You shall not steal
(Screen capture/X)
A recent report in the ToI describes an incident that, on its face, would disgust any fair-minded person. I say “on its face” because the story is based on a video and narrative presented by Arab media in only one X post and, as far as I know, there has been no independent confirmation of the content of that post.
But this is what the ToI reports: The video shows what seem to be five Israeli settlers in the village of Fandaqumiya (which is located in Judea&Samaria/the West Bank/the Disputed Territories) very calmly taking boxes of fruits and vegetables from the stand of an Arab merchant and loading them into the back of a pick-up truck, and then driving off without paying. Put bluntly, the video seems to show Israeli settlers stealing from an Arab food-vendor.
Since October 7, 2023, we have seen a multitude of harrowing images–images of flattened residential buildings in Gaza and mass burials of Palestinians, undoubtedly including infants and young children. But those who understand the enemy confronting Israel understand that the ones who are primarily responsible for death and destruction in Gaza are Hamas terrorists and their supporters.
Israeli bombs do destroy civilian infrastructure and kill civilians. But a fair-minded person realizes that the fundamental war crime is committed by the terrorists, who hide within and underneath civilian infrastructure and among civilians, and thus give Israel no reasonable option other than creating substantial collateral damage (a wretched phrase) while legitimately attacking enemy combatants. I have written about this here and here.
It is the cowardly tactics of Hamas–tactics that sacrifice Palestinian civilians to protect Palestinian terrorists–that are responsible for the death and destruction we see in Gaza. The I.D.F. does not intentionally, deliberately kill Palestinian civilians. Hamas intentionally, deliberately uses Palestinian civilians to shield Hamas terrorists, and this tactic is a violation of the most fundamental law of war: combatants must not put civilians at risk to protect themselves.
In my eyes, the video of what seems to be a relatively everyday, nonviolent crime–the crime of stealing boxes of fruits and vegetables from an Arab vendor–depicts something that is even more upsetting than flattened buildings and mass funerals. It is more upsetting because there is no possible justification for such behavior, and the very calm and brazen demeanor of the thieves indicates quite clearly that they believe there will be no investigation of, and no punishment for, their crime. Not one of the Israelis seems to be wearing a mask.
Again, I only can know what I see in the video, but I would guess the Israelis who are shown hauling off unpaid-for fruit and vegetables think of themselves as extremely pious, observant, orthodox Jews. They probably believe that they are settling the land G-d gave exclusively to the Israelites, and thus are fulfilling a sacred mission. And I would be willing to bet that they judge non-observant Jews, such as myself, not to be real Jews at all.
Yet even non-observant Jews know that, when the Ten Commandments were handed down to Moses on Mount Sinai, the eighth commandment was: You shall not steal.
The commandment was not: You shall not steal from another Israelite, but you are permitted to steal from a non-Israelite.
And it was not even: You shall not steal from another Israelite, but you are permitted to steal from a non-Israelite who is living in the land of Israel.
It was very plainly and simply: You shall not steal.
I would submit that, if (and I emphasize that if) the video depicts what it seems to depict, those five Israeli settlers have stained and disgraced both Judaism and the modern State of Israel. If so-called “pious” Jews believe that, consistent with Jewish law, they can steal fruit and vegetables from an Arab vendor, they ought to take a look at the Ten Commandments and focus on the one dealing with theft. A person does not have to spend years studying Torah and Talmud to understand what “You shall not steal” means.
And it is, moreover, disgraceful that the State of Israel is so derelict in its duty to punish theft that the five settlers apparently have no worry whatsoever that they will be tried or punished for their brazen, unlawful behavior. The video shows them to be calm and even smug as they steal what belongs to an Arab, and they make no attempt to conceal their identity.
The relevant Israeli legal authorities must promptly and vigorously investigate the entire incident. Israel has a responsibility to protect the property of both citizens and non-citizens, and both Jews and Arabs, wherever Israel exercises legal authority.
All of us who want to see Israel thrive and prosper should be appalled by the video, which for anti-Zionists will be evidence that “proves” that Israel maintains an “apartheid” regime. The behavior seemingly depicted in the video is more ammunition for those who wish only to harm Israel.
Supporters of Israel can properly refute accusations grounded on pictures of bombed buildings and mass funerals, because Hamas, with its tactic of hiding among and beneath civilians and civilian infrastructure, is primarily responsible for all that death and destruction. But when Israelis steal from Arabs with apparent immunity, there is no refutation.
