Tony D. Senatore
"I'm the spokesman for the OK Boomer generation"

What Is America, and What Does It Mean to Be an American?

Photo: Tony Senatore: all rights reserved
I’ve been thinking a lot about what America means, what it means to be an American, and how far we may have drifted from the principles on which this country was founded.
Perhaps part of the reason I find myself asking these questions is my own family history. My grandparents came to this country from Russia and Italy, as did millions of others who left behind familiar surroundings, languages, traditions, and, in many cases, difficult circumstances in search of something better. They came to a country that offered something profoundly different: the opportunity to determine their own futures rather than have those futures dictated by the circumstances of their birth.
That idea has always been central to my understanding of America.
I don’t believe a particular race, ethnicity, religion, or ancestry defines America. Nor do I believe it is simply a geographical location surrounded by borders. America is an idea, a political experiment, and a collection of principles that brought together people from vastly different backgrounds under a common system of government.
But I also think we have become so accustomed to talking about America, celebrating its achievements, criticizing its shortcomings, and arguing over its future that we sometimes lose sight of what actually makes it distinctive.
America did not emerge from an intellectual vacuum, nor did its Founders invent the principles of liberty and self-government from scratch. We are beneficiaries of centuries of human achievement, much of it originating in civilizations far removed from our own. Understanding where our ideas came from, what the Founders hoped to accomplish, and why they disagreed is essential to understanding what America is.
And perhaps just as importantly, it helps us recognize what we stand to lose when we abandon the principles that made this experiment possible.
Our system of government owes an enormous intellectual debt to ancient Greece and Rome. The Greeks gave us the foundations of democratic thought and political philosophy. Plato and Aristotle examined questions of justice, citizenship, political authority, and individuals’ responsibilities within society. The Romans developed a republican tradition, with elected officials, a Senate, representative institutions, and an understanding that governmental power should not rest entirely in the hands of one individual.
The Founding Fathers studied these civilizations extensively. They understood that republics could become corrupt, that democracies could be vulnerable to demagoguery, and that concentrated political power threatened liberty. They drew upon these historical experiences when designing a government intended to restrain power through institutional checks and balances.
But Greece and Rome were only part of the intellectual inheritance. The English constitutional tradition, including the Magna Carta, the English Bill of Rights, and centuries of common-law development, helped establish the principle that government itself must be subject to law. Enlightenment thinkers such as John Locke influenced the Founders’ understanding of natural rights, private property, consent of the governed, and the social contract. Montesquieu’s ideas about the separation of governmental powers helped shape the constitutional structure.
Even the contributions of civilizations outside the Western political tradition deserve recognition. Chinese, Japanese, Indian, and Middle Eastern civilizations contributed enormously to mathematics, science, medicine, engineering, commerce, and the development of knowledge upon which the modern world was built. America inherited a world of accumulated human achievement and built upon it.
What makes America remarkable is not that it invented everything, but that it brought together ideas, institutions, and people from different places and constructed something distinctly its own.
And that brings me to immigration.
We use the expression “America is a nation of immigrants” so frequently that it has almost become a cliché. It is true, of course, but I think we sometimes overlook an important part of that story.
My own grandparents came to America from Russia and Italy. Like millions of others, they crossed an ocean in search of opportunity and a better life. Ellis Island remains one of the great symbols of that experience. Between 1892 and 1954, nearly 12 million immigrants were processed through its doors. They arrived from different countries, spoke different languages, practiced different religions, and brought different customs. They were not required to abandon their heritage, but they were expected to become part of a larger American society.
Immigration was regulated. People were inspected, documented, and admitted under the laws in effect at the time. It was not a perfect system, and American immigration history included shameful discrimination and exclusion. Chinese immigrants, for example, faced exclusion laws, and later national-origin quotas discriminated against immigrants from Southern and Eastern Europe, including people from countries like Italy and Russia.
We should acknowledge those injustices without losing sight of the value of an orderly immigration process.
I believe we have lost our way in the immigration debate. There is a difference between welcoming people who want to become Americans and allowing our immigration system to lose credibility through inconsistent enforcement, uncontrolled unauthorized entry, and policies that fail to establish clear expectations.
The United States has made significant changes to its immigration laws over the decades. The 1965 Immigration and Nationality Act replaced the national-origins quota system with a framework emphasizing family reunification and skilled immigration. Subsequent legislation and administrative policies further shaped the system. Today, immigration from Central and South America, as well as other parts of the world, is part of a much larger and more complicated debate involving legal immigration, asylum, border enforcement, and humanitarian obligations.
But why must compassion and enforcement be treated as mutually exclusive? Why can’t we welcome immigrants while maintaining control over who enters, how they enter, and how many people we can reasonably accommodate?
