Melanie Phillips’s Krav Maga for the Mind
The most telling conclusion to a London debate on multiculturalism did not come from the stage. It was available for purchase after the event. It was 160 pages long and bore the provocative title Fighting the Hate: A Handbook for Jews Under Siege. In societies that have made tolerance and diversity among their most cherished values, Melanie Phillips has felt compelled to write a self-defense manual for Jews. It is difficult to imagine a more bitter counterpoint to a discussion about the state of the modern West.
On Tuesday evening, November 17, I attended a debate at London’s Emmanuel Centre, organized by the British weekly The Spectator. The question posed to the participants was deliberately provocative: Has multiculturalism failed? On one side stood former Home Secretary Suella Braverman and journalist Melanie Phillips. Opposing them were journalists John Kampfner and Sarfraz Manzoor. The discussion was moderated by the charismatic Michael Gove, a veteran of several Conservative governments and now editor-in-chief of The Spectator.
It was a fascinating exchange about the limits of tolerance, integration and the values that should bind modern societies together. I was particularly struck by Phillips. She argued with remarkable clarity, consistency and conviction. Her assessment of Western multiculturalism is uncompromising, and certainly not everyone would agree with it. Yet what interested me most was something that extended beyond the debate itself.
On the train journey from London back to Amsterdam, where I live, I quite literally devoured Phillips’s latest book. What began as a continuation of the evening’s intellectual debate quickly turned into something more personal. As the train carried me home, I found myself reflecting not only on the arguments I had heard in London, but also on the unsettling reality that had made such a book necessary in the first place.
Published in March 2026 by Wicked Son, Fighting the Hate: A Handbook for Jews Under Siege is neither another historical treatise on antisemitism nor merely an indictment of Western elites. It offers something far more practical. It explains how to respond to anti-Jewish hostility, challenge aggressive accusations, preserve one’s dignity and recognize situations in which personal safety matters more than winning an argument.
Of course, the very need for such a book does not settle the debate over whether multiculturalism has succeeded or failed. It does, however, expose a troubling gap between ideals and reality. Western democracies have spent decades teaching their citizens to respect diversity, yet some of their Jewish citizens must now learn how to cope with hostility directed at them because of their background and religion.
And this is precisely where the book’s greatest value lies. Phillips does not simply ask why antisemitism is gaining ground. She attempts to answer a far more immediate question: What should we do when we come face to face with it?
From Londonistan to a Self-Defense Manual
For more than three decades, Melanie Phillips has been one of the most outspoken voices in British public debate. A journalist, political commentator and author, she has consistently defended traditional values in arguments about culture, religion and Western identity. Her work appears in The Times, the Jewish News Syndicate and The Jewish Chronicle, among other publications.
Her books include the 2006 bestseller Londonistan, in which she criticized the British establishment’s response to Islamist extremism, and The World Turned Upside Down (2010), which examined conflicts over religion, truth and power. In her memoir Guardian Angel, first published in 2013, she explored, among other things, her own ideological evolution. Five years later, she published her first novel, The Legacy, dealing with Jewish identity, antisemitism and the enduring influence of history on individual lives.
In 2025, she published The Builder’s Stone, offering her interpretation of the role played by Judaism and Christianity in shaping Western civilization. Her latest book is therefore a natural continuation of her longstanding intellectual interests. Yet it differs significantly from her previous works. Rather than another extensive political analysis, Phillips offers a practical guide designed to help readers regain confidence when confronted with antisemitism.
The starting point is the experience of Jews living outside Israel following October 7, 2023, when Hamas terrorists and members of other Palestinian armed groups launched a large-scale attack on Israel, killing many civilians. The subsequent war in Gaza generated enormous political and social tensions, including in Europe and the United States.
Phillips draws attention to a disturbing phenomenon: Jews are sometimes held responsible for the actions of the State of Israel, even when they have nothing whatsoever to do with those decisions. A Jewish student is expected to explain the conduct of the Israeli military. A Jewish employee is blamed for the policies of the government in Jerusalem. Longstanding friendships collapse over the conflict in the Middle East.
These concerns are set against a documented rise in antisemitic incidents. According to Britain’s Community Security Trust, 1,926 antisemitic incidents were recorded in the United Kingdom during the first half of 2026, an increase of 21 percent compared with the same period the previous year. These included 135 assaults and one additional incident classified as extreme violence.
