Richard D. Gitlin
An Engineer’s Perspective on Israel and Jewish Life

The Paradox of the Jewish Experience

How does a small people, repeatedly conquered, dispersed, persecuted, and threatened with annihilation, survive for thousands of years, while the mighty empires that once ruled them and their land disappear?

And how does that same people, with only 0.2% of the world’s population, after nearly two millennia without sovereignty in its ancestral homeland, reestablish a nation that becomes a world leader in science, finance, technology, medicine, defense, the arts, and innovation?

More than a century ago, Mark Twain posed much the same puzzle in his 1899 essay Concerning the Jews: “All things are mortal but the Jew; all other forces pass, but he remains.” Twain asked, “What is the secret of his immortality?” His question captures the mystery of survival. The further question is how that survival helped make extraordinary achievement possible.

Yet survival and achievement are two different accomplishments. Survival is endurance against destruction. Achievement is the proactive creation of knowledge, institutions, discoveries, and contributions that benefit humanity. The Jewish people have done both.

I am not a rabbi or a scholar of Judaism. I am simply an American Jew who has watched with admiration, and sometimes astonishment, the extraordinary achievements of the Jewish people and the State of Israel. Throughout my professional life as an engineer, I have been fascinated by how innovations emerge and how institutions create the foundations for future advances.

The remarkable survival of the Jewish people has fascinated historians and Jewish thinkers for generations. Nahum Goldmann’s The Jewish Paradox explored the relationship between Israel and the Diaspora, while Robert Mnookin’s The Jewish American Paradox examined the challenges of Jewish identity and continuity in America. My question is different. How did institutions evolve within Judaism that not only enabled Jewish survival but also helped make extraordinary achievements possible? I believe my engineering experience offers a useful perspective on that question.

The connection between Jewish survival and achievement lies, at least in part, in Judaism’s extraordinary capacity for institutional adaptability and reinvention. Over centuries, Jewish civilization evolved into an institutional architecture that preserved its identity while allowing its institutions to adapt to changing circumstances. This architecture was not the product of a grand design. It emerged as successive generations responded to religious obligations, historical challenges, and changing opportunities. Individual institutions were often deliberately created, but their combined capacity to support later achievements was largely unforeseen.

Survival Without Sovereignty

The Assyrian, Babylonian, Persian, Greek, and Roman empires, along with the Crusader kingdoms, exercised enormous political and military power. Their imperial structures eventually disappeared, even as their peoples and cultural legacies continued. The Jewish people followed a different path.

The Babylonians destroyed the First Temple in 586 BCE and deported many inhabitants of Judah. Jewish identity survived. The Second Temple was rebuilt, but Rome destroyed it in 70 CE. Once again, Jewish life faced a profound challenge. How could a civilization centered on a sacred Temple endure without it?

The answer did not emerge overnight. Before the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE, Jewish religious life included both centralized Temple worship and local synagogues, prayer, study, and varying traditions of interpretation. After the Temple’s destruction, these decentralized institutions became increasingly important. Rabbinic scholarship, the Mishnah, and subsequently the Talmud helped create a religious framework that could function across widely dispersed communities, without dependence on a central Temple or Jewish political sovereignty.

The synagogue, school, family, and community made Jewish life portable. Jews in widely separated places could retain shared texts, practices, historical memory, and communal obligations. None of this prevented persecution, forced conversion, assimilation, or catastrophic losses. But it helped make continuity possible. Across different lands, Jewish communities developed distinct customs and forms of communal organization while continuing to share foundational texts and practices. This combination of continuity and local adaptation became another source of resilience.

Institutions That Created New Capabilities

Judaism did more than preserve beliefs. It made learning and interpretation central to communal life. The Torah provided foundational teachings. Rabbinic literature preserved legal reasoning, competing interpretations, and arguments across generations. Traditions of studying competing interpretations and debating texts also gave intellectual disagreement a recognized place in communal life.

Economists Maristella Botticini and Zvi Eckstein argue that religious education and literacy gave Jews capabilities that later proved valuable in trade, skilled occupations, and networks spanning distant communities. Their book, The Chosen Few, develops this interpretation of Jewish economic history.

As an engineer, I find this especially interesting. Some innovations solve a particular problem. Others create a platform, or architecture, upon which future capabilities can be built. The Jewish emphasis on study was a religious commitment, not a plan to develop future scientists or merchants. Yet the institutions that transmitted knowledge served purposes their founders never anticipated. The importance of education also made knowledge and skills more portable than land or property, an advantage for communities repeatedly exposed to displacement and restrictions on occupations.

Jewish achievement has sometimes been attributed to innate intellectual ability. Whether inherited characteristics contribute to that achievement remains a subject for scientific investigation. What Jewish history clearly demonstrates is the importance of institutions, incentives, education, historical opportunity, and the choices of successive generations.

The Paradox of Preservation and Change

Judaism placed enormous importance on preserving ancient teachings and communal obligations. Yet Jewish continuity repeatedly required change and sometimes reinvention.

The destruction of the Temple accelerated the development of Rabbinic Judaism. Dispersion strengthened institutions that could function across political borders. The Jewish Enlightenment, or Haskalah, emerged in eighteenth-century Germany and spread through much of Europe during the nineteenth century. It encouraged engagement with secular education and European intellectual life while raising difficult questions about preserving Jewish identity. Jewish emancipation was a separate, gradual legal and political process through which European states removed restrictions on Jews and extended civil rights, although progress varied greatly among countries. Together, these changes expanded opportunities in science, medicine, commerce, and the professions.

