Tim Orr
Bridging faith. Defending truth. Confronting hate

Understanding the Red and Green Alliance

Image created from Google Gemini by Tim Orr

So why do Western progressives and Islamists agree so much on Israel and Palestine, despite not agreeing on almost anything else that has to do with religion, sex, gender, family, and society as a whole?

In this video, I look at the Red-Green Alliance. I believe that the Red can supply the terminology, and the Green can help supply some of the story.

Progressives talk about colonialism, oppressed peoples, indigenous peoples, resistance, liberation, and decolonization. Islamists come from an entirely different background and can use concepts involving Muslim rule over land, holy land, Jerusalem, Al-Aqsa, jihad, and Islam as a whole.

So when some of these stories are used within the progressive realm, how does that happen?

I’ll be looking at:

* Concepts that Islam and Islamists use to describe Israel and Palestine.
* Hamas and the Muslim Brotherhood.
* Holy land, Al-Aqsa, sovereignty, and resistance.
* How religious concepts can be applied to progressive ideas.
* Why progressives can support the Palestinian cause even if they don’t agree with traditional Islamic morals.
* Antisemitism and where it comes into play.
* Why criticism of Israel is not always antisemitic.

I’m not saying that progressives have turned into Islamists or that Islamists have become progressives. I also don’t think all Palestinian narratives come from Islam. Arab nationalism, Marxism, and many other movements have played a role in this story.

But I think it is interesting to see how certain concepts can be transferred from one side to the other while still maintaining some of the same story.

How can two ideologies that disagree with each other on so much start telling parts of the same story?

That’s what I’ll be covering in this video about the Red-Green Alliance.

About the Author
Tim Orr, D.Min., is a Research Fellow with the Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy (ISGAP). His scholarship examines contemporary antisemitism, Islamic antisemitism, Shi'a religious thought, and the relationship between religion, ideology, and public life. He is the author of the forthcoming book What Antisemitism Explains: Why Failed Ideologies Blame Jews. AI Disclosure: Artificial intelligence tools may be used in the preparation and editing of articles, including assistance with language, organization, and revision. The arguments, interpretations, and conclusions are my own. I review and revise the final text and take full responsibility for its accuracy and content.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.