Aimez-vous the Brahms Requiem?
The thought that thinking intellectual thoughts
can’t be expressive
is just as false as thinking that religious ones
can’t be progressive.
Both of these fallacies are put to bed by the great
Requiem of Brahms
in which he intellectually the charms of
death embalms,
inspiring listeners as does the kaddish prayer recited for
our dear departed,
not mentioning death while feeling upbeat about God, not made
by death downhearted.
This poem was inspired by the pianist Paul Lewis, whom David Allen quotes in an article in the New York Times entitled “There’s Nothing Quite as Distressing as This Piece.” Picking his favorite page of Brahms’s late solos, a work he describes as reflecting “abject anguish,” the distinguished pianist says:
There’s this tendency to think that things that are intellectual are not that expressive. I think Brahms puts that argument to bed.
Aimez-vous Brahms? by Françoise Sagan was a best-selling novel published in 1959 and translated into English in 1960. It was made into a 1961 film titled “Goodbye Again’ with stars Ingrid Bergman and Anthony Perkins.