Who Do You Think You Are?
The arrogance, hypocrisy and moral bankruptcy behind the fashionable obsession with hating Israel
Who do you think you are? You wannabe influencer, desperate for glory, recognition and fame, ignoring facts, ignoring history, but above all ignoring the sorrow and pain of Israelis who have been victims of terrorism and must live under constant threats. You, apparently blessed with an abundance of ignorance, seem perfectly comfortable selling your soul and your moral compass to the devil in exchange for followers, likes and applause. You have turned human suffering into an opportunity to promote yourself, and somehow you have the audacity to present yourself as a humanitarian. Tell me, what exactly is humanitarian about ignoring the suffering of an entire nation simply because acknowledging it would damage your carefully constructed narrative?
Tell me, you pro Palestine supporter who has never visited Israel, who has never looked beyond the narrative presented by the engineers of terror and the supporters of Hamas, what makes you an authority on the Middle East? Have you ever sat with an Israeli family that lost a child to terrorism? Have you ever experienced the sound of an air raid siren or witnessed the anxiety of parents worrying about their children serving in the IDF? Have you ever bothered to study the history of the Jewish people without filtering it through your ideological prejudices? Or would acquiring actual knowledge interfere with the satisfaction you derive from your manufactured moral superiority?
Who do you think you are, you Jewish activists living safely in Europe and the United States, who believe that publicly condemning the very existence of the Jewish state earns you some extraordinary moral status? Do you really believe that belonging to the biggest and loudest crowd makes you morally superior? Criticizing an Israeli government is perfectly legitimate, but denying the Jewish people their fundamental right to national self determination is an entirely different matter. When anti Zionism becomes the denial of rights afforded to other peoples, it crosses into antisemitism. Do you honestly believe that abandoning Israel will protect you from antisemitism? If, God forbid, Israel were ever to fall, do you really believe that those who genuinely hate Jews would make an exception for you because you once marched alongside them? History should have taught you better.
Who do you think you are, academic professionals, doctors, lawyers, professors and intellectuals, rallying against Israel, delivering impressive speeches and signing petitions while possessing remarkably little firsthand knowledge of the reality on the ground? What exactly do you gain from your obsessive hostility towards Israel? Popularity? Recognition? The admiration of your students? Perhaps you finally discovered an opportunity to be considered cool and revolutionary rather than being perceived as intellectual nerds. But do you genuinely believe that boycotting one of the world’s most innovative societies is an intelligent decision?
Look up the extraordinary number of Nobel Prizes awarded to Jewish individuals. Look at the contributions Israel has made to medicine, science, agriculture, cybersecurity, water management and countless other fields. Look at the medical innovations that save lives regardless of nationality, religion or political allegiance. Then explain to me how excluding Israeli researchers, physicians and academics benefits humanity. Your academic titles apparently do not guarantee intellectual independence, because some of you seem incapable of questioning the prevailing narrative within your own professional circles. Start using those sleeping brains of yours. Education without independent thinking is nothing more than accumulated information.
Who do you think you are, actors, singers, television personalities and celebrities who use their fame to promote hostility towards Israel? I get it. Israel is one of the hottest subjects in the international media, and joining the crowd provides a convenient boost to your fragile egos. Suddenly, thousands of people admire you, not because of your artistic achievements or your knowledge of international affairs, but because you repeat the politically fashionable slogans they want to hear. You mistake popularity for integrity, applause for intelligence and visibility for moral authority. Sorry, but exploiting a complicated conflict for personal recognition is pathetic, egocentric and morally reprehensible. Having millions of followers does not make you an expert on geopolitics.
As a person who lived in both Israel and Syria, I cannot comprehend how much intellectual cowardice and dishonesty exist in this world. I have experienced two fundamentally different societies. Of course Israel makes mistakes. I have cursed plenty of times in Israel, disagreed with decisions, criticized politicians and been frustrated by Israeli bureaucracy. Israel is not perfect, and neither are Israelis. But when you take a helicopter view and compare the institutions, freedoms, opportunities and social structures of Israel and Syria, the differences are impossible to ignore.
Israel is in a league of its own.
Israel has built a democratic society in which citizens can criticize their government, demonstrate, vote, practice their religion and challenge political authorities. It has built universities, hospitals, research institutions and an extraordinarily innovative economy while facing wars, terrorism and existential threats. Its imperfections deserve scrutiny, but its achievements deserve recognition. Yet acknowledging those achievements has seemingly become unacceptable in certain supposedly progressive circles.
What disgusts me most is the selective application of morality. Where are your endless demonstrations against the Iranian regime? Where is your relentless outrage over the oppression of women in Afghanistan, the persecution of religious minorities and the countless victims of brutal dictatorships? Why does your humanitarian enthusiasm reach such extraordinary heights whenever Israel is involved, while so many other tragedies barely register on your moral radar?
Israel does not need your permission to exist. Israelis do not need your approval to defend themselves against terrorism. The Jewish people do not owe you an apology for having established a sovereign nation in their ancestral homeland.
And to everyone who considers themselves an authority on the Middle East simply because they have watched a few videos, read some social media posts and memorized a handful of fashionable slogans, I have one piece of advice: shut up long enough to actually learn something.
Knowledge requires effort. Integrity requires courage. Morality requires consistency. Joining the loudest crowd requires absolutely nothing.
Before you appoint yourself judge, jury and executioner of the Jewish state, ask yourself one fundamental question.
Who the hell do you think you are?

