Understanding the Ultra-Orthodox Struggle in a Secular Age
In the World but Not of It
During my travels in Israel, I had the opportunity to meet with an ultra-Orthodox rabbi. As a Christian who has spent considerable time studying Judaism, participating in Jewish religious life, and thinking about the relationship between faith and society, I was interested in understanding a community often discussed in political terms but less frequently understood in religious ones.
Much of what we hear about Israel’s ultra-Orthodox Jews, commonly known as Haredim, concerns military service, government subsidies, religious education, employment, and political influence. These are consequential questions in a country where national survival and the distribution of public obligations cannot be treated lightly. Yet beginning with these controversies risks overlooking something fundamental about Haredi life: the belief that preserving a community ordered around God’s commandments requires deliberate resistance to some of the most powerful influences of contemporary society.
I recognized something familiar in that conviction. Religious communities throughout history have wrestled with how to inhabit a surrounding culture without allowing that culture to determine the meaning of faithfulness. They have disagreed about which practices must be preserved, which innovations can be accepted, and how much separation is necessary to sustain a distinctive way of life.
The Haredi struggle is profoundly Jewish in its religious foundations, but the underlying problem is one that Christians and other religious believers should recognize. Understanding it requires beginning with the community’s understanding of holiness rather than with the state’s demands for participation.
Holiness as an Organizing Principle
In Leviticus 19:2, God calls upon the Israelites to be holy because God is holy. Jewish tradition understands holiness not merely as a private spiritual quality but as something expressed through the ordering of everyday life. Food, family, commerce, worship, dress, the observance of sacred time, and obligations toward other people can all become expressions of fidelity to God.
The Hebrew concept of kedushah, or holiness, conveys dedication and distinction. Within Haredi communities, that commitment takes particular institutional forms: intensive Torah study, strict observance of Jewish law, distinctive educational systems, and communal structures intended to transmit religious obligations across generations.
For many Haredim, Torah study is not simply preparation for a profession or the acquisition of historical knowledge. It is a sacred activity whose worth cannot be adequately measured by its contribution to the economy. The ideal of Torah lishmah, studying Torah for its own sake, places learning within the relationship between humanity and God.
That commitment must be taken seriously before the public argument about employment or military service can be understood.
Yet Judaism has never spoken with only one voice about the relationship between study and ordinary responsibility. Pirkei Avot 2:2 praises the combination of Torah study and worldly occupation, while Berakhot 35b preserves a debate over the relationship between religious learning and earning a livelihood. The tension between contemplation and action is therefore not simply imposed upon religious Jews by secular society. It also belongs to the internal history of Jewish religious thought.
Why Religious Communities Separate
Christianity offers useful comparisons, although Christian categories cannot substitute for a Jewish explanation.
The early Christian desert tradition developed among people who believed that ordinary social life could compromise the disciplined pursuit of holiness. Anthony of Egypt and subsequent monastic communities sought a measure of withdrawal from the prevailing culture. Later Christian movements developed rules governing communal life, work, worship, property, and relationships with the surrounding world.
The Amish provide another example of selective separation. Their boundaries involving dress, technology, education, and social participation reflect religious judgments about which practices sustain communal faithfulness and which threaten it. Other Christian traditions, including Mennonite and Hutterite communities, have developed different arrangements between spiritual discipline and participation in wider society.
These movements are not equivalent to Haredi Judaism, and their differences matter. What they reveal is a recurring religious conviction that not every development celebrated by the surrounding culture deserves acceptance.
The Christian theologian H. Richard Niebuhr explored this issue in his 1951 book Christ and Culture. Among his five approaches was what he called “Christ against culture,” describing religious movements that regard substantial elements of prevailing social life as incompatible with faithful discipleship.
That category illuminates part of the dilemma, but it should not be imposed wholesale upon Haredi Judaism. Haredim are not Christian monks, and they do not simply reject modern society. They participate in elections, conduct business, organize extensive charitable institutions, use technology selectively, and maintain relationships with the wider Israeli public.
Their concern is frequently not whether something is modern but whether accepting it would weaken the authority of Torah and the community’s ability to transmit its religious way of life.
A Religious Civilization Shaped by History
Contemporary Haredi society did not emerge fully formed from the biblical period. Its institutions and communal boundaries developed through historical encounters with Jewish emancipation, the Enlightenment, religious reform, secularization, Zionism, and the destruction of European Jewish communities during the Holocaust.
These experiences help explain why religious continuity can be regarded not simply as a preference but as a responsibility toward previous and future generations.
