Saurav Dutt
Author and Global Affairs Commentator

What India Can Learn From Israel

Israel is a small country with an unusually large presence in American strategic thinking. Its influence in Washington is not the result of a secret lever, a single lobby or the power of one community. It is the product of something more durable: institutions that organize voters, donors and advocates; evangelical support; deep military and intelligence ties; technological advantages; and decades of political investment. For India, the lesson is not to copy Israel’s politics, but to understand how national influence is built.

Small population, large footprint

The arithmetic is striking. Israel has a population of roughly 10 million. The world’s Jewish population is around 16 million, representing only a small fraction of humanity. Yet the United States and Israel have constructed one of the most durable strategic relationships in modern international politics.

That cannot be explained by demographics alone.

The concentration of Jewish populations in Israel and the United States has created dense networks of family, professional, academic and civic connections between the two countries. But those networks should not be mistaken for a single political bloc. American Jews hold a wide range of political views, including significant disagreements over Israel’s government and its policies.

The more useful explanation is institutional.

Israel’s influence in Washington has been built through several overlapping constituencies: Jewish-American organizations, pro-Israel advocacy groups, evangelical Christians, defense and technology interests, foreign-policy institutions and voters who regard the US-Israel relationship as strategically or morally important.

The result is an unusually broad political ecosystem.

The power of organization

The American Israel Public Affairs Committee, or AIPAC, is among the most prominent organizations in that ecosystem. Its political network has become a significant force in congressional elections, particularly by supporting candidates who favor a strong US-Israel relationship.

But the important point is not simply how much money is spent.

American politics rewards organization. A relatively small group of highly motivated voters can exert influence when it is concentrated in strategically important states, participates consistently in elections and communicates effectively with lawmakers.

This is not unique to the pro-Israel movement. Energy companies, labor unions, gun-rights groups, environmental organizations, technology companies and numerous ethnic and religious communities use similar mechanisms to influence Washington.

Israel’s advantage is that several of these forces often point in the same direction.

And even within the Jewish-American community, the political spectrum is broad. Groups such as J Street, for example, have challenged some of AIPAC’s positions. Treating Jewish Americans, Israel’s government and pro-Israel advocacy organizations as interchangeable therefore obscures more than it explains.

The evangelical multiplier

One of the most important parts of the equation lies outside the Jewish community altogether.

Christian Zionism has become an important pillar of American support for Israel, particularly among conservative evangelicals. For many of these voters, Israel is connected not merely to foreign policy but to religious conviction and biblical interpretation.

Organizations such as Christians United for Israel have demonstrated the scale of this constituency.

Its importance lies partly in its numbers. The evangelical constituency is vastly larger than America’s Jewish population. Its political influence, particularly within the Republican Party, gives pro-Israel sentiment a reach that cannot be explained through Jewish-American advocacy alone.

The motivations may differ, but the political outcome can converge.

That convergence has helped make support for Israel unusually resilient across successive Republican administrations.

A strategic relationship, not charity

Domestic politics is only half the explanation.

Washington has long viewed Israel as a strategic asset. American assistance has helped sustain Israel’s military capabilities, including its sophisticated missile-defense systems. In return, the United States receives intelligence cooperation, access to advanced defense technologies and a highly capable military partner in one of the world’s most strategically important regions.

Israel has also become an important technology partner.

Its strengths in cybersecurity, defense electronics, artificial intelligence, intelligence systems and other advanced technologies have created commercial and strategic relationships that extend well beyond traditional diplomacy.

For Washington, therefore, Israel is not simply a recipient of American assistance. It is also a source of military, technological and intelligence capabilities.

That makes the relationship easier to sustain even when political disagreements emerge.

Influence has limits

The notion that Israel simply dictates American foreign policy is too crude.

American presidents have repeatedly demonstrated that Washington retains the ability to impose its own preferences when the stakes are sufficiently high.

