Mara Riegel

America’s Newest Red Scare: AIPAC

American history has long been riddled with boogeymen and fearmongers. Joseph McCarthy gave us the Red Scare on a national stage, villainizing Americans who disagreed with him as communists. Even further back, the Salem Witch Trials scapegoated women who dared to have even a tinge of independence as agents of the devil. 

In 2026, America is dressing up AIPAC to take center stage as yet another scapegoat. When I sit behind my desk in college classrooms, I spend many days hearing nothing but how un-American the “Israel lobby” and AIPAC are, and how Israel has supposedly bought the US Congress. 

The reality of things is that this simply is untrue. There are fundamentally two points at play here: that congressional support for Israel is entirely a product of AIPAC’s lobbying power, and that if not for this, anti-Zionist policies would dominate American political culture.

To understand this entire debate, one must first understand what AIPAC is. AIPAC, or the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, is a US advocacy group that argues for a strong US-Israel relationship, and that often advocates for Jewish-Americans. It is funded by American citizens with a vested interest in these two issues.

Let’s first discuss the idea that AIPAC can buy members of Congress and in turn their votes. In 2026, the House of Representatives voted on the Massie Amendment, which would cut over $3 billion in funding to Israel. Of the 104 votes in favor of this amendment, 48 of them have attempted to receive AIPAC support since 2022, 15 of whom are officially endorsed by the group. That is 46% of the anti-Israel vote having ties to the pro-Israel group. Roughly 65% of Congress received AIPAC money in the 2024 election cycle, but 72% of members voted in favor of Israel on the Massie Amendment, a seven percent discrepancy. 

On a House bill called H.R. 7006, a bill that approved national security funding including appropriations for Israel, 78% of members voted in a way that supported Israel. That same bill was introduced by Rep. Tom Cole, who has taken $0 in AIPAC-affiliated funding in the 2026 election cycle. On S.J.Res. 26, the Senate voted 83-15 against restricting arms sales to Israel, an overwhelming majority. 

To make the claim that AIPAC is the reason that members vote the way that they do on Israel and that the money itself is the cause, you’d expect votes supportive of Israel to occur at the same rate that members receive AIPAC funding, 65% percent or so. However, what the numbers show is that members can vote against Israel while still receiving AIPAC support, and they can vote for it while relinquishing any potential financial incentives. Logically speaking, there must be an alternate explanation other than just financial support for why some members vote the way they do.

To proponents of the idea that AIPAC is the only thing standing between Congress and an anti-Zionist anti-Israel point of view, the idea that members having their own reasons for supporting Israel is simply inconceivable. The conception is that people only support Jews and Israelis because we have the “Israel lobby’s” money to entice them. This line of thinking harkens back to one of the most common antisemitic tropes in history: the idea that Jews hold all of their power through money. This idea is not only farcical, but it is exceptionally conspiratorial. 

It can’t just be that members support Israel because it is the only democratic country in the Middle East, or that it has significantly more tolerant social conditions for a swath of diverse communities, or that they are one of the strongest American allies in the region. 

With this specific issue, the public unequally assumes that support of Israel also means supporting every policy the Netanyahu government implements, independent of potential changes in leadership or circumstance. Just as you can support the idea of a German government while hating the Alternative for Germany Party (AfD), you should be able to support the idea of an Israeli state and its survival without aligning with the policies of the current leadership.

Shifting back to the “Israel lobby,” according to OpenSecrets’ reporting, Israel has not even been in the top 10 for countries that spend the most lobbying the American government for the last six years. From even the last decade, there are still nine other countries spending more than Israel in lobbying costs, including South Korea, Liberia, and Japan. Yet no one talks about the South Korea lobby or attacks Japanese people for their involvement in foreign politics. The rage toward pro-Israel lobbying is overly selective and inappropriate without commensurate criticism of every other lobbying country.

The outrage America is seeing in 2026 regarding AIPAC is performative activism for the Palestinian cause at best, and antisemitic at worst. If money in politics is distasteful to you, there are many Jews, including myself, who would gladly cosign that argument and help to regulate PAC spending on elections. Going forward, AIPAC themselves have even pledged that they will no longer be spending money on campaign contributions. However, if you are only enraged by the money coming from Jews and their allies to support policy interests regarding the only Jewish state, your anger is religiously selective, and that is the most distasteful thing of all.

Mara Riegel is the Director of Political Affairs at the George Washington University’s chapter of Jewish on Campus, and a fellow with the Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting and Analysis (CAMERA). She is also an intern in the US House of Representatives. Opinions expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of CAMERA.

About the Author
Mara Riegel is a senior at the George Washington University studying political science. She is also a fellow with CAMERA, on top of working in Democratic politics.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.