The Holocaust destroyed not only millions of Jewish lives but also religious institutions, yeshivot, communal networks, and centers of scholarship that had developed over centuries. Rebuilding those institutions became an urgent undertaking for religious leaders and families who believed that the survival of Jewish life required preserving the traditions through which that life had been sustained.
For some communities, separation helped make that reconstruction possible.
But Haredi Judaism is not a single movement. Hasidic communities, Lithuanian or Yeshivish communities, Sephardi Haredim, and other groups differ in their historical experiences, religious leadership, attitudes toward Zionism, and engagement with modern institutions. Their approaches to work, education, political participation, and military service are not identical.
This diversity is essential to understanding what is changing within Haredi society today.
The Pressures of Contemporary Israel
The Israel Democracy Institute’s 2025 statistical report estimated that approximately 1.45 million Haredim represented 14.3 percent of Israel’s population. The population is unusually young, with significant implications for schools, employment, public finances, and Israel’s future demographic composition.
Employment patterns also complicate the popular image of a community withdrawn from economic activity. Haredi women participate substantially in the workforce, often assuming major responsibility for household income alongside demanding family and religious obligations. Men’s employment is lower, reflecting in part the central place of prolonged Torah study in many communities.
These differences raise legitimate questions about economic sustainability and opportunity. They also reveal the inadequacy of treating all Haredi families as though they occupy the same relationship to the state or economy.
The rapid development of digital technology creates further complications. Internet access can offer employment, education, medical information, and contact with the wider world. It can also introduce forms of entertainment, commercialism, and cultural influence that religious leaders regard as spiritually destructive.
What a secular observer may describe as access or opportunity can therefore be understood within a Haredi community as a challenge to its capacity to shape the religious lives of future generations.
Neither perception is imaginary.
Understanding Without Romanticizing
A serious account of religious freedom must distinguish between understanding religious commitments and accepting every arrangement defended in their name.
Religious institutions can preserve learning, meaning, mutual assistance, and moral discipline. They can also become attached to political privileges or communal practices whose consequences deserve criticism.
Christian history provides many examples of religious communities confusing the protection of faith with the preservation of institutional power. Religious commitment does not automatically guarantee justice, nor does every challenge to religious authority constitute persecution.
The same distinctions matter when discussing Haredi Judaism.
Questions involving military service, public resources, educational opportunity, women’s economic and personal autonomy, and the obligations of citizenship must be addressed. Religious freedom does not settle them automatically. But policies intended to address these concerns are unlikely to succeed if they begin by treating religious conviction as ignorance or the community itself as a problem to be overcome.
There is an important difference between respecting the religious reasons people live as they do and agreeing that those reasons justify exemption from every public obligation.
That distinction is where the Israeli debate should begin.
A Mirror for Other Religious Communities
As a Christian, I recognize the attraction of a community determined not to surrender its religious identity to whatever values happen to dominate its surrounding society. Religious institutions that become indistinguishable from their culture may retain their ceremonies and language while gradually losing the convictions that once gave them meaning.
Yet I also recognize the opposite danger. Communities can become so concerned with preserving their boundaries that they neglect the obligations they owe to people beyond them or diminish the freedom of individuals within them.
These are not exclusively Haredi challenges. They belong to the history of religion itself.
The question I brought to my encounter with an ultra-Orthodox rabbi was therefore larger than a dispute over Israeli politics. I wanted to understand how a community preserves a way of life it regards as sacred while inhabiting a society whose institutions and expectations do not always reflect its convictions.
That question deserves an answer grounded in religious understanding. But Israel presents an additional complication that cannot be resolved through sympathy alone.
The Haredim are not simply preserving religious life under a foreign government. They are citizens of a Jewish state in which their own political participation, public resources, and collective future are intertwined with those of other Israelis.
The meaning of separation changes when the society from which one seeks distance is also a society one helps govern.
That is where the next part of the discussion must begin.
Notes and References
- Leviticus 19:2; Pirkei Avot 2:2; Babylonian Talmud, Berakhot 35b. These sources provide different perspectives on holiness, religious study, and worldly responsibility.
- H. Richard Niebuhr, Christ and Culture (Harper & Brothers, 1951); John 17:14–16 (NIV).
- David Sorotzkin, “The Formation of Ḥaredism—Perspectives on Religion, Social Disciplining and Secularization in Modern Judaism,” Religions 13, no. 2 (2022): 175.
- Gilad Malach and Lee Cahaner, Annual Statistical Report on Ultra-Orthodox (Haredi) Society in Israel 2025, Israel Democracy Institute, 2026.
- Pew Research Center, Israel’s Religiously Divided Society, March 8, 2016.
.