The clearest historical example came in 1956, when President Dwight Eisenhower pressured Israel to withdraw from the Sinai Peninsula following the Suez crisis. More recently, successive administrations have disagreed with Israeli governments over settlements, Iran, military operations and the conduct of wars.

The relationship is therefore better understood as one of considerable influence rather than control.

An American president must consider Congress, voters, donors, evangelical Christians, foreign-policy advisers and the strategic consequences of weakening Israel. An Israeli government, meanwhile, must account for the preferences and limits of its most important ally.

Leverage runs in both directions.

The consensus is changing

There are also signs that America’s long-standing consensus on Israel is becoming less secure.

Younger Americans have generally become more skeptical of Israel than previous generations. Democrats and Republicans are increasingly divided over the conflict, while debates over the war in Gaza have exposed substantial disagreements inside both political parties.

Among American Jews, attitudes toward Israel are similarly diverse.

This matters because political influence cannot survive indefinitely without public legitimacy. Organizations can mobilize voters and donors, but they cannot completely insulate policymakers from changing public opinion.

The next generation of American politicians may therefore approach the US-Israel relationship differently from their predecessors.

That does not necessarily mean a rupture. It may instead mean a relationship that becomes more openly transactional and politically contested.

The lesson for India

India should pay close attention.

The country already possesses many of the ingredients required for greater influence in Washington. The Indian-American community is large, affluent and highly represented in technology, medicine, academia, business and government.

Indian Americans have also achieved remarkable political prominence.

Yet economic success does not automatically translate into foreign-policy influence.

The Israeli experience suggests that the crucial ingredient is institutional architecture: organizations capable of sustaining relationships with Congress, state governments, universities, think tanks, business leaders and successive presidential administrations.

India’s objective should not be to reproduce Israel’s political model. Nor should it attempt to turn the Indian-American community into a monolithic political bloc. That would be neither realistic nor desirable.

The more useful lesson is organizational.

India needs durable institutions that can articulate American and Indian interests simultaneously, build bipartisan relationships and maintain engagement regardless of which party controls the White House or Congress.

That means investing not only in lobbying, but also in scholarship, research, technology partnerships, cultural diplomacy, business networks and public diplomacy.

Influence is accumulated over decades.

From diaspora to strategic asset

India’s diaspora gives it a considerable starting advantage.

Indian Americans are already prominent in Silicon Valley, Wall Street, universities, hospitals and corporate America. Their presence in government has grown substantially as well.

The question is whether this individual success can be converted into a durable institutional network.

Israel demonstrates what is possible when diaspora relationships, strategic interests, technological capabilities and political organization reinforce one another.

India has something Israel cannot replicate: a population of more than a billion people, a rapidly expanding economy, a growing technology sector and a diaspora spread across some of the world’s most important financial and political centers.

Its challenge is turning those assets into sustained influence.

The bigger lesson

Israel’s position in Washington is sometimes portrayed as a mystery: how can a country of roughly 10 million people command so much attention from the world’s leading superpower?

The mystery largely disappears once the relationship is examined as an ecosystem.

There are advocacy organizations. There are committed voters. There are major donors. There are evangelical Christians. There are defense and technology partnerships. There are intelligence relationships. There are decades of diplomatic investment. And there is a political establishment that has repeatedly concluded that the relationship serves important American interests.

None of these factors is sufficient on its own.

Together, they are powerful.

For India, that is the central lesson. Influence is not simply a function of population, economic size or military strength. It is the ability to convert those assets into relationships, institutions and political relevance.

Israel did not acquire influence in Washington overnight. It built an ecosystem.

India has many of the raw materials to build one of its own.

About the Author
Saurav Dutt is a TIME magazine featured published Author and Global Affairs Commentator. He is the Author of Modi and Me: A Political, Cultural, and Religious Reawakening, and Balance of Power: US-India Ties in the Epoch of Trump and Modi.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.