A country without meaningful immigration enforcement risks undermining the very laws that make citizenship and legal immigration meaningful. We should be able to defend our borders without demonizing immigrants, just as we should be able to welcome immigrants without dismissing legitimate concerns about border security and the rule of law.
My grandparents’ experience should remind us of the opportunities America offers, but it should also remind us that becoming part of this country involves more than simply arriving here. It involves joining a common civic community.
There is another part of the American story that I think we have increasingly forgotten: America was built, in considerable measure, on the pursuit of wealth.
That might sound unfashionable in an era when wealth is frequently portrayed as something inherently suspicious. We hear considerable criticism of successful entrepreneurs, business owners, investors, and people who have accumulated fortunes. Certainly, there are legitimate reasons to criticize how wealth has been acquired and concentrated. The industrial era produced monopolies, exploitation, political corruption, and the so-called robber barons. Not every fortune was earned fairly, and not every successful business person was a model of virtue.
But we should not confuse the abuses of capitalism with the broader economic experiment that helped build this country.
Think about the people who ventured west during the gold rushes, the entrepreneurs who developed the oil industry, the railroad builders, industrialists, inventors, and countless small-business owners who took enormous risks. They were driven by the possibility of acquiring something that was not necessarily available to them in the societies they had left behind.
America offered a different economic proposition.
In much of traditional European society, wealth, land, titles, and social standing were heavily influenced by inheritance and birth. An aristocratic family could enjoy privileges for generations, while those born into poverty often faced formidable barriers to improving their circumstances. There were certainly exceptions, and Europe was never completely devoid of social mobility. But America offered a comparatively greater opportunity to escape the economic circumstances into which one was born.
You didn’t need an aristocratic title or an inherited estate to start a business, acquire property, or build a fortune. You could take a chance, work, invest, invent, and potentially improve your standing in society.
America never promised equal outcomes. Its promise was the possibility of opportunity.
That distinction matters enormously.
We must also be honest about the contradictions in our history. Slavery, discrimination, inherited wealth, and unequal access to opportunity prevented generations of Americans from participating equally in that promise. The founding generation did not live up to the universal principles it articulated. But those principles established an ideal that subsequent generations could invoke to challenge those injustices.
The idea that your birth should not determine your economic destiny remains one of the most powerful aspects of the American experiment.
And this brings me to another principle that I believe has become increasingly neglected: individual responsibility.
The American ideal was rooted in the belief that individuals should have the freedom to make their own choices, pursue their ambitions, take risks, and accept the consequences. Freedom was not meant to guarantee protection against failure. It meant having the opportunity to succeed without requiring permission from an established class or political authority.
That doesn’t mean people never needed assistance or that society had no responsibility toward those facing genuine hardship. But there was an important distinction between helping someone overcome adversity and making government permanently responsible for every individual’s circumstances.
Today, we seem increasingly inclined to confuse equality of opportunity with equality of outcome. We want the rewards of individual freedom without always accepting the responsibilities that accompany it. We criticize wealth while overlooking the risks, investments, and decisions that sometimes produce it. We demand government intervention without adequately considering the costs, unintended consequences, or long-term dependency that some policies can create.
We have also allowed the relationship between government and the private sector to become increasingly complicated. We criticize corporate power, yet sometimes overlook how regulation, subsidies, political influence, and government favoritism can protect established businesses from competition. We talk about free markets while tolerating arrangements that benefit politically connected interests.
This is not the capitalism of open competition and individual enterprise that Americans have traditionally celebrated. Nor is it a healthy relationship between government and the people it is supposed to serve.
Perhaps one of the best ways to understand what America was intended to be is to examine the disagreements among the people who helped establish it.
Consider Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson. They had fundamentally different visions of America’s economic and political future. Hamilton believed in a strong national government, a sound system of public credit, manufacturing, commerce, and a vigorous financial system. He understood that a young nation needed economic institutions that could support its independence and growth. Jefferson, by contrast, was deeply suspicious of centralized authority and envisioned a republic built around independent citizens, agricultural communities, and a more limited federal government.
Their disagreements were substantial, sometimes bitter, and extended well beyond economic policy. Yet both contributed to the development of the American republic.
That is an important part of our history. America was never supposed to be an ideological monolith. The Founders did not agree on every issue, nor did they expect future generations to. The genius of the constitutional system was that it provided a framework in which competing ideas could coexist without requiring one faction to dominate every aspect of national life.
James Madison understood this particularly well. In Federalist No. 51, he explained the need to divide governmental power and create institutional checks and balances. His famous observation that “ambition must be made to counteract ambition” reflected a realistic understanding of human nature. He did not believe we could depend on the virtue of individual politicians to prevent abuses of power. Instead, he believed institutions needed to be designed to restrain them.
That is a lesson worth remembering today, when so much of our political culture revolves around finding the right person to occupy the presidency rather than preserving the institutions that limit presidential power.