During meetings with Jewish communities in Britain, the United States and Australia, Phillips heard many similar stories. As she described in The Jewish Chronicle, what struck her was not only the scale of hostility but also the helplessness of those confronted by it.
One Australian businesswoman told her that, during a business discussion, another woman suddenly accused her of killing children. She had no idea how to respond. Should she end the meeting, challenge the accusation or simply ignore it?
Experiences like these inspired Phillips to write her book.
How Should You Respond When Someone Attacks You?
This is the most interesting and practical part of the publication. Phillips starts from a simple observation: Most people are not professional debaters. They do not know every detail of Middle Eastern history, nor can they instantly produce a convincing response to an aggressive accusation, particularly when caught off guard at work, during a family dinner or on a university campus.
The author therefore proposes what might be described as intellectual self-defense training. Her advice can be distilled into four particularly useful principles.
The first is to remain calm. Anger, outrage and hurt are natural responses to antisemitic remarks. An emotional reaction, however, often merely escalates the confrontation. Phillips encourages readers to prepare calm, factual arguments rather than respond in the heat of the moment.
Equally important is refusing to accept the role of the accused. If someone holds a Jew responsible for the actions of the Israeli government, there is no obligation to launch into a lengthy defense of Israeli policy. One can simply ask why the other person believes that an individual should be personally accountable for decisions made by a state of which they may not even be a citizen. Instead of defending ourselves against an accusation, we can challenge the assumption on which it rests.
Phillips also recommends occasionally reversing the direction of the conversation. An aggressive claim can be met with a question or an unexpected argument that encourages the other person to reconsider their position. The aim need not always be to persuade an opponent. Sometimes it is enough to interrupt an established pattern of thinking.
Finally, not every battle needs to be fought. There is a fundamental difference between an unpleasant conversation and a situation involving a genuine threat to personal safety. When intimidation or violence is involved, protecting one’s health and life matters more than winning an argument. Sometimes the appropriate response is to walk away, report the incident or seek help.
In this sense, the book is not a call for constant confrontation. It is a guide to choosing one’s response wisely and developing psychological resilience.
Krav Maga for the Mind
Fighting the Hate is certainly not an ideologically neutral handbook. Phillips has long been one of Britain’s most prominent conservative commentators. She believes that the rise of antisemitism is not merely a consequence of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict but also reflects a deeper moral crisis in Western societies.
In her view, some political and intellectual circles that proclaim their commitment to human rights, tolerance and the protection of minorities fail to apply those same principles consistently to Jews. She is particularly critical of contemporary anti-Zionism, which she regards as one of the most significant expressions of antisemitism.
Phillips has found a particularly striking metaphor for her book. In an article published in The Jewish Chronicle, she described it as “krav maga for the mind.”
Krav maga, the Israeli system of self-defense, is designed to prepare people to respond effectively to threats. Its purpose is not to stage impressive duels but to develop instincts that help individuals regain control in dangerous situations.
Phillips wants her handbook to serve a similar purpose. Instead of physical exercises, it offers intellectual and psychological preparation. It teaches readers to recognize manipulation, challenge false accusations, and remain composed in the face of hostility.
Of course, rational arguments will not persuade every antisemite. But the impossibility of convincing an opponent does not mean that one should abandon the defense of one’s own dignity. Moreover, the person making the accusation is not always the most important audience. Sometimes the real audience consists of bystanders who, perhaps for the first time, hear a calm and reasoned challenge to an antisemitic stereotype.
That is why Fighting the Hate should not be seen as a book exclusively for Jews. Its recommendations may also prove valuable to teachers, journalists, academics and anyone wishing to respond more effectively to expressions of hatred.
This brings me back to the London debate about multiculturalism. One of its most intriguing features was that people on opposing sides of the argument had personal histories that themselves reflected the diversity of modern Britain. Yet they drew markedly different conclusions from those experiences.
This does not, of course, mean that multiculturalism itself causes antisemitism. Nevertheless, placing these two subjects side by side raises an important question about whether societies that celebrate diversity are equally capable of protecting the rights and security of all their minorities.
When I left London’s Emmanuel Centre, I did not have a definitive answer to the question of whether multiculturalism had failed. Nor should one expect such a complex issue to be resolved in a single evening’s debate.
But I was left with another, perhaps more important question: What does it say about the state of Western democracies that Jews once again need a handbook on how to defend themselves against hatred?
It is a good thing that Melanie Phillips has written one. It would be better still to live in a world where such a book was no longer necessary.

