Moises Salinas Fleitman
Author, Academic, Peacebuilder and Progressive Zionist Activist

Can you separate Judaism from Zionism?

Lately, an increasing number of prominent Jewish figures have publicly declared that they are Jewish but not Zionists, seeking to distance their Jewish identity from a movement that has become controversial. In my view, this position is often intellectually inconsistent and politically convenient. It attempts to separate Jewish identity from a connection to the Land of Israel that has been central to Jewish religion, history, and collective consciousness for millennia. In my opinion, that is an hypocritical position hoping to distance themselves from a politically inconvenient movement while trying to stay part of the Jewish people. That’s like trying to eat the cake and eat it too. Or rather like claiming Christianity while insisting that Jesus has no meaningful place in Christian tradition.

The idea that Zionism created the Jewish connection to Israel in the 19th century is historically absurd. While political Zionism emerged in the late 1800s, the Jewish people’s religious, historical, and cultural connection to the Land of Israel is thousands of years old. It is a core principle of Jewish peoplehood that is embedded in the foundations of Judaism itself.

Consider what Jewish tradition actually teaches and practices.

Every day, observant Jews pray for the return to Zion. The Amidah, traditionally recited three times daily, asks God to restore Jerusalem and gather the Jewish exiles. For centuries, Jews across the world have prayed facing Jerusalem. Even the biblical Book of Daniel (6:11) describes Daniel praying toward Jerusalem while living in exile.

Every Passover, Jews declare, “Next year in Jerusalem.” The same declaration traditionally concludes Yom Kippur. These words were recited for centuries before Theodor Herzl was born. What exactly do these Jews think we are returning to?

At Jewish weddings, we break a glass to remember Jerusalem’s destruction. Even at a moment of personal happiness, Jewish tradition insists that we remember our historical homeland. This reflects Psalm 137:5: “If I forget you, O Jerusalem, let my right hand forget its skill.”

Our holidays are tied to the land. Passover, Shavuot, and Sukkot originated as pilgrimage festivals associated with Jerusalem and the agricultural cycle of ancient Israel. On Tisha B’Av, Jews mourn the destruction of the Temples and the loss of Jewish sovereignty.

And this connection was never limited to ritual.

In the 12th century, the great Jewish poet and philosopher Judah Halevi wrote, “My heart is in the East, and I am at the farthest West.” His longing for Zion was central to his religious philosophy. The great Jewish philosopher Maimonides, also writing in the 12th century, emphasized the religious importance of living in the Land of Israel (Mishneh Torah, Kings and Wars 5:12), and another Jewish sage, Nachmanides, in the 13th century, went further, arguing that settling the Land of Israel constitutes a positive biblical commandment. In fact, centuries before modern nationalism, the Mishnah (Ketubot 13:11) already recognized the extraordinary religious significance of moving to the Land of Israel and Jerusalem.

This is the crucial distinction: Political Zionism is modern. Jewish attachment to Zion is ancient. Modern Zionism only translated a longstanding religious, historical, and national attachment into a political movement for Jewish self-determination. It did not invent that attachment.

Of course, Jews can – and do – disagree about Zionism, the modern State of Israel, its governments, and its policies.  But those disagreements do not erase the central place of the Land of Israel in Jewish history and religious consciousness. Judaism survived nearly two thousand years of dispersion because Jews maintained their  connection to their ancestral homeland. They built communities throughout the world, but they never removed Jerusalem from their prayers or Zion from their collective memory.

You can disagree with modern Zionism. You can criticize the Israeli government. But claiming that the Jewish connection to Israel is a modern political invention and not necessary to be Jewish requires ignoring the Torah, the Talmud, Jewish liturgy, Jewish philosophy, and centuries of Jewish practice. Judaism existed long before political Zionism. But Judaism without its connection to-and its yearning for – the Land of Israel would probably not have survived 2000 years.

The Jewish connection to Israel is not a political invention. It is one of the foundations of Jewish civilization.  Modern political Zionism is simply a modern expression of an ancient, core principle of Judaism. Claiming the two can be separated is like imagining a without a patty. Technically possible, perhaps, but you’d be missing something rather essential.

About the Author
Dr. Moises Salinas Fleitman is Executive Director of Remember Us The Holocaust and forme Rector (President) of ORT University México. He has a Ph.D. in Educational Psychology and is recipient of the Herzl Award by the World Zionist Organization in 2004. Former president of the Hartford, Connecticut Zionist Federation and president of Partners for Progressive Israel. Author of numerous books and articles including "Planting Hatred, Sowing Pain: The Psychology of the Israeli Palestinian Conflict" (Greenwood/Prager) and "Resolving the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: Perspectives on the Peace Process" (Cambria Press).
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.