Where Do I Belong?
This month, the Brazilian Jewish journalist Breno Altman proposed a law declaring Zionism a form of racism. Jones Manoel, a communist just elected to Congress, wants it criminalized. The idea has a pedigree. The UN adopted the same formula in 1975, backed by Idi Amin’s Uganda, the Khmer Rouge’s Cambodia, and General Geisel’s Brazil, while Pinochet’s Chile abstained. The UN revoked it in 1991, and part of the left wants to revive a vote even Pinochet would not cast.
Racism against whom, exactly? No assembly ever called Irish or Palestinian nationalism racist, and only one won that distinction, that of the people racism nearly exterminated. In 2003, Brazil’s Supreme Court heard the case of Siegfried Ellwanger, a Holocaust-denying publisher, and ruled, seven to three, that antisemitism constitutes the crime of racism. Altman would finish the sentence, making it racism to defend the home of nearly half the world’s Jews. Jean Améry would have called this antisemitism with a clean conscience, and Congress should shelve it before it is filed.
Plenty of people criticize Israel in good faith, and I furiously criticize my own government. But a law like this would pass Netanyahu by and land on ordinary people. In practice, it is already in force, just not yet official. When Russia invaded Ukraine, I called a friend of Ukrainian descent in Curitiba, in southern Brazil, to ask if his relatives were alive. He added me to a group of fans of Internacional, the Porto Alegre football club, and assured me that having lived in Curitiba and rooted for Inter since boyhood qualified me. After October 7th, he kicked me out and blocked my number. Membership had fine print, and being Israeli voided the rest.
Améry read that fine print before we did. A left-wing Viennese Jew who survived Auschwitz, he watched the German left turn the Jewish state into a comfortable villain and wrote in Die Zeit that anti-Zionism contains antisemitism the way a cloud contains a storm. The cloud has traveled well and now covers the European left, American rednecks, and the Latin American left, three tribes that disagree about everything except us. Améry saw the cloud and warned us. Altman wants to have it notarized.
The cry that unites these tribes, from the river to the sea, draws a map with no room for the seven million Jews here, and erasing them has a name, genocide. For the cry to sound like justice, we have to be colonists. But colonists bring their language from elsewhere, and Hebrew was born here some three thousand years ago and is the only language of this land still spoken in it. Arabic became the language here in the seventh century, through an empire’s conquest. Before anyone concludes otherwise, I believe the Palestinians also have a right to their land, where they have lived for generations. If time creates the right, it creates it for everyone. The Portuguese reached Brazil over five hundred years ago, and every Brazilian feels the land is theirs. The English reached Virginia over four hundred years ago, and no one tells Americans to go back to England. If four centuries turn real colonists into natives, how long until they stop calling us colonists, when we never were?
The title asked where I belong. The answer is wherever I fucking want.
P.S. This piece is for everyone the cap fits.