Alexis de Tocqueville, the French political thinker who traveled through America in the 1830s, recognized another important characteristic of American society. In Democracy in America, he examined the country’s individualism, its voluntary associations, and the tendency of ordinary citizens to organize themselves to address common problems. He recognized that American democracy depended on more than elections and political institutions. It depended on citizens who participated in their communities, formed associations, and took responsibility for matters beyond their immediate personal interests.
Tocqueville understood that a free society could not survive through government alone. It required a culture of civic participation and individual initiative.
John Adams also understood the importance of character and civic virtue. He believed that the Constitution was designed for a people capable of exercising self-government, not a population indifferent to morality or responsibility. He famously warned that the Constitution was made for a moral and religious people and was inadequate to govern any other.
His point was not that government should impose a particular religion. Rather, constitutional freedom requires citizens who exercise restraint, respect others, and recognize obligations beyond their own immediate interests.
Taken together, these thinkers offer a useful way of understanding the American experiment. Hamilton and Jefferson demonstrate that disagreement is not a threat to the republic. Madison reminds us that power must be restrained. Tocqueville reminds us that democracy depends on an engaged citizenry. Adams reminds us that political institutions cannot substitute for individual character and civic virtue.
Today, however, we increasingly treat political disagreement as a moral failing. We identify ourselves through political parties and ideological camps, often placing loyalty to those groups above our responsibilities as citizens. We look to presidents and politicians to define the country for us, forgetting that the government belongs to the people, not the other way around.
We have also become accustomed to expecting political leaders to solve problems that cannot always be solved through legislation. Government can establish rules, protect rights, provide essential public services, and maintain the conditions in which people can prosper. But it cannot manufacture personal character, ambition, responsibility, or civic virtue.
Those things must come from individuals, families, communities, and the broader culture.
So what is an American?
I don’t think the answer should depend on where your grandparents were born, what language your parents spoke, what religion you practice, or how much money you have in the bank.
An American is someone who embraces the principles that make this country possible: individual liberty, equality under the law, constitutional government, personal responsibility, economic opportunity, and the freedom to pursue a better life.
It means recognizing that we are inheritors of an extraordinary intellectual and political tradition, one built over centuries and contributed to by people from around the world. It means respecting the rights of others, accepting the legitimacy of disagreement, and understanding that citizenship carries responsibilities as well as privileges.
My grandparents came here from Russia and Italy because they believed America offered a chance to build a different future. They didn’t come here expecting the government to guarantee their success or to make their lives easy. They came for the opportunity to make something of themselves. Their story is hardly unique, but it represents something I believe we have increasingly taken for granted: the freedom to determine, as much as circumstances allow, the direction of our own lives.
I am not suggesting that America was ever perfect, or that there was a golden age when everyone enjoyed freedom and opportunity equally. There wasn’t. Slavery, discrimination, and economic privilege are part of our history, and we should never pretend otherwise. But we should also recognize that the principles articulated at our founding provided the foundation upon which subsequent generations could challenge those injustices and expand the promise of American liberty.
The Founders gave us a framework, not a guarantee. They disagreed about the country’s direction, but they understood that preserving a republic required more than electing the right leaders. It required constitutional restraints on power, an engaged citizenry, individual responsibility, and a shared commitment to the principles that allowed people with different beliefs to live together under one system of government.
That is where I believe we need some serious soul-searching. We have become increasingly concerned with what government should provide, what political opponents believe, and which side should prevail. We spend far less time discussing what we owe one another as citizens and what responsibilities come with the freedoms we enjoy.
America is an inheritance, but it is also a responsibility. We didn’t create the original experiment, and we certainly didn’t perfect it. We inherited something extraordinary, built upon centuries of human thought, sacrifice, disagreement, and achievement. Our responsibility is to preserve its essential principles, correct its failures, and pass on something worthy of the generations who came before us.
My grandparents made that journey because they believed in what America represented. I want to think that if someone from another country arrived here today, they could still recognize that same promise—not simply the promise of material prosperity, but the promise of individual freedom, dignity, opportunity, and a future not predetermined by the circumstances of one’s birth.
Perhaps we have become so preoccupied with arguing over what America should become that we have forgotten what made it worth building in the first place.
The question isn’t whether America has changed. Of course it has. Every generation leaves its mark. The question is whether we will remain faithful to the principles that made this country possible, and whether we will have the wisdom and character to pass those principles on.
America isn’t simply something we inherited from the Founders. It is something we are responsible for leaving to those who come after us.
About the Author
I was a sociology major at Columbia University, where i received my B.A in 2017, at age 55. My opinion pieces have appeared in the Columbia Spectator, the Tab at Columbia University, and Merion West. I have been called The Arthur Avenue Mozart by friends, and have been described as Paulie "Walnuts" Gaultieri of The Sopranos had he attended a prestigious Ivy League university.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.