Apartheid: A Misapplied Label
There is a remarkable contradiction in the international campaign against Israel. Countries, organizations, politicians, and activists who loudly proclaim their opposition to apartheid routinely brand Israel an apartheid state. Yet many of those same voices display little interest in the systematic discrimination, exclusion, and persecution of Jews and Christians in various Arab and Muslim-majority countries.
If opposition to apartheid is truly a matter of principle, shouldn’t that principle apply universally? Or does it apply only when Israel is the accused?
Consider the contrast between two of the world’s holiest religious sites. The Western Wall, or Kotel, Judaism’s holiest accessible site, is open to visitors of every religion and nationality. One need not be Jewish to stand before it, pray, or experience its religious and historical significance.
Now consider Mecca, Islam’s holiest city. Non-Muslims are prohibited from entering Mecca and therefore cannot visit the Kaaba or participate in the Hajj pilgrimage.
I am not suggesting that Muslims should abandon the religious requirements governing access to their holy places. But consider the irony: Israel is routinely accused of religious exclusion despite the accessibility of the Kotel to people of all faiths, while restrictions surrounding Islam’s holiest city attract nothing approaching the international condemnation directed at Israel.
The contrast extends beyond religious access.
Approximately 20 percent of Israel’s population is Arab. Arab citizens, overwhelmingly Muslim and Christian, possess Israeli citizenship, vote in national elections, elect representatives to the Knesset, and serve as judges, physicians, university professors, diplomats, and public officials. They participate in every aspect of Israeli civic life.
Granted, Arab citizens have legitimate grievances involving housing, economic opportunities, public investment, and other disparities. Those shortcomings deserve scrutiny and correction, just as similar inequalities do in the United States and other Western democracies. But unequal outcomes, by themselves, are not proof of apartheid. If they were, would we also characterize the United States, France, England, Germany, and Spain as apartheid states because economic and social disparities exist within their societies, along racial and ethnic lines?
Now consider the historical treatment of Jews in the Arab and Muslim world.
For centuries, Jews living under various Muslim rulers were classified as dhimmis—non-Muslims afforded a degree of communal protection but relegated to a legally subordinate position. Although they could practice their religion under certain conditions, they did not enjoy equal legal and social standing with Muslims. The system involved special taxes and, in different periods and places, restrictions on religious expression, communal institutions, buildings, and other aspects of Jewish life.
The twentieth century brought an even more devastating chapter for Jews. Following the establishment of Israel in 1948, approximately 850,000 Jews left or were driven from Arab countries and other Middle Eastern and North African communities. Many were expelled or forced to flee, losing their homes, businesses, property, and ancestral communities. In several countries, persecution, confiscation, and legal restrictions made continued Jewish life increasingly impossible.
They did not all support the establishment of a Jewish state. Their common identity was that they were Jews. Yet their collective displacement and dispossession generated remarkably little international attention or condemnation.
Today, historic Jewish communities in countries such as Iraq, Yemen, Syria, and Egypt have been reduced to a fraction of their former size, in some cases virtually disappearing.
What should we call a world in which Jews are driven from lands where their families lived for centuries, their property is confiscated, and their communities are effectively erased? History offers a disturbing pattern. Jews were expelled from England in 1290, from Spain in 1492, and from Portugal in 1497. They were welcomed into various European countries at different times, only to face renewed restrictions, expulsions, pogroms, and persecution when political winds shifted. In the twentieth century, Nazi Germany and its collaborators turned that history of exclusion into genocide. More recently, following Israel’s establishment in 1948, approximately 850,000 Jews left or were forced from Arab and other Middle Eastern and North African countries, many losing their homes, businesses, and ancestral communities.
The lesson is unmistakable: Jews may be welcomed by host countries, but that welcome has often proved conditional and temporary. Without a sovereign homeland of their own, they remain vulnerable to the whims of governments and the prejudices of societies in which they live. Yet even with Israel as their national homeland, much of the world challenges their right to it. The historical circumstances differ, but the recurring pattern of exclusion, dispossession, and expulsion evokes the chilling prospect of a Judenrein world—a world without Jews.
The experiences of Christians in several Muslim-majority countries also deserve attention. Like Jews, Christians have frequently been treated as religious outsiders and subjected to discrimination and persecution. Depending on the country and period, they have faced restrictions on worship, church construction, conversion, religious expression, and participation in public life. Some have endured mob violence, intimidation, forced displacement, and attacks on their churches.
Yet where are the international campaigns, university demonstrations, academic condemnations, media attention, resolutions, and diplomatic boycotts demanding that these governments be held to the standards so frequently invoked against Israel?
Too often, the apartheid accusation is deployed less as a consistent human-rights standard than as a political weapon to delegitimize Israel. If the concern is equal rights, examine equal rights everywhere. If the concern is religious freedom, defend it everywhere. And if the concern is protecting minorities, include Jews and Christians whose religious identities have made them vulnerable to persecution.
Israel’s Arab citizens must also be distinguished from Palestinian Arabs living in Judea and Samaria, whose legal and political circumstances are fundamentally different. The latter situation is further complicated by the policies of neighboring Arab governments, which have failed to integrate Palestinian Arab refugees and have denied them citizenship and equal rights for generations.
Why, then, is Israel held solely responsible for a refugee situation that neighboring countries have also helped perpetuate? An honest discussion must examine the responsibilities and policies of all parties, not selectively assign blame to Israel.
This brings us to a larger question: Why is Israel, the world’s only Jewish-majority state, so frequently singled out for condemnation at a level not consistently applied to other nations?
There are approximately 50 Muslim-majority countries and more than 120 Christian-majority countries and territories. There is just one Jewish-majority country: Israel.
The historical persecution and near disappearance of Jewish communities throughout much of the Arab world rarely receive the attention devoted to accusations against Israel. When the rights of Jews and Christians are overlooked while Israel is portrayed as uniquely oppressive, the inconsistency demands an explanation.
And when Israel is judged by standards that its critics do not consistently apply to other countries, while its very legitimacy as a Jewish state is challenged, we are no longer discussing an ordinary disagreement over government policy. We are confronting a much deeper question about the nature of the hostility directed at Israel.
Consider the slogans emblazoned on demonstrators’ posters: “From the River to the Sea” and “Go Back to Poland.”
The first is widely understood as a demand for a territory without Israel as a sovereign Jewish state. The second tells Jews to return to a country where six million Jews were murdered during the Holocaust.
What exactly are these slogans demanding? When opposition to Israel is expressed in language that denies Jews their national home and tells them to leave, it goes beyond criticism of Israeli government policies. It challenges the Jewish people’s right to national self-determination in their ancestral homeland.
If apartheid is wrong, it is wrong everywhere. If religious persecution is wrong, it is wrong regardless of who the victims or perpetrators happen to be.
Anything less is not a principled defense of human rights. It is selective indignation.
And when that indignation consistently singles out the Jewish state while denying the Jewish people the right to their own homeland, we must ask whether the issue is really apartheid—or something much older and more deeply ingrained: an enduring antisemitism that has infected societies and civilizations for millennia. Its roots reach back to the time of the biblical Abraham, whose introduction of monotheism and a moral code challenged the pagan world around him.
Sadly, today we are witnessing a form of historical entropy: a regression toward primitive prejudices, intolerance, and moral chaos. It is as though civilizations that once embraced the moral principles Abraham introduced are abandoning them, reverting to the very chaos and darkness those principles sought to dispel.
