Dory Benami
Writing on Jewish identity, Israel, and American politics

The Shah’s Warning in Trump’s Saudi Nuclear Deal

At a town hall this week, Rep. Brad Sherman explained the Saudi nuclear agreement he warned about in his Washington Post op-ed. I support his call for Congress to scrutinize the deal because the short-term risks are not worth the long-term vulnerabilities.

Trump sent the agreement to Congress in August. The public text provides for a two-year study of uranium enrichment. Afterward, enrichment could proceed if the United States and Saudi Arabia agree in writing. The agreement does not require Saudi Arabia to adopt the International Atomic Energy Agency’s Additional Protocol, which allows broader inspections, or permanently renounce enrichment and reprocessing. It does include a separate bilateral safeguards arrangement, but that does not provide all the access the Additional Protocol would. (Agreement submitted to Congress; Arms Control Association analysis) www.govinfo.gov

Sherman told us he reviewed the classified provisions and found a blank page marked “to be filled in later.” That is his account of what he saw. He argued Congress cannot properly assess the agreement if some of its terms remain unwritten. (Sherman’s statement) sherman.house.gov

Sherman pointed to the 2009 U.S.–United Arab Emirates agreement as a model. The UAE agreed not to enrich uranium or reprocess spent fuel on its territory and adopted the IAEA Additional Protocol. It still built a civilian nuclear program. (State Department summary; IAEA record of the UAE protocol) 2009-2017.state.gov

Sherman said he and Trump agree on one basic point: Iran cannot be trusted with a nuclear weapon. The disagreement is what that means for Saudi Arabia. Mohammed bin Salman has said his kingdom would seek a nuclear weapon if Iran gets one. Sherman warned that the United States is fighting Iran to prevent it from acquiring a weapon while advancing a Saudi agreement that could open a path to enrichment. (MBS interview transcript) Congressman Brad Sherman

The Shah’s Iran is the long-term warning. The United States helped start Iran’s civilian nuclear program under a friendly monarch. The revolution changed the relationship: the Shah was gone, and the United States had lost its ally. Iran did not inherit a bomb, but the new government inherited nuclear infrastructure and expertise. Sherman questioned whether an agreement with today’s Saudi leadership can protect us from the decisions of whoever rules the kingdom decades from now. www.congress.gov

Sherman and then-Senator Marco Rubio previously backed bipartisan legislation that would have required Congress to approve a U.S.–Saudi nuclear agreement before it could take effect. That bill did not become law. Sherman is now urging Congress to block the current agreement unless it has stronger protections. He also pointed to Saudi Arabia’s $2 billion investment in Jared Kushner’s Affinity Partners and Trump family real estate projects in the kingdom. Those relationships do not prove a quid pro quo, but they make transparency and oversight more important. (2018 bill announcement; current resolution) www.markey.senate.gov

The town hall also revealed Sherman’s frustration with Congress. He estimated that 45 percent of its members are “toadies to the administration.” He said he supports Hakeem Jeffries because he would not vote for Jim Jordan. Sherman’s point was that Congress must be willing to challenge the president when national security is at stake.

I’m Israeli-born, pro-Israel, and want the United States to be safe. Sherman did not mention Israel by name, but the regional implications were clear to me. A Saudi nuclear capability could threaten Israel’s security and encourage other countries to follow. Pro-Israel, anti-Iran voices in the Democratic Party have become harder to hear. I support Sherman’s warning, and I intend to follow him in representing California’s 32nd District. The Shah’s lesson is simple: don’t trade long-term security for short-term confidence in a monarch.

About the Author
Dory Benami is the author of Bad Jew, out now on Amazon in paperback, hardcover, and Kindle Unlimited. He is an entrepreneur, attorney, and former congressional candidate from California. Born in Israel and raised in the United States, he writes about Jewish identity, Israel, antisemitism, and American politics. He is the founder of Fortress and Huma Blanco and holds an LL.M. in Intellectual Property and International Business Transactions Law from the University of San Francisco.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.