The Wicked Truth: A Convert’s Perspective

As a convert to Judaism, I naturally view the world through the lens of my faith and personal journey. This perspective has fueled my fascination with stories that challenge preconceived notions and upend everything you thought you knew. I often compare this transformative experience to The Matrix, where characters confront harsh truths and boldly choose a new path despite the cost. Wicked is another such story. By flipping the familiar narrative of The Wizard of Oz on its head, it shattered my expectations and struck a deeply personal chord.

Rewriting the Narrative of Oz

In Wicked, audiences are invited to reconsider the familiar tale of The Wizard of Oz from a radically different perspective. Elphaba, the so-called “Wicked Witch,” transforms from a misunderstood idealist into a pariah, cast out by a society desperate to maintain the myth of the Wizard’s benevolence.

For those who have left a deeply ingrained religious system, like Christianity, this story resonates in striking ways:

• The shock of discovering that the truths you built your life upon were never what they seemed.

• The immense pressure to conform.

• The courage it takes to step into the unknown as an outcast.

The Pain of Disillusionment

Much like Elphaba’s revelation about the Wizard’s fraud, leaving the church often begins with a moment of profound disillusionment. Whether it’s discovering textual inaccuracies, mistranslations, witnessing hypocrisy, or grappling with doctrines that no longer hold true or align with one’s values, the experience can be akin to pulling back the curtain to reveal a supposedly divine figure as nothing more than an illusion.

Image created with AI

The betrayal stings deeply, not only because of the institution’s deception but also because of the personal investment made in believing and defending it.

The Pressure to Conform

The pressure to conform is enormous. In both Wicked and organized religion, the narrative is carefully maintained by societal forces that rely on compliance. The church thrives on collective belief, and dissent threatens the stability of the entire institution.

Those who question the narrative are labeled as heretics, the antichrist, or—ironically—wicked. The parallels are painfully clear: just as Elphaba is painted as a villain for refusing to perpetuate the Wizard’s lies, those who leave the church are often ostracized, shamed, or accused of moral failing (backslidden and hell bound).

The Cost of Integrity

The isolation that follows can be brutal. To leave is to risk losing not only your faith but also your community, your family, and sometimes your entire support system. Friends become strangers, loved ones become judges, and the institution brands you as dangerous simply for choosing integrity over conformity.

For Elphaba, the cost of standing for what’s right is exile. For many ex-believers, it’s the same—cut off from the only world they’ve ever known, forced to rebuild their lives while carrying the stigma of apostasy.

The Courage to Walk Away

Yet, there is courage in choosing to walk away. Like Elphaba, who chooses truth over complicity, those who leave the church embody a defiant bravery. It takes immense strength to reject the comforting lies and face the uncertainty of life without the frameworks that once defined you.

And though the journey is fraught with pain and loss, it is also liberating. Outside the confines of the dogma, there is freedom to explore, to question, and to embrace a more authentic existence.

Reconsidering Who the Villains Are

Ultimately, Wicked challenges us to reconsider who the real villains are. Elphaba, far from being wicked, is a symbol of integrity, strength, and resilience.

Image created using AI

In the same way, those who leave the church are not betrayers or villains but seekers of truth. They are people who refuse to perpetuate a narrative they no longer believe, choosing instead to forge a path of honesty and self-respect, even if it means walking alone.

Conclusion: Brave and Free

Leaving the church comes with a heavy cost, but the rewards—freedom, authenticity, and the strength to stand for what is right—are beyond measure. I’ve been fortunate to meet countless individuals who have embarked on this transformative journey. Like Elphaba, those who dare to defy the narrative and forge their own path are far from wicked.

They are brave.
And they are free.