they lose their status and privilege of being wealthy and white. Except that isn’t what happens in Israel. Israeli’s are helpful of Olim and my experience is of complete strangers treating me like family. Far more so than any American Jew ever has.

I came to Israel as an adult woman who had spent decades building a life in America. I had professional experience. I spoke the language. I understood the institutions. I knew how to navigate the society around me.

Then I made Aliyah.

Suddenly, I was the immigrant. I was the woman struggling with Hebrew. I was the person trying to understand bureaucracy, employment, healthcare, transportation, and an entirely different cultural mindset. My American professional experience did not magically translate into Israeli professional status. My American confidence did not automatically make me fluent in Hebrew. My American identity did not spare me the challenges of starting over.

And I would do it again.

Because I did not make Aliyah expecting to preserve every comfort I had in America. I made Aliyah knowing I would sacrifice some of them and to make myself more uncomfortable because I knew I would grow from the process.

It is easy to celebrate immigrants when someone else is doing the immigrating, isn’t it?

It is much harder when you are the one standing at the government counter, unable to understand the person speaking to you. No American Jew has the right to call any Olim less resilient than them.

The Price of Comfort

A recent Pew Research Center report has now provided demographic evidence consistent with what Israeli author Orr Leschziner warned about in his March 2026 book, Juggernaut: A Paradigm Shift on Antisemitism.

Leschziner argued that the Jewish diaspora was entering a period of profound demographic and cultural decline, driven by assimilation, intermarriage, and the gradual erosion of Jewish identity within the societies Jews had worked so hard to enter.

And now Pew is projecting the same numbers: By 2070, Israel will be home to approximately 62% of the world’s Jews by religion, compared with 46% in 2020. America’s share will decline from approximately 39% to 26%. And the American Jewish population is projected to lose approximately 1.2 million people, while Israel’s Jewish population grows from 6.8 million to 11.1 million.

But tell me again how much Israel “needs” American Jewry when their President just announced all military aid to Israel will be cut off by 2027. Most Israeli’s I know are actually grateful that the American leash will now be cut so we can do as we please in the region. But you ask an American Jew and they turn it into an opportunity to express their outrage towards their arch enemy, Donald Trump.

Allegiance, Identity, and the Courage to Begin Again

For me, appeasement was never an option. The hatred I experienced in America was not something I was willing to continue enduring, especially after it became real-world violence. I was not interested in spending the rest of my life explaining why Jews deserve to exist or being a good little dhimmi.

So I did something about it instead of bitching about it online. I made Aliyah.

I sacrificed familiarity, professional standing, financial security, and the ease of living in the country where I had spent most of my life. Not because I thought Israel would be easy. But because I knew where I belonged. The distinction, for me, is one of allegiance. I realized while still living in America that my deepest national attachment was to Israel. I had spent years hearing antisemites accuse Jews of possessing dual loyalties, or of placing Israel above America.

And eventually I confronted a question: If my allegiance was truly to the Jewish state, why was I still living in a country where I no longer felt safe or wanted?

The answer, for me, was clear.

The Frog in the Pot

There is a familiar metaphor about a frog sitting in a pot of water. The temperature rises gradually. The frog adjusts. And by the time the danger becomes undeniable, it is too late. I think about this metaphor when I watch the response of American Jews to the rise in antisemitism. The hatred grows. The threats become more explicit. Jewish institutions increase security. Students conceal their identities and businesses are boycotted.

And still, the conversation so often returns to the same reassuring phrases:

“It will get better.”

“It can’t happen here”

I hope all of you in the diaspora understand German and Iraqi Jews thought that too. German Jews were deeply integrated into German cultural, professional, and intellectual life before Nazism destroyed that world. Iraqi Jews had lived in Mesopotamia for more than two millennia before persecution, political upheaval, and mass emigration devastated one of the world’s oldest Jewish communities.

The future demographic center of Jewish life is shifting toward Israel, not America.

The transformation of world Jewry is being driven largely by the demographic vitality of Israeli Jewish society.

And this, perhaps, is the greatest irony of all.

American Jews have spent generations building institutions, acquiring wealth, achieving professional success, and securing a place within American society. They have become extraordinarily successful at becoming American.

But the center of Jewish demographic life is moving toward the country where Jews have built a sovereign society of their own. The Jewish future is not determined by the number of op-eds written about antisemitism. It is not determined by how many arguments are won on social media. It is not determined by how much money someone donates while remaining comfortably removed from the daily responsibilities of Israeli life.

It is being shaped by the people who live here in the land God told us to. Who birth Jewish babies raised on Jewish time, speaking the tongue of our people. Who work, struggle, serve, sacrifice, and raise the next generation here.

I did not come to Israel because I believed it would be comfortable. I came because I knew it was home.

And perhaps that is the real privilege paradox.

The descendants of Jews who once crossed an ocean with almost nothing now possess so much that the thought of starting over can feel unbearable. Their ancestors understood that survival sometimes required leaving everything behind.

I wonder how many of their descendants still do.

The water is getting hotter, And the frogs are still debating whether they should jump.

About the Author
Shayna Netanya is an American-born writer, content creator, and co-host of the Podcast & Live show, Am Yisrael Thrive. After making Aliyah from California in October 2026, she settled in Netanya, where she is learning all about the art of starting over. Drawing on a background in theater and psychology, she writes about Jewish identity, Israeli life, and the unexpected encounters that make a new country feel like home. Her blog, “The Adventures of Shayna Netanya: An American Olah in Israel,” follows that unfolding story with humor, curiosity, and a willingness to be the stranger in the room.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.