Bepi Pezzulli
Solicitor & foreign policy adviser

Italy passes antisemitism law, the Left votes no

Photo by David Köhler on Unsplash

There was a time when the Italian Left regarded opposition to antisemitism as a moral obligation. Apparently, it now requires a parliamentary debate, several amendments and a vote against.

On November 17, Italy’s Chamber of Deputies gave final approval to legislation combating antisemitism, with 147 votes in favor, 93 against and five abstentions. The measure, already approved by the Senate in March, was carried by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s governing coalition with support from centrist parties, including Matteo Renzi’s Italia Viva. Its central provision adopts the working definition of antisemitism developed by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA), including its eleven illustrative examples.  The legislation establishes a three-year national strategy, strengthens the coordination and monitoring of antisemitic incidents, and provides public institutions with a common framework for identifying contemporary anti-Jewish prejudice. It also addresses education, prevention and the institutional response to antisemitism.

The government deserves recognition for confronting a problem that has become increasingly difficult to discuss without encountering the ideological sensitivities surrounding Israel. The law acknowledges that antisemitism has evolved beyond the familiar expressions of racial prejudice, religious hostility and Holocaust denial. It can also appear in political campaigns against Jewish national identity and Israel’s right to exist. The parliamentary opposition was revealing. The Democratic Party, the Five Star Movement and the Green-Left Alliance voted against the legislation. A handful of Democrats refused to follow their party’s direction and abstained. The rebellion exposed a fracture between the Democratic Party’s traditional reformist wing and the increasingly anti-Israel orientation of the broader left-wing coalition.

The law’s implications are substantial. The IHRA framework identifies circumstances in which ostensibly political statements about Israel may constitute antisemitism, including the denial of Jewish self-determination, discriminatory double standards, Nazi comparisons and the attribution of collective responsibility to Jews for Israeli government actions. Context remains essential, and the law expressly preserves constitutional freedoms of political criticism and expression. It creates no new autonomous criminal offence. Its importance is therefore principally institutional and cultural. Italian authorities now have a statutory reference for confronting forms of antisemitism that have too often escaped scrutiny because they were expressed in the language of international politics. Universities, public administrations and educational institutions will have to consider the relationship between anti-Jewish prejudice and anti-Israel activism with greater consistency.

The urgency is supported by evidence. According to the Centre for Contemporary Jewish Documentation, Italy recorded 963 antisemitic incidents in 2025, compared with 241 in 2022. The increase has accompanied a political atmosphere in which Jewish citizens have increasingly reported hostility associated with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Italy’s predicament, however, has deeper ideological roots. Italian anti-Zionism did not begin on October 7, 2023. It has a long political genealogy, reaching back to the Cold War, when important sections of the Communist left adopted the Soviet interpretation of Zionism as an expression of imperialism. That interpretation subsequently merged with Third Worldism, revolutionary anti-colonialism and the romanticization of Palestinian terrorism.

The Palestinian cause became a fixture of the Italian radical imagination. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict was increasingly interpreted through a rigid political division between oppressor and oppressed, with Israel cast as an outpost of Western capitalism and Palestinians as representatives of anti-imperialist resistance.

This ideological inheritance survived the collapse of the Soviet Union and the transformation of the Italian Communist Party. It migrated into university politics, trade-union activism, radical Catholic networks, sections of the peace movement and the contemporary progressive Left. Palestinianism became a durable political identity, capable of uniting constituencies otherwise divided by economic, religious and cultural differences. The Gaza war intensified these tendencies and brought them into the political mainstream. Pro-Palestinian mobilization acquired exceptional visibility, while campaigns for boycotts, academic disengagement and the exclusion of Israeli institutions found sympathetic audiences across segments of Italian civil society.

The intellectual problem lies in the relationship between this political tradition and the principle of national self-determination. Zionism is the Jewish national movement, grounded in the proposition that Jews constitute a people entitled to exercise self-determination in their historical homeland. Israel is the institutional expression of that right. Its legitimacy is independent of the political orientation of its government, just as the legitimacy of other states does not depend on the conduct of their elected administrations.

There is a serious contradiction in defending national liberation as a universal entitlement while treating Jewish sovereignty as uniquely illegitimate. Anti-Zionism becomes particularly troubling when it ceases to criticize Israeli conduct and instead makes the disappearance of the Jewish state its political objective. At that point, the argument concerns the collective rights of the Jewish people rather than the policies of Benjamin Netanyahu or any future Israeli government.

The IHRA definition recognizes this problem. It does not prohibit criticism of Israel; indeed, it explicitly states that criticism comparable to that directed against other countries cannot, in itself, be regarded as antisemitic. It instead identifies the circumstances in which hostility toward Israel may express older forms of anti-Jewish prejudice through a contemporary political vocabulary. That is precisely why the definition has become controversial among sections of the anti-Zionist Left. It challenges the assumption that the language of anti-imperialism automatically places political claims beyond scrutiny for antisemitism.

The vote also illustrates an uncomfortable reversal in Italian political culture. Meloni leads a party whose historical roots include Italy’s post-Fascist Right. Yet her government has now secured legislation aimed at combating contemporary antisemitism, while substantial sections of the Left opposed its defining provision. Historical affiliations do not eliminate contemporary responsibilities, and a movement’s anti-Fascist credentials cannot substitute for examining the implications of its present political positions. The real test will be implementation. Public institutions must protect Jewish citizens and recognize antisemitic hostility without restricting legitimate political disagreement. The government’s achievement is to establish the framework through which that responsibility can be exercised.

For Italy, a country whose twentieth-century history includes the racial laws of 1938, the persecution of Jewish citizens and the deportations of the Holocaust, the issue carries particular gravity. But contemporary antisemitism cannot be confronted exclusively through historical remembrance. It must also be recognized when it adopts the language and causes of the present. Meloni’s government has taken that step. The Left has demonstrated how difficult it has become to achieve a common understanding of antisemitism when Israel is involved.

Italy has finally put contemporary antisemitism into the statute books. The challenge now is to ensure that the law changes more than just the vocabulary of the institutions charged with enforcing it.

About the Author
Giuseppe Levi Pezzulli (“Bepi”) is a corporate counsel, board adviser, and academic with international experience across finance, government, and industry. His research focuses on the use of economic and financial power in foreign policy and national security. His analyses have appeared on CNBC, Rai News, Sky News, Milano Finanza, the NATO Defense College Foundation, The American Banker, The American Thinker, CityAM, The Critic, and Bloomberg terminals. He is the Research Editor at Longitude Magazine. He currently serves as Political Director at Italia Atlantica, as well as a Councillor of the Great British PAC and Britain Unbound.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.