These changes created new pressures toward assimilation. The very changes that enabled extraordinary individual achievement could weaken some traditional mechanisms of Jewish continuity. Jewish communities responded differently, and often disagreed sharply over what should be preserved and what should change. The same communal boundaries that helped preserve Jewish identity could also reinforce separation from surrounding societies, sometimes increasing vulnerability to prejudice.

The resulting intellectual achievement is striking. As noted earlier, Jewish recipients account for about 22 percent of individual Nobel laureates through 2025, despite Jews representing roughly 0.2 percent of the world’s population.

Israel: From Preservation to Creation

Modern Zionism emerged in the late nineteenth century, building on earlier movements such as Hovevei Zion (Lovers of Zion), which gained momentum following the Russian pogroms of 1881. Theodor Herzl organized the First Zionist Congress in Basel in 1897, giving political Zionism an organized international framework. But institutional development was already underway. During the First Aliyah (1882–1903), approximately 35,000 Jews immigrated to Ottoman Palestine, establishing agricultural settlements and new communities. The Second Aliyah (1904–1914) brought roughly 35,000–40,000 additional immigrants, contributing to the development of the kibbutz movement and the founding of Tel Aviv in 1909. Long before independence in 1948, Jewish immigrants were building the social, economic, educational, and political foundations of a future state.

The scientific foundations of the Start-Up Nation, as Israel is often referred to,  were also being constructed before the State of Israel existed. The Technion began teaching in 1924, the Hebrew University opened in 1925, and Chaim Weizmann founded the Daniel Sieff Research Institute, predecessor of the Weizmann Institute, in 1934.

These institutions did not guarantee future success. But they educated scientists and engineers, developed research capacity, and helped create opportunities that a new state could expand. After independence in 1948, Israel’s universities, defense establishment, entrepreneurs, government research programs, international partners, and investors became parts of an increasingly productive innovation system.

The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) helped train young people to solve demanding technological problems in defending the country, which often led to start-up companies. Government initiatives supported industrial research and venture capital. Entrepreneurs converted technical expertise into companies serving global markets. Immigration brought additional talent and experience.

Israel’s emergence as the Start-Up Nation illustrates the difference between inheriting an intellectual tradition and building modern institutions that turn knowledge into achievement. Dan Senor and Saul Singer tell much of this extraordinary story in Start-Up Nation: The Story of Israel’s Economic Miracle.

The Enduring Power of Reinvention

The survival of the Jewish people across millennia is extraordinary. Their achievements are no less remarkable. But survival and achievement are not the same thing.

Survival means enduring conquest, exile, persecution, and attempts at annihilation. Achievement means going beyond survival to create, discover, build, and contribute to civilization. Salomon L. Vaz Dias has argued that survival alone cannot be the final measure of what Jewish sovereignty should accomplish.

Throughout my engineering career, I have learned that lasting achievements rarely arise from isolated breakthroughs. They depend upon an underlying architecture of ideas, institutions, support systems, partners, and capabilities that makes further innovation possible.

I believe Jewish history reveals something similar. The Covenant that God made with Abraham established a shared identity and moral obligations. The Torah and rabbinic traditions placed learning, law, and ethical responsibility at the center of Jewish life. Synagogues, families, schools, and communities sustained Jewish identity in the diaspora without sovereignty. The Haskalah, the Jewish Enlightenment,  and subsequent emancipation expanded opportunities in the secular world. Zionism and the institutions built before and after 1948 helped turn a national aspiration into a sovereign state and a remarkable center of innovation.

It is tempting to describe Jewish survival and Israel’s rebirth and achievements as miracles. In the emotional and spiritual sense, perhaps they are. But history also reveals an explanation grounded in human institutions and accomplishments.

The foundations were laid over centuries through the religious, intellectual, ethical, and communal traditions of Judaism. These traditions did not guarantee survival or success. They provided resources that successive generations could preserve, reinterpret, and apply to new challenges.

What may appear to be a miracle is also the product of an extraordinary institutional architecture that evolved over millennia. Built on enduring Jewish teachings and values and strengthened by generations of perseverance, inquiry, and adaptation, this architecture helped preserve the Jewish people and made their remarkable contributions to the world possible.

Its greatest strength may be its capacity for continued reinvention. The challenge now is to preserve its essential foundations while having the imagination and courage to build what the future requires.

Author’s Notes

This is the first in a planned series of essays exploring the paradoxes of Jewish history and experience, from the intellectual achievements of the Jewish people to the rebirth of Israel and the emergence of the Start-Up Nation.

I am especially grateful to my daughter, Rachel Gitlin Herman, for her thoughtful review, insightful suggestions, and encouragement. Her understanding of Jewish history and her deep connection to Israel helped sharpen my thinking and improve this essay. She also suggested its title, The Paradox of the Jewish Experience.

In preparing this essay, I used ChatGPT as an intelligent assistant in developing and editing it, including identifying and checking the historical and Jewish sources cited in the text, as well as generating the graphic. The ideas and conclusions are my own.

About the Author
Richard D. Gitlin is an engineer, inventor, co-inventor of DSL, former Bell Labs research executive, and Distinguished University Professor Emeritus at the University of South Florida. Educated at the City College of New York and Columbia University, he is a member of the National Academy of Engineering and recipient of the IEEE Alexander Graham Bell Medal. His career has centered on research, innovation, and the development of transformative communications technologies. A lifelong American Jew and Zionist, since October 7 he has devoted considerable time to studying and writing about Israel, Zionism, antisemitism, and the changing position of Jews in America